Software
Houzz Logo Print
onthebrinck

When is Topsoil simply Dirt?

16 years ago

I found this great nursery near my new home. Great? well, at least they didn't say "huh?" when I said amalanchier. They, in turn, recommended a place nearby for topsoil. I was quite specific when I told the topsoil guys that I wanted to use the soil for raised beds. They actually held the order back until, as they said, the soil dried out from the wettest March on record. When they delivered the 10 yards of soil it looked nice and dark and had that rich 'earthy' smell I usually associate with composting (or, in hindsight, was it herbicide --- hehe). Two days later and in surprising 90 degree heat, I shoveled all 10 yards throughout the gardens into edges and beds. That's when it started turning grey. Now, 6 weeks later the soil is blonde-gray with an abundance of sand. Was there something I should have done differently? I figure that when the annuals die off in October (if they don't die prematurely soon), I'll get about 5 yards of compost/humus whatever and work it in. In the perennial beds, I'll top the beds with the same compost and try to gingerly work it in.

I'm not sure I'll be in need of topsoil again, but what does one look for when buying it, and where in Central NJ is a good place to go?

Comments (18)

  • 16 years ago

    What was your expectation about what this "topsoil" would be?
    I have found that most people expect the "topsoil" they buy to be Loam a specific type of soil not readily available everywhere. Most everywhere "topsoil" is simply the top 4 to 6 inches of soil scraped off someplace that may or may not be worth what you spent on it. Loam is about 25 percent clay, 25 percent silt, 45 percent sand, and about 5 percent organic matter. Most everyone would be much better off spending their money on organic matter, it it is necessary to buy anything, or for your raised beds maybe 1/2 of what was sold as "topsoil" and 1/2 organic matter (compost, leaf mold, etc).
    Most all of the stuff being sold as "topsoil" I have seen is simply dirt and not worth what is charged.

  • 16 years ago

    What he said. Dirt gets moved around when construction is done, and the excess of often sold as "topsoil." But no one is making an effort to be sure that only the top 12 inches of soil is in that pile. To be sure of getting topsoil, you would have to dig it yourself, and then transport it home, yourself. I think that the soil you have in your raised beds will be fine when you are done amending it with compost or leaf mold.

  • 16 years ago

    Re: 'what to look for in future B4 buying'. I would suggest doing that 'shake soil sample in bottle of water' test that kimmsr often details. Wait 1 day and see how the material settles out.

    Apparently this is a common problem, not having much to do with the ethics/standards of the garden center/nursery who supplies the material. By all means, share your experience with this particular nursery, whose staff don't flinch at "amalanchier." They will want to learn from this.

  • 16 years ago

    I'll be making my own leaf mold this year. I had great success at my last house of 'mulch mowing' leaves and then piling them in handmade cribs, alternating between twin bins. This year I might try the garbage bag liner method ... I've got just the place hidden away where I can roll around 30 bags with ease --- keeping them brewing. Betcha' come this time next year, I'll have some nice ripe stuff.

    But what exactly should I look for in compost to compliment the mold ... and WHERE? I need to augment maybe 1,000 square feet of beds. I live in Freehold, Monmouth County, New Jersey. From what I see piled outside Brocks on 9, that's mulch, not organic. Please prevent me from making another mistake --- I don't have that many more years left to waste on failed experiments.

  • 16 years ago

    Any vegetative material is an acceptable, organic, mulch, although some of us think the dyed stuff greatly offends the eye. Even though shredded rubber is "organic" many of us also do not think this is an appropriate use of old, discared, tires because of the potential heavy metal contamination.
    All you need do is add organic matter to the soil you have. To fill raised beds get whatever soil you can get at the least cost with no expectations and then get organic matter to supplement that soil. "Topsoil" is not a magic elixar and neither is "Garden Soil" since either one is simply what ever the person selling it wants it to be.

  • 16 years ago

    I think I received the same type of soil in Ocean County, NJ for my veggie garden. I just keep adding my homemade compost each year and I think it is slowly improving. It does have lots of worms so I am hopeful.

  • 16 years ago

    I need to wait til fall to amend the flower borders of annuals. In the meantime, I'm watering almost daily, and fertilizing weekly. As for the 6' x 100' expanse of new shrubs and perennials I cut into the front lawn, I couldn't stand looking out on that parched desert-like color any longer. Since I can't get any good recommendations for local composters (most people mistake mulch for compost), and since the town chops up everything we put to the curb, I know sure as hell I don't want that in my yard, and since places like Brock's sell black stuff of unknown origin --- I bit the bullet and went to HD and bought Scott's Manure and Humus --- 12 bags. I know you guys might turn your nose up at this stuff (literally and figuratively) --- it is at least the color I want (hehe). I emptied 3 bags on a tarp, mixed in about 5 double handfuls of peat moss to lighten it a bit and mixed it all into a perfect consistency. I loaded it into a wheelbarrow and then threw it by the shovelful onto the raised beds between the plants. I then used a long-tined hand cultivator to get down about 4-5 inches (less, the closer I got to the plants) and mixed it to a consistent color with the 'topsoil'. Finally raked smooth ... creating small depressions around each plant for added water retention. The result is a tri-colored bed --- blonde sand around the edge, milk chocolate as you move toward the center of the bed and finally dark fudge as the bed flattens out. I could immediately see the difference when I watered. The center turned black and has kept that dark color all afternoon in the hot sun! I'll reserve judgement as to my success when I see how the soil retains water and how the plants respond. But at least for the moment, it finally 'looks' like a flower bed.

  • 16 years ago

    Scotts Manure and Humus "Contains: organic materials (peat, composted forest products, aged rice hulls, or compost), composted manure, pelleted poultry litter." So most of what you added to your soil was peat moss. When you buy stuff like this you pay a lot of money for really little of benefit.

  • 16 years ago

    Your soil sounds fine to me. The color of soil means nothing. Topsoil is dirt, and you have to add your own organic matter.

    Almost all dirt is light colored when it is dry. Your soil was dark colored and smelled right when it was delivered, and it contains sand, which is good for drainage.

    I have volcanic soil and it is excellent. Things grow extremely well in it, and it is pale sand colored, even when wet. Color means nothing.

    Daily watering might be too much unless you are in the blistering hot desert. It doesn't matter what the temperature is, plants don't need water until the soil is dry.

    Lots of organic material is available for free: leaves in the fall, coffee grounds from Starbucks or other coffee shops, wood chips from the power company or tree service, ashes from wood stoves, manure from stables, dairies, poultry farms.

    Low cost: alfalfa pellets and wood shavings from the feed store.

    I prefer to not use peat moss except for my blueberries. It retains water for too long and is difficult to re-wet if it gets dry.

  • 16 years ago

    Your dirt sounds find. Topsoil is just the top part of the dirt. The quality of topsoil varies widely depending upon your location. In Illinois, we have drummond some of the best topsoil known for growing things.

    Just keep adding organic matter and mulch well and your soil would be fine.

  • 16 years ago

    Topsoil is what you have on the top 4 to 6 inches of your soil. In a good healthy soil that topsoil will be a rich chocolate brown colot that has a distinctive and pleasant odor, and if you have a good healthy soil you will find large numbers of earthworms active when the soil temperature is above about 45 degrees. That rich chocolate color of good topsoil comes from adding enough organic matter to the soil.
    I have seldom seen and "topsoil" sold in bags or even in bulk that had that good rich earth smell, that many of us get in the spring as the soil warms up and the Soil Food Web becomes active again.

  • 16 years ago

    It's too bad that the term "topsoil" isn't regulated, or at least better-controlled by the nursery and landscaping industry. It seems to be used interchangeably with "clean fill," meaning anything that came out of the ground somewhere that didn't sit under a gas station or toxic waste dump, screened for large rocks. They call it topsoil because that sounds good for marketing, but it's seldom even fertile.

  • 16 years ago

    When is Topsoil simply Dirt? When it's in Ohio.

    In the past I have bought "garden mix" soil, supposed to be soil and compost. I was never convinced that it contained any compost at all, it was crappy stuff. Now if I need soil I buy the cheapest soil I can find and build on that.

    We made new tomato beds last year, bought several scoops of cheap "topsoil" and added that to the beds. For about a month I added OM- coffee grounds from the coffee shop, yard waste, a few kitchen scraps. Every week when the lawn was cut I mixed grass clippings with fall leaves and piled them on, about a foot deep. They'd shrink down some, the next week they got several more inches of stuff. Around late October I mounded it high one more time, topped with leaves, covered with a cotton sheet, and let it sit all winter. The mulch on there is still remaining leaves from then. The soil looks and feels great, and my tomatoes are happy.
    {{gwi:291405}}

    Karen

  • 16 years ago

    When it gets under your finger nails or ground into your clothing, oh yes, when ANY of it gets on the paint job of your new Porsche!

  • 16 years ago

    Most of what I have seen in Ohio is clay, a reddish/yellow coloered clay, although around Lake Erie is a lot of sand similar to what I have. The places I have been in Ohio that sell something called "topsoil" mix some organic matter into the clay which changes the color for the reddish/yelloe to a dark chocolate to black, so, again, what most people buy in Ohio as "topsoil is simply some clay with some organic matter mmixed in. Spend you money on organic matter and mix that into your clay for better results.

  • 16 years ago

    ..
    I got into composting after buying topsoil to cover grass seed. After screening out the rocks and chunks of asphalt, I felt real dumb paying money for dirt. Never again.

    I'm with Kimmsr and the others - get the most organic material as fast as you can into your soil and then you'll have something. Used coffee grounds from starbucks can go directly in or on the ground and worms dig it. Mulch with grass clippings and keep your water bill down while feeding the soil. Of course, make compost.

    to sense
    ..

  • 16 years ago

    Sometimes you need to buy soil... I needed to buy some soil last year to backfill the new driveway that we installed. We changed the grade and didn't have enough in-situ soil for backfill around the edges.

    The misconception is that purchased topsoil is going to be a rich loam sent from heaven. If you don't have that misconception, then you buy the cheapest stuff you can find and amend it. Paying more money for topsoil, doesn't necessarily make it better.

  • 16 years ago

    ..
    Fill dirt for a driveway is one thing. Hell you probably want some rocks and stuff with that.

    When you ask for something for cover and order the 50 percent compost it ought to be better than fill dirt.

    If you want dirt, check out Craigslist. There are lots of people looking to unload free dirt. If you want soil you better start on that organic material.

    to sense
    ..