Software
Houzz Logo Print
tigereye

Rubber Mulch - don't do it!

13 years ago

We bought this house last summer. I have a large planting area in the front of the house that former owners mulched deep in rubber mulch. Well, I was pretty clueless on this and with so much to think about didn't pay much attention. Well, I noticed last August how bad it stunk when it was hot. I could not sit in the front of the house it smells so much. Husband doesn't notice and neither do my kids. Guess I am sensitive to it.
I advertised on Craigslist and have 2 people come and get it and they have actually gotten most of it except a thin layer. It no longer smells so bad. I'm not able to do all the work to completely dig it out and husband isn't either. Since I don't ever plan on putting veggies in there I am thinking of just covering it with mulch. I was going to go with dark brown but now thinking a red is what it is going to have to be since the rubber was red and will probably get mixed up some over time with planting flowers. What a pain! I see a lot of people remove it but there must be some that like it.
Anyway, I just thought I would through this out as food for thought.

Comments (12)

  • 13 years ago

    I would use a more natural color like plain wood chips or the brown stained wood. Maybe you could hire a young person to remove the remaining rubber since that is a tedious but easy job for a kid who wants a few dollars.

  • 13 years ago

    Burning of tires, shredded or not, is considered a hazardous problem that produces large amounts of pollution so that is not an option. Some time back there was some experimenting with mixing shredded tires with asphalt and laying it on our roads until those roads spontaneously combusted. There have been some reports of shredded tire mulches catching fire.
    So aside from the fact that rubber mulches contribute nothing of value to soil and they stink, just the fact that they might start burning should be enough of a deterent to use.

  • 13 years ago

    Once again I think ceth_k is being facetious... :-]

    I have never heard of a crumb rubber asphalt mix spontaneously combusting. I've been told by a state solid waste regulator that crumb rubber/asphalt pavement "works, but is more expensive than regular asphalt" due to the cost of the crumb rubber. If you know of a specific case I'd be interested to hear about it.

  • 13 years ago

    Tox, what I can tell you is that in the 1990's congress passed a law requiring 25 percent crumb rubber in federally funded highway asphalt and in less than 5 years that was rescinded and sections of highway around here that had been paved using crumb rubber were removed and replaced. Two members of our counties road commission told me that part of the reason was spontaneous combustion. i have found nothing about that although there are articles about the failure of this type of paving.

  • 13 years ago

    I recall a few stories on highway mixes of asphalt and tire materials that heated up and smouldered if not caught fire. The metal belt material in the tires seemed to cause the problem.

  • 13 years ago

    Well that was a crappy crumb rubber product then. Part of the production process is (should be) removing the steel belt material with magnets. Can you imagine a flower bed mulched with sharp pieces of wire sticking out? Or playground?

    I digress. I'm not going to claim this couldn't happen in an asphalt mix just because I haven't heard of it. I highly doubt crumb rubber mulch can spontaneously combust, and there are plenty of other reasons not to use it that have already been mentioned (i.e. the fact that it never breaks down and has to be removed by hand, and that it smells bad). there's no need to cloud the issue with dire warnings about extremely unlikely dangers.

  • 13 years ago

    I use rubber mulch in my containers. Just put a little in the bottom of each pot for drainage. Keeps them lighter than using rocks/pebbles.

  • 13 years ago

    A shop vac if the ground is dry should do the trick.

  • 13 years ago

    Husband seems to think shop vac would pull up more dirt than rubber.

  • 13 years ago

    The garden re-do shows I watched recently used rubber mulch in every project.
    Yuck.
    The gal was supposed to be a big time landscape architect, or whatever they call them.
    She put a movie screen made of wood at one end for movie nights. No electricity, no projector.....what the...?

  • 13 years ago

    I would just rake up as much as possible, then put down a nice thick layer of leaf mold and then top dress with hardwood mulch. I have never used and never will use rubber mulch as it does more harm than good in your garden.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio