Software
Houzz Logo Print
scottplumerias

Soil versus Potting Mix

19 years ago

We are trying to figure out more about our mixes on a Plumeria forum.

I have a general question I thought you guys might be able to help me/us with: how can things grow in the ground in such poor soil, clays and the like, while in pots, we have to be so careful about drainage and water retention.

What am I missing here?

I saw someone mention that soil is a very complex system and when it is brought into a pot, it is held hostage and doesn't act the same way. I understand this, but there seems to be something I am missing also. I look at my Maple trees and the soil is much more compact than in my pots. But the trees do fine. So do the bushes. I don't need perlite for my bushes or for my trees. Well, I know I need to break up the soil and amend it when I plant them, but after that they seem to be ok.

I would be grateful for any insights/links on this.

Thanks

Scott

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    My *guess* is that in the ground, you have two factors that can't be replicated in a pot.

    The main one is a sort of "buffering" capacity for moisture. In the ground, the water can diffuse from throughout your yard (and further) .... so overwatering or underwatering is less of a concern. In a pot, you might see more drastic swings in moisture.

    The main reason I think moisture would be a problem though, is because it will affect the microbes growing around the roots, etc. In a pot, an excess of water might promote some fungus or something to grow, and this could be bad news for the plant. In the ground, you would have difficulty getting that level of moisture, because it is buffered by such a large land area.

    The second idea is similar, but has to do with nutrients. Once a nutrient is used up in a pot, it's gone.

    0.02.
    Patty

  • 19 years ago

    The main two issues with roots in pots are:

    1 Water in soil does not move from one texture layer to another until the first layer is completely saturated. What this means is that, if you have a layer of sandy (or clay) soil on top of a layer of clayey (or sandy) soil, the water in the top layer will not drain into the lower layer until the top layer is saturated. In the ground this is usually not a problem because there's plenty of room for the water to spread out in and the plant roots too, they can still get air somewhere. In a pot however the area of interest is much much smaller, and the roots are confined in that small area, and the whole pot volume may have to be completely saturated before anything will drain out the drain hole, which acts as the lower layer of different texture in this case. this is why my plant pathology professor way back in undergrad school insisted that we not use gravel or rock in the bottom of pots to increase drainage, because it makes drainage that much worse. The potting soil has to become completely saturated before the water will move into the gravel layer. Even without the gravel layer at the bottom of the pot, the pot bottom and drain hole itself acts as a layer impeding drainage, but now you have only one layer change instead of two. Saturated soil is bad for roots because it eliminates oxygen.

    2 The other issue also has to do with the confined space of a pot, so that any plant root pathogen that gets into the pot has a field day so to speak because there may not be any predators or competitors of the pathogen, and the roots can't grow away from it. Most root pathogens prefer soils that are poorly drained and deficient in oxygen, like pots are more likely to be than open ground. And in the ground, you are more likely to have a complete soil microbial community to keep pathogens in check, plus pockets of better drainage and more air, even in compacted soil.

    It's all a matter of scale. Pots are a very small, confined space and cannot duplicate the variability of the soil.

    Does this help? It's a very good question, and one that is critical to caring for plants properly.

  • 19 years ago

    Everything said is true, so lets construct a system that will work for almost any type of plant in a pot.

    Pot with large water retention saucer or water holding method.
    Fill pot above saucer height with ½ inch size or less volcanic rock. Use hammer to size if necessary.
    Sit root ball on top of this porous rock base then fill around the side with volcanic rock.
    Keep saucer watered constantly.

    Increase potting soil or rock depending on how much water the plant likes.

    I use about 1/16 rock to soil for African violets and ½ rock to soil for jade.

    Forget everything said about what the plant likes in the soil you ain't in the soil no more. Except moisture which you adjust by more or less porus rock.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting