Software
Houzz Logo Print
rckowal

Big Store Composted Manure

15 years ago

How is the quality of the cheap, bagged composted manure sold by Lowes &/or Home Depot? Do they contain un-composted weed seeds?

Additionally, what is the difference between the high priced ($4.99/40 lb. bag) and the low priced ($1.75) stuff?

Regards, Richard

Comments (25)

  • 15 years ago

    I really cannot vouch for the quality of either, but I definitely have used those products from each store, for example, when making raised beds for veggies (when I did not have enough of own compost). I have noticed no adverse effects. I generally buy the cheapest product, unless I have had problems with it before. You might want to buy one bag of the cheaper one, and see what it looks like. If possible, read the bag labels, they might shed some light on what is in there. I would guess that if Miracle Grow made such a product (not sure if they do), it would be more expensive than a more generic brand. However, for example with potting soil, the brands such as Miracle Grow and Shultz (no financial interest in any of these products) are virtually always a better, lighter potting soil than the generic brands which look like wet mud.

  • 15 years ago

    Prices are cheaper for bagged steer manure in southern California. Lowes and Home Depot usually charge around 98 cents for a one cubic foot bag, and I have used it and it has worked well.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the replies. I never buy the generic "mud mixes" at any price - even it was free. I try to use the big name brands but haven't seen them in my area (S.E. Michigan). Scotts for instance, makes a compost & manure product but not even the big buck nurseries stock it.

    The high priced product I've seen is called Dehydro, it's dehydrated manure. After posting here, I found this explanation of the differences between the dehydrated & the "plain vanilla" products. Apparently, dehydrated is easier to work with and less of it is required to get equal results.

    Best regards, Richard

  • 15 years ago
  • 15 years ago

    I don't know what mud mix is, but why would any manufacturer mix heavy dirt in with manure. It would make the cost of shipping prohibitive. A cubic foot of dirt would weigh almost a hundred pounds.

  • 15 years ago

    but why would any manufacturer mix heavy dirt in with manure.

    I think the reference was to moisture, not the mineral component.
    But since you asked...
    You'll often get a fair amount of dirt in manures because:
    A) The animals will often eat dirt along with the plants that they forage which, of course, shows up in the manure.
    B) When you're turning over a windrow of manure with a skip loader, it's easy to scoop up some dirt whether you want to or not.

  • 15 years ago

    I've used those cheap bags of manure from HD in the past, but not anymore. I had quite a bit of spotted spurge, a nasty weed, show up in the bed where I used the manure and had never seen it anywhere on my property before or since. This was in my very sheltered, fenced backyard, where weed seeds generally don't just blow in. I know I can't be absolutely sure the seeds came from the steer manure, but it was enough for me to put me off it ... forever. I use only compost now.

  • 15 years ago

    The primary source of that manure is the Confined Animal Feeding Operation, the place the animals are fattened up before the slaughter house. Animals in those places are routinely fed antibiotics to aid in putting on weight and to aid in preventing the spread of disease. The only source of any "weed" seeds from that manure would be the tiny bit of hay they may be fed, but since most of the diet consists of grains there will not be many.
    That manure does not come from grass fed animals out on the range.

  • 15 years ago

    Californian, Mud mix is just my self-coined term for some cheap top soil (not composted manure) sold by the big stores here in Michigan. I suspect it may be dredged from river bottoms or swampy areas. Or they deliberately add water to top soil to reduce its cost since they sell it by weight in 40 lb. bags.

    Speaking of weed content, I once had a nasty experience with free compost available from city recycling centers around here. I foolishly spread lots of it around my garden beds then spent several years pulling weeds to get their population under control again. Brings to mind the old saying "you get what you pay for"!

    To me, spending a few extra bucks on a bag of high quality, weed free soil additive is worth a lot more that the back breaking work & expense involved to control weeds.

  • 15 years ago

    I think it's only sold in the SE, but Black Kow is a superior composted manure. I used to use the HD or Lowe's brand, and it was a medium brown and not very thick. Black Kow is just composted manure, and it's black and earthy. I love it.

  • 15 years ago

    I just did a study on this very question using local products here in central MO. I'll give you the short version since the report isn't online yet.

    First we looked at the 3 major components: organic matter, moisture and 'ash'. Ash is everything else that's not the other two, and includes all mineral matter, salts, and any soil that may be in the mix.

    Of the 7 products sold by weight, 4 were over 5% below their marked weight with the lowest weighing in at 81%. Only one was over 100% of its advertised weight.

    Water content ranged from 24% to 51%.

    After moisture is measured, organic matter and all other analysis (NPK etc.) are on a dry-weight basis. OM ranged from a dismal 3.27% to 32.9% (dry weight basis). So, if the product is 50% water and 5% OM (dry weight), the product in the bag is 2.5% OM, which is not even a really good topsoil, never mind compost. The lower cost products had lower organic content, and in fact the bottom of the curve was made up of products priced less than $2 per bag.

    Ash content: Most middle of the road products were in the 80s, and again, the lower priced products scored the worst, with up to 96% of the dry weight as mineral matter.

    NPK was also higher in the higher priced products. Micronutrients (Mg, Cu etc.), pH, electrical conductivity and CN Ratio were within acceptable ranges for almost all products tested.

    Conclusions:
    1. Generally you get what you pay for.
    2. Cheap stuff has more soil and mineral matter mixed in. If you don't mind getting some soil that will build up your beds over time, there's nothing wrong with using the cheap stuff.
    3. Very expensive products (>$10/40 lb) didn't seem to be worth it.
    4. The best commercial product was a cotton burr compost that had very high OM/low ash, acceptable moisture, excellent texture, good nutrient content and was $5.99/40 lb (middle of the cost range).
    5. HOMEMADE COMPOST BEAT VIRTUALLY EVERY COMMERCIAL PRODUCT IN EVERY CATEGORY AND WAS FREE.

    :-]

  • 15 years ago

    Toxcrusadr: Very interesting! Please clarify what type of products were studied. Were they compost, manure, or compost/manure mix?

    Did you by any chance evaluate any "dehydrated" compost/manure products? De-hi-gro, marketed by Garick, is one such product. I think Scotts now has one as well. These are about $5.00/40 lbs.

    Richard

  • 15 years ago

    It was a wide range of products, labelled as compost, organic humus, composted manure, and combinations of those. There was one dehydrated manure product in a small package, can't remember the brand offhand but it was not either of the ones you mentioned. And a couple 40 lb. composted manures. They vary regionally so folks elsewhere are not likely to see the same products. But, I think the rules will hold pretty well across the country.

    If/when I can get this reported hosted on line (maybe our Extension office which helped out with it), I'll post a link.

  • 15 years ago

    For value conscious shoppers, it would be very helpful if makers of such products would disclose content like moisture & organic matter. However, they don't like to do that so they rely on the use of obscure verbiage & low price to sell them.

    I've used the low priced stuff in the past then learned that it can contain a lot of weed seeds. I would prefer to pay a few dollars more to have weed free (dehydrated) compost.

    Richard

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the posting, toxcrusadr. Very interesting. I would love to see the full report when it is available. In the meantime, it seems safe to say that the el cheapo stuff that I bought contained very little OM and a lot of soil and quite likely the spotted spurge seeds.

  • 14 years ago

    Gardeners brand composted steer manure has always worked well for me. Its .98 cents a bag. Never had a weed or rock or black sludge. I let it sit for a year in the bag (dot know if that does anything or not). Its dark brown and fluffy and barely smells like cow poo. I kinda like the smell. When I first buy it it is kinda wet and dark. But after the year in the garage its nice! anyways, they sell chicken manure too. "Gardeners" brand

    Here is a link that might be useful: Steer Manure

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, poop can smell good if you have a little patience. Same with beer goggles, give enough time and everything is beautiful. If you can leach it with rain water out in the street, not only can you eliminate the smell rather soon, but rainbows and shamrocks appear, and slowly, little mushrooms waft their ethers into your senses... ahhh, the magic in the essence... just a matter of time, that pooey goo turns into the dark, magic moist pixie dust that posters like to wiff of..it's all in God's plans...over and out from the bamboo grove.

    Mackel

  • 14 years ago

    Lol! You must have got a hold of some good $heeit!

  • 14 years ago

    I was thinking the same thing. :-o

  • 14 years ago

    Black Kow is a ripoff and it doubles its crime with the sanctimonious "pure product" full-page lies put in gardening magazines. Until someone shows me a university or industry bulletin recommending a healthy double-dose of fine sand in cattle rations I call "bull" on their self-serving claims. (Black Hen seems not quite so adulterated.) I used to be able to get dehydrated and pretty pure bagged cow manure at a good local feed store but they can no longer get it (it came from Texas I think I recall). I have no access at all to bagged cow manure that is relatively unadulterated with dirt.

  • 14 years ago

    Damn that sux!

  • 14 years ago

    It's true, most of the bagged compost products have a lot of soil in them. Anything from sand grains to little clay balls. Especially the cheaper ones. The test results confirm it.

    Products are VERY regional due to the shipping expense. Something you get for a buck at your local store is probably made a few miles away, and the rest of us probably haven't heard of it. Scotts potting mix (etc.) are the exception, big brands will have a forumula and if they have regional factories, they have to follow the recipe, same as Bud Light. But the cheap stuff is pot luck.

  • 13 years ago

    You'd be lucky to find manure at a big store. Years ago I would buy cow manure at K-Mart and make a tea for my roses. That was pure composted manure. Now big store products like Black Cow is nothing but a bag of sand with the equivalent of a couple of cow chips added. I guess real composted manure is still available; but, you'll not find it at Walmart, HD, Lowe's, etc. What you'll get will do almost nothing to add organic matter to your soil.

  • 13 years ago

    I get organic composted manure for $2 at Menard's.