Software
Houzz Logo Print
walksindarkness

Organic Watering

19 years ago

Hi All,

I am posting my water questions here since it directly applies to my composting and soil philosophy. Sorry if these questions have been beaten to death, but I can never get the search function to work right.

1) Roof Rain Runoff, good thing or bad?

I was at my girls' soccer coaches house for a cookout. She does some "green" gardening, and had 2 nifty rain-barrels; which are specifically designed to sit under a gutter downspout. I like this idea, because I dont want to use tap water in my garden (nor compost bins). But much of the web searching I do says that roof runoff should not be used for vegetables, as the roof materials may leach off harmful chemicals (ex. There is LEAD flashing on my chimeny, that has to be a bad thing I would think...). What are you opinions?

2) Where can I get ground water tested, for compatibility with Vegetables? (hopefully for free!)

The reason I ask, is that I have another possible solution. I have a very high water table, and during the rainy months (and spring snowpack melt) my basement sump pumps out dozens of gallons a day. I could pump some of it into the barrels, and use that for my garden. My concern with this is that our neighborhood gets the runoff from the propeties from some other development on some small hills. I am worried that some harmful things like lawn pesticides might carry through the underground aquifer. What are your thoughts on this subject, and what type of testing should I do?

Anyone looking for an economical recycled rain barrel in the Mass area should check out http://www.nerainbarrel.com/

They are about half the price of the ones I see online, but you have to drive to pick them up.

TIA,

Will

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    g'day will,

    can't see any need for testing water unless it is for human consumption.

    litteraly if water is fresh it can be used for vege's, grey water from the home can be used for vege's we have to if we want our gardens to survive this drought and water restrictions.

    if you have a look at the pic's on our 'permacuture essay' page we have pic's of how we set our rain barrels/drum up. because it has no additives ie.,. chlorine or flouride rain water from the roof will be great for all plants, the only restriction may be in areas where pollution is very high.

    len

    Here is a link that might be useful: len's garden page

  • 19 years ago

    It doesn'r rain much in California so when we finally get a rain the water coming off the roof is muddy from all the dust that had accumulated on the roof. I have an asphalt shingle roof and even after waiting for the roof to be washed off by several hours of rainfall the water still had a terrible taste to it. I wouldn't use it for human consumption. In fact the guy across the streets dog was killed after being poisoned by rainwater that happened to drip off the roof into its water bowl. He had a treated cedar shake roof.

  • 19 years ago

    How old is your house that you still have lead flashing around the chimney? That has not been used it somewhere around 30 years. The first rainwater off the roof, according to some sources, should not be used because of potential pollution, all the rotten stuff in the air falls on your roof and that first rain washes it off. Of course that those that tell you that do not quite grasp the simple fact that you have been breathing this stuff and it has been falling on your garden right along.
    That water from your basement can be collected and used in your garden, just don't drink it without having it tested. All of my water comes from a well, the ground water, kind of the same place your sump pump gets the water it pumps, but those of us on wells should, periodically, have that water tested to be sure it is potable.

  • 19 years ago

    It's possible that the flashing is not actually lead but something that is flexible like lead (lots of products out there these days). If it is lead, get rid of it. Pumping dozens of gallons per day out of the basement seems a bit much. You might want to look into the whole drainage situation around your house. The asphalt particles from shingles should mostly settle out if the water is allowed to stand for a while (cover to avoid mosquitoes) - detention ponds are used to settle particles out of water at construction sites, etc.

  • 19 years ago

    This is an interesting thread since there seems to be a difference of attitude towards lead between the US and the UK. We are being encouraged from all sides over here to install water butts on our down pipes for garden use and yet and I have never heard any mention of lead problems. Lead is still currently used in the UK building industry for flashing and doesn't look like being phased out anytime soon. Our roof needed reflashing only this year and it was done with traditional rolls of lead. In fact as I live in a listed building in a conservation area we are not allowed to use anything BUT genuine lead flashing. Obviously lead plumbing inside the home is banned but roof lead is thriving. The high number of terraced houses and chimney stacks means that we have a great deal of flashing. Just how much lead do you think leaches out when cold rain water runs over it?

  • 19 years ago

    I can't answer all your questions but only some.

    I don't think you're going to find anyone who will test your water for free. It costs money to do, and takes some training to do so, so no one's going to give all that away for nothing.

    Groundwater - depending on the soil above it - should be ok for watering vegetables. Exceptions to consider would be if the soil in the area is extremely coarse gravelly sandy soil, and the groundwater is very shallow, and there are concentrated livestock operations in the area or farming that uses soil pesticides, or heavy industry. Fine textured soils and reasonably deep soils will filter out most contaminants before they reach the groundwater, given half a chance to do so.

    It's more likely you'd get the lawn pesticide runoff from surface runoff, rather than in the groundwater.

    About storing the basement water - how much could you reasonably store, and what percentage of your dry season use would that be? Storing a useful amount of water can be a real problem, at least here on the west coast where rain doesn't fall during the growing season. Here I'd need a good 3 month supply to get through the summer, and in California you'd need at least 6 months worth. A 50 gallon rain barrel just doesn't cut it - I'd go through that in one watering! and there'd be no more rain to refill it until October. Maybe back east, where it rains every week or so, it makes more sense.

    We do tend to be paranoid about chemicals here in the US. You need to consider that not every chemical in the water or the soil will be picked up by the plants, and that the amounts we're talking about in most cases are not what I'd worry about. But, it is a good idea to keep in mind that water and soil can become polluted, and can contaminate our food supply, and that as a society we really should be doing more to prevent those pollutants from entering the water and soil to start with. It's not just the things that get sprayed directly on the plants that can hurt us, but byproducts of other activities too.

    It's not that you can't make the Search function work, the Search function just does not work anymore. No apology necessary as it's not your doing!

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals