Software
Houzz Logo Print
swjonthebay

A soil test question or twenty...:)

18 years ago

We are attempting to establish a new organic vegetable garden and have had a soil test done. I'm trying to make sense of this so we can go ahead and get the space ready for planting a fall garden. This is an area that was previously a garden probably 20 years ago. Heavy equipment was used to remove several trees and numerous shrubs/bushes. The results are as follows:

Recommendations:

Ground agricultural limestone=0.0 tons/acre

Fertilizer N-P2O5-K20=___-0-110 lbs/acre

Soil group--clays and soils high in organic matter (CEC>9.0 cmol kg)

pH-- 6.2

P=114 lb/acre (very high)

K=156 lb/acre (medium)

Mg=528 lb/acre (very high)

Ca=6536 lb/acre (extremely high)

Comment #1: Soil analyses indicate very high or excessive

P. Additional organic amendments will add more

P. Use materials high in N but low in P, such

as cottonseed meal (6-3-1), fish meal (10-6-1),

or blood meal (13-2-1). Legume cover crops can

also provide some N to subsequent crops.

Comment #2: Organic materials generally provide less K

compared to N and P. K can be supplied with

"green sand" (6% K20), or potassium magnesium

sulfate (18% K20, 11% Mg, 22% S). Apply enough

material to supply 1 to 3 lbs K20 per 1000 sq.

ft.

Comment #3: As a precautionary measure, consider applying

10 lbs sulfur per acre per year.

After the initial clearing was completed, there were numerous shells visible in the soil. We were told there used to be a shell driveway next to the garden, so I'm sure they came from there. My first question: Could the 'extremely high' calcium levels be from the shells decomposing? Or would it be more likely that the high reading of calcium could be falsely high due to scraping and turning the shells during the tree removal? Would true soil levels of calcium that high somehow interfere with the uptake of other nutrients?

The pH of 6.2 is a little bit of a surprise. Most of our soil around here is more acidic than that. I'm assuming the recommendation for considering yearly sulfur applications is to keep it where it is, correct?

Finally, I know I can find the potassium magnesium sulfate locally but haven't been successful so far in finding green sand. Wouldn't using the former be detrimental (despite their recommendation) by adding more magnesium along with the potassium? I have a seaweed fertilizer that lists 0-0-1. Would regular feedings of the vegetables with that be sufficient for the K that's lacking in the soil?

And finally, what about N? There was no recommendation for that. Is that standard? Should I not worry about that and just feed the plants with fish emulsion?

Any help will be greatly appreciated!

Comments (7)

  • 18 years ago

    What are you planning to grow in this area?
    What is the humus level, organic matter, in this soil?
    Who did this soil test and why do they recommend adding any Sulfur to a soil that has barely adequate pH for growing most every plant except those that need a low soil pH such as the Rododendron family?

  • 18 years ago

    Quick answers:

    Calcium could very well be coming from the shells, but the previous gardener probably limed the site.

    The sulfur application is because they didn't test for it, but since it leaches, you most likely need some.

    You can use potassium sulfate which is very similar to potassium magnesium sulfate but without the magnesium. Greensand is more of a slow acting long term amendment.

    There is no N recommendation for N because they didn't test for it. It is best to assume that you do not have much unless you have been adding manure or compost or had a legume cover crop. Add N at the rate required for the crop you are growing.

  • 18 years ago

    "What are you planning to grow in this area? "

    Initially broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cabbage, collards, lettuce, spinach, carrots, beets, onions, potatoes, tomatoes, rutabagas and cauliflower all to be planted from August to December at the appropriate times for my area.

    "What is the humus level, organic matter, in this soil?"

    Soil group--clays and soils high in organic matter (CEC>9.0 cmol kg)

    This was tested as bare soil. I have yet to add any organic matter to it. I wanted to fully understand the test results before I added anything. Also, they caution that adding further organic matter may/can raise the P in the soil. Now, having said that, I still plan on adding leaf mold and compost to these beds to improve the texture.

    "Who did this soil test and why do they recommend adding any Sulfur to a soil that has barely adequate pH for growing most every plant except those that need a low soil pH such as the Rododendron family?"

    This test was done by Auburn university and if I knew the answer to the rest of your question, I guess I wouldn't have to ask. (smile) Why wouldn't they recommend the addition of agricultural limestone if the pH is "barely adequate"?

    Fertilizersalesman, thank you for your information. A couple more questions, if I may? Would lime have such a lasting effect in the soil? I'm sure it was limed when it was a garden before but that was at least 20 years ago.

    Do you know of any adverse effects of very high calcium levels in soil and if so, are there any ways to counteract tham?

    I appreciate y'alls input.

  • 18 years ago

    Did you post all the information that was on the test results?

    Was there anything indicating Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC)?, percentage of cation saturation or what you've got in the lesser minerals? NO organic matter? NO nitrogen???

    I'm no expert, but that seems like a really odd test result.

    Is there a phone number on the test, where you could get some answers?

    Did you take your soil sample from just one spot?

    I would be tempted to send in another soil sample, with a combined sample of several places as far from the shell source as possible (still within your garden area), and see if there is a difference.

    Sue

  • 18 years ago

    Adding lime each and every year is unnecessary, unless an inadequate amount or the wrong kind is added, (the people at PBS Victory Garden should take note). If you put down the proper amount, and type of lime, that should correct the soils pH for several years.
    I asked who did the test because there is no indication of where in the world you are and that Auburn did that test tells me you are in Alabama. High Calcium in the soil can mean a high soil pH and a high soil pH can keep some nutrients from getting to the plants. Most all plant nutrients are most readily available to plants in the 6.2 to 6.8 soil pH range.
    Other than adding more organic matter to your soil (it may raise the soils pH and I have seen my soils pH, normally in the 5.7 range, change in some places to 7.2) because that OM will make your soil more workable, I would do nothing more until a future soil test showed a larger problem.

  • 18 years ago

    If your garden had been limed 20 years ago it is very likely that is the reason your pH is sill up where it is. In a natural system rain water is slightly acidic and will very gradually lower pH over time. Water moving through the soil leaches bases out of the system as well. The decay of organic materials is also an acidifying process. If these natural process provide more acids than there are bases in the weathering soil minerals the soil will naturally have a low pH. Alternatively in arid low rainfall areas and in limestone areas the soils will naturally have higher pHÂs. In a less than natural system sulfur in the air forms acid rain and will lower pH faster. Adding synthetic fertilizers will drastically and rapidly lower the soil pH. The reason you see farmers adding lime every 3 years is because they are adding a lot of fertilizer every year. Note that not all synthetic fertilizers are acidifying, but the ones that are not tend to be a lot more expensive.

    Having a lot of calcium in the soil is not a problem except that it means you are short on another base, in your case potassium. If your soil was high in calcium, magnesium, and potassium your pH would be higher. pH is a measure of the total bassicity/acidity of your soil. The Âpercent base saturation is a breakdown of how the bases (calcium, magnesium, potassium, sodium) are distributed. Ideally calcium takes up 65-75%, magnesium 10-15%, and potassium 2-5%. Sodium is not necessary and is toxic at relatively low levels. Exactly how much that is in lbs per acre or parts per million depends on how much your soil can hold which is represented by the cation exchange capacity (CEC). More clay, and more active (sticky) clay means more holding power and a higher CEC. That is why it takes more lime (base) to raise the pH of a heavy soil than a low CEC sandy soil. Simple eh?

  • 18 years ago

    "Simple eh?"

    Lol, not as simple as I might have hoped but I think I understand what you're saying. :)

    Thank you fertilizersalesman and kimmsr. I appreciate y'all taking the time to respond and share your knowledge with me.

    Sherry