Software
Houzz Logo Print
sheryl77

Vegetable soil

18 years ago

Is there a resource where I can look to find the best soil for growing a variety of veggies?

Thanks from Sheryl

Comments (21)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am a relatively newbie but I have found all sorts of great information

    searching this forum - try a search for lasagna or mels mix

    asking at a local nursury - hopefully they have some good options available in bulk, you can also find out their bulk supplier and ask them

    extension offices - your local office might have info specific to your climate / soil conditions but a number of the state extension offices have really great material available on the web such as http://www.cmg.colostate.edu/gnbynumber.htm (see section 210 and 710)

    Good Luck

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you mean to buy the soil for veggies, as for filling containers? My cynical opinion is that most of the stuff available in the big box stores is waste from other types of businesses, and not much good.

    If you mean what kind of soil is best for growing the widest assortment of soil, that's what we're all working toward!

    I googled 'ideal soil'... one clinical description said
    50 % porosity (air space)
    45 % mineral soil
    5 % organic matter
    25 % water (occupying the porous air spaces)
    25% air (occupying the porous air spaces)

    A slightly embellished version is at the link below, but really, it's a complicated subject.

    Balanced minerals, a nice combination of sand, clay and organic matter, the proper ph (which should follow the balanced minerals), all are important.

    Of course, lack of undesirable minerals is always a plus.

    Sue

    Here is a link that might be useful: Ideal soil

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Best is a subjective term. To me, is is usually the soil most people have in their yards, with generous additions of compost and other organic nutrients.

    The worst, in my opinion, is expensive concoctions like "Mel's mix," designed to ignore your garden soil and replace it with potting mix.

    The first thing to determine is why you need to buy any soil. What, exactly, is wrong with yours?

    Wayne

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The "best" soil for growing vegetables is one that is well amended with organic matter that is evenly moist but well drained with a soil pH in the 6.2 to 6.8 range. A soil with balanced nutrients to feed the plants you are growing.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I also think that the best soil is what you've got, amended with lots of compost and leaf mold and such. Unless you're talking about growing in containers, or unless the soil is contaminated with lead?

    There may be, out there, somewhere, some soil that is truly phenomenally the best and grows transcendentally fabulous vegetables, but my opinion is, so what :-)? The vegetables from my garden are pretty darn good, grown in the soil I've got.

    (However, I do realize that this is a question of temperament. I also think, for example, that the best compost is the compost that you make, however it's convenient for you, with the putrescibles you can round up, and that compost tea made with compost in pantyhose soaking in a bucket full of water is good stuff. I am not a gearhead :-).)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In other words, some plants prefer sandy soil, some like poor soil, etc. Is there a web resource that might tell me that.

    Sheryl

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sheryl:
    Most garden vegetables are grown as annuals and are bred to grow in relatively fertile, relatively well drained soil. Season and planting dates are probably more important for you to consider. Otherwise, your own soil, amended with homemade or store bought compost should be just fine. You can do pretty well with a generalized fertilization program or, if you want to optimize things, get a soil analysis and use that to guide supplementation. The vegetable forum should be able to help although you may need to supply them with your location.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Where I grew up we had loam, a soil type that is made up of 45 percent sand, 25 percent silt, 25 percent clay, and about 5 percent organic matter. Many people around us had a clay or a sand type, depending on where in relation to the river (apparently) they were. Dad each year got some manure from an uncle (his brother in law) and we had our vegetable (Victory) garden. Later, after school, I ended up on soil that is Lake Michigan beach sand, but by amending that sand with organic matter I can grow vegetables and flowers just as good as those of the olden days and a cousing that landed on a clay soil does the same doing the smae thing, adding organic matter. But all soils, except maybe a swampy soil, need organic matter first to be able to support good plant growth.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for all the input. And good luck with your gardens this summer.

    Sheryl

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    All she wanted was a receipe......try these ..there are a few receipes for different veggies.......

    Potting Soil Specialized Recipes

    If plants growing in the ground don't receive all the water or nutrients they need they can send their roots out farther than normal in search. Container garden plants don't have that luxury. We have to give them all they need in their potting soil and the water and nutrients added throughout the season. For many plants, a good-quality generic potting soil will do. However, certain plant types have specific needs and they will flourish only if those needs are addressed.

    For container gardening always start with a good-quality potting soil. Not all potting soils are created equal. Be sure yours is made with well-composted ingredients and holds water while at the same time proves good drainage. If you have a type or brand of potting soil you like you can use it as a base for the recipes below, or start with the basic potting soil recipe if you prefer to make your soils completely from scratch.

    TOOLS/EQUIPMENT NEEDED FOR ALL RECIPES
    Wheelbarrow, large bin, or heavy plastic tarp in which to mix materials
    Large trowel or small shovel for mixing
    Bucket for measuring (size depends on amount of soil you make)

    BASIC POTTING SOIL
    2 buckets good-quality fine compost, any large sticks or clumps removed
    (this should smell very fresh and earthy)
    bucket fine coconut coir (substitute peat moss if you want an acidic potting soil)
    ½ bucket coarse sand (builders sand)
    ½ bucket perlite
    Optional: add ½ bucket vermiculite for added water retention

    For every 5 gallons of mix add 1 cup of mineral powder (Calcium, Phosphorus and Potassium) and 2-3 Tbs of Kelp Meal. If you cannot find a good mineral powder, mix bone meal with a potash source such as greensand.

    Mix well and store any unused portion in plastic bags or covered buckets. Do not allow to dry out! The beneficial organisms in the compost need moisture to survive. If your mix is getting dry, spray with a little water to keep the beneficial bacteria alive.

    ACIDIC POTTING SOIL
    This mix is excellent for Azaleas, Camellias, Rhododendron, Hydrangeas, Evergreens, Blueberries, Raspberries, Potatoes and Strawberries
    2 parts potting soil mix
    1 part coarse sand or perlite
    1 part peat moss
    ½ part well composted manure

    POTTING MIX FOR BULBS
    Great for Daffodils, Glads, Dahlias, and all bulbs. Add a little lime to raise the pH for bulbs which prefer an alkaline soil, such as Bearded Iris.
    2 parts potting soil mix
    1 part coarse sand
    1 part fine coir fiber
    Bone meal (follow package directions according to quantity)

    POTTING MIX FOR CACTUS AND SUCCULENTS
    Great for all plants which require a well-drained, coarse soil.
    2 parts potting soil mix
    2 parts coarse sand
    1 part perlite
    For additional nutrients add:
    Worm castings, 1 cup per 5 gallons of mix
    Bone meal (follow package directions according to quantity)

    POTTING MIX FOR ROSES
    This mix is excellent for all types of roses. If you have a large bush or vigorous climber be sure to give extra feedings throughout the growing season.
    2 parts potting soil mix
    1 part well-composted manure
    ½ part good compost
    ½ part peat moss
    1 part perlite
    1 cup alfalfa meal and ½ cup bone meal for every 5 gallons of soil, or according to package directions.

    POTTING MIX FOR TERRESTRIAL ORCHIDS, BROMELIADS AND FERNS
    This mix is great for Cymbidiums, Lady Slipper Orchids, Terrestrial Bromeliads, and Ferns.
    1 part potting soil mix
    ½ part peat moss
    ½ part perlite
    1 part coconut husk chips or medium orchid bark
    optional:
    ½ part charcoal (approximately ½ inch chunks)

    SEED STARTING MIX
    This mix works well in seed starting trays, six-packs, or peat/coir fiber pots.
    1 part potting soil mix
    1 part vermiculite

    IMPORTANT NOTE FOR ALL MIXES:
    Mix all ingredients well and store any unused soil mixes in plastic bags or covered buckets. Do not allow to dry out! The beneficial organisms in the mix need moisture to survive. If your mix is getting dry, spray with a little water to keep the beneficial bacteria alive.

    andy

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sounds like a pretty expensive proposition to grow a vegetable garden, Andy. Still think the source of soil she's looking for may be free and under her feet.

    By the way, the text you cut and pasted here is copyrighted and requires permission of the author. You should at least post the author's name.

    Wayne

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your right Wayne....thanks for pointing that out....the source is http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art21655.asp .... Jessica Carson of BellaOnline is the editor.....I have tried a couple of the receipes and just watching....so far so good....as far as expense goes.....initially it might be but then the expense lessens.....and you know whats it your soil...

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you build a lasagna garden out of leaves, manure, compost, vegie scraps, coffee grounds, etc. you also know what it is made out of, and it is fabulous stuff and vegies LOVE it. The difference is that it is FREE. Besides the waste of money buying soil 'products,' you are using up plastic bags or some type of packaging, the stuff you are buying was processed and then transported a long way to reach you, etc. Lots of useless overhead on a planet full of free organic material that your vegies would love to get into.

    Marcia

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Whoa Marcia...I was simply giving my input to a lady who wanted some info....I do not need a lecture on global warming...I am aware of the horrible future that my grandkids and great grandkids might have.....voice your opinions to the President....not that it will do any good but with your enthusiasm you might get thru to him.....

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry if my enthusiasm was a bit intense - I was actually just answering the original question, not trying to give talk 7 in my series on global warming "Don't buy products when you can make something free and better." :-) What is the best soil for growing a variety of veggies? A lasagna garden!

    I do grow a large variety of vegetables, and I haven't found a one that doesn't love it. Well, hard to say about the beets because the rabbits always eat them, but everything else grows well: corn, tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, lettuce, beans, arugula, spinach, cilantro, dill, cucumbers, rhubarb, garlic, onions, radishes, Swiss chard, oregano, kohlrabi, potato, and kale are what I am growing this year. Plus the irises, bachelor buttons, cosmos, and morning glories which are in my lasagna beds.

    Marcia

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In my state we have a great website put out by the University of Illinois extension that is full of information about gardening, from basics to specifics about various garden plants.... its somewhat specific to Illinois climate, but I am sure much of the information is valid no matter where you live.

    I check the site, for planting dates and good ideas...

    I agree that for gardening, use the soil that you have, amended with organic matter (even as recommended on the site link I provided).

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Marcia.... you mentioned a lasagna garden....what exactly is that.....would appreciate the specifics.....thanks

    andy

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You can probably find a lot of posts on lasagna gardening using the search here, and probably many more using google, so you can start with what I give you here and then search and read some more. I'll give an overview, but there are books written about it, so I'll be scratching the surface.

    I think it's also called sheet composting and/or interbay mulch, but those may have some variations in them.

    Lasagna gardening is not a good idea for perennials because the organic matter continues to decompose and needs to be replenished. The condensed version is that you create layers of organic matter and plant directly in that instead of in the ground. You can put up a wall around it or just heap it up on the ground.

    Now for some details. You want to start with a layer of cardboard (or a couple of layers) or many layers of newspaper. I think you need to water them after putting them down. Then put down a layer of high nitrogen matter (greens) such as grass clippings, used coffee grounds (available from Starbucks for free), kitchen waste, etc. Then a layer of high carbon matter such as leaves, shredded paper, sawdust, etc. You keep layering until it is several feet deep. You do this in the fall for spring planting. In zone 10 California, maybe you do it in the spring for fall planting?

    I don't follow the "rules" very much and just dump stuff without regard to whether I'm getting good layers or not, but I try to get a mixture of high carbon and high nitrogen (mine is usually leaves and coffee grounds). I've had a pile that was waist high in the fall end up about 6 inches deep in the spring. I had a deeper pile last fall and many of the leaves were shredded (and I didn't have enough coffee grounds) and the pile was probably a foot and a half deep this spring.

    You can plant directly into the "lasagna" although some plants (like corn) can blow over unless you use some soil for the seeds.

    You don't have to worry about the hard packed clay from the beginning and the worms and soil microbes get busy and carry much of the organic matter into the soil, so you're improving that over time, as well.

    You'd think that piling all that stuff on every year would end up creating a mound after a few years, but as it decomposes, it loses nearly all of its volume. The 3 ft pile I created in fall of 2006 was undetectable by the time I started piling leaves on in fall 2007. The same for the year before. I'm curious whether any of last year's leaves will be visible this fall. It started out larger and was more compact due to the shredded leaves, so it may still be there.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello all! Thanks for all the information. I like Marcia's ideas the best. (ok..I'm flirting). LOL.
    Marcia, try planting bagonias (spelling?). The rabbits hate them. My uncle told me this in the 80's and it works very well. It also makes the vegetable garden more colorful. I plant them in groups of 3 about every 8 feet.
    Chuck
    ps...I am going to try my own potting soil with boiled hay(to kill the seeds and to retain moisture), saw dust from oak(I have a wood planer), and my own garden soil(a bit too much clay but almost sandy loam)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A question:
    Is styrofoam ok to use for starting vegetable seeds? (I have a lot of cups from mom getting meals on wheels). I worry about the chemicals...
    What about organic paper cups? I think I will google that one. Chuck.
    ps..the early bird gets the worm, the second mouse gets the cheese! :)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    greenthumbchuck, it would have been better if you had started a new discussion instead of tacking onto one almost a year old.
    Is styrofoam ok to use for starting vegetable seeds? Yes, as long as none of it ends up in the garden.
    Why on earth would one boil hay? I see something about killing "weed" seeds and retaining moisture, something I've not seen as a problem in over 35 years. This would be a pointless use of scarce energy.

Sponsored
Buckeye Restoration & Remodeling Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars7 Reviews
Central Ohio's Premier Home Remodelers Since 1996