Software
Houzz Logo Print
meyermike_1micha

Aphids

17 years ago

Does anyone have a fantastic and easy way of ridding aphids on roses. After all these cloudy rainy days, my roses are loaded with these buggers...

Thanks alot...

Comments (15)

  • 17 years ago

    A blast of water is the most fantastic and easy way I've found.

  • 17 years ago

    Of course there is always squishing. It might seem offensive at first but you quickly get used to it. My husband laughs at how quickly I went from not wanting to do it to doing it every time I see some now without a second thought.

    Kate

  • 17 years ago

    Kate has guacamole fingers.

  • 17 years ago

    Is there any 'greener' way to kill bugs?

    I'm sorry Michael that was irresistible:)

    Kate

  • 17 years ago

    I post this simple, biodegradable, and cheap cure at least five times every year. Guess you have missed it. Email me direct, and I will respond with it.

  • 17 years ago

    The easiest way is to ignore them. If you aren't spraying, the predators will move in and take care of your problem. A few days ago I noticed that Cardinal de Richelieu was covered with aphids. Yesterday it also had several hungry syrphid fly larvae chowing down, and there was a tremendous reduction in aphids. In a day or 2 the aphids will probably be gone--or at least back down to a manageable level. (Thanks to michaelg for identifying this wonderful predator!)

  • 17 years ago

    OK,
    So far so good.
    The squashing thing though, I don't know if I can do it. What if there is such a thing as reincarnation and those are people from another life?
    What a drastic way to die....

    As for blasting with water, won't they just come back to haunt them again along with all my other plants?

    As for the biodegradable stuff, I might be interested.

    How about kneem oil, has anyone ever used this and does it work?

    What happens if the good critters never show up for the party, and the aphids have won out from leaving them alone?

    But I really appreciate the ideas and guacamole thing!!

    Man, I dunno...

  • 17 years ago

    Roseman's trick is to dust them with flour, and then hose them off the next day. If you use plain water, many of them will live and climb another plant. However, if you break up the encrustations occasionally, that's enough to prevent noticeable damage. But damage rarely gets beyond the level of cosmetic. Every rose garden has aphids, and frankly, experienced growers don't worry about them-- except for exhibitors in show season. Predators usually clean them up around the end of the first flush. This year I did nothing beyond wiping off a few shoot tips, and there was no damage.

  • 17 years ago

    I use soap and water in a spray bottle.
    Good old Dawn and I just spray the buds as I don't care if they chew on a few leaves.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm a squisher.

  • 17 years ago

    lolololol..;-0)..

    I actually sprayed my roses with fish emulsion since this post, and they seem to of all just croaked...NICE!!

  • 17 years ago

    Don't use Neem Oil.

    I believe it kills bees =:(

    Can you search your yard for a ladybug or two? I had aphids on a potted morning glory, found a few ladybugs elsewhere, plunked them on the morning glory, and two days later, no aphids =:)

  • 17 years ago

    nutsaboutflowers: neem oil, when used properly, causes very little problems for bees whatsoever. All horticultural oils should never be sprayed directly onto bees. Actually, we should avoid spraying anything directly onto bees or into flowers where bees are actively foraging.

    Insecticidal soaps can do significant harm to bees if they come into contact with the product while it is still wet.

    Neem has been used very successfully in the control of different types of mites in bee hives....with little collateral damage to bee populations.

    If an aphid population is very much out of control, neem is a good tool to use in conjunction with squishing and sharp sprays of water. Spray the foliage and buds, avoid the flowers. Since part of the action of Neem is as an anti-feedant, it can reduce the damage from Japanese Beetles, though it won't kill them outright.

  • 17 years ago

    I have made a garlic oil spray in the past - crush a couple cloves of garlic soak overnight in a couple tablespoons of vegatable oil, then strain to make garlic oil, add a teaspoon or two of the oil with a teaspoon or two of baby shampoo (to emulsify), fill a spray bottle with water. The aphids drop fast and mosquitos scatter. I have also heard that the garlic (as well as others in the allium familly) are good anti-fungals as well, due to high sulfur content. It is a good short term fix, but doesn't last long.

    I have also read about using zest from citrus peels to make a similar spray, but have yet to try it.

    I am uncertain about the impact on beneficial insects. I don't want to harm bees, butterflies or ladybugs. Has anyone tried these homemade sprays? Thoughts, comments.

    But, so far Bayer 3-in-1 has worked best for me.

  • 17 years ago

    You don't want to harm bees, but you're using Imidicloprid?

    You don't realize that your rose's pollen is full of that, and that the bees carry it back to feed to the developing larvae???

    A contact poison that killed worker bees (the oldest individuals in the colony) would be less-harmful to the hive. At least they wouldn't take that back to contaminate the whole colony. :-(

    Truthfully, if your concern is fungal disease, for Heaven's sake use a product made to control fungus.
    DON'T use an insecticide unless you have insects!

    Jeri