Software
Houzz Logo Print
cheri_in_maine

Nitrogen?

19 years ago

My husband brought home Urea to fertilze our vegetable garden. Evidently, for the past two years the vegetable garden they grow at work benefits greatly from the Urea - everything "jumps." I've been using Rose Tone, Compost and coffe grounds on my roses. Urea has ALOT of Nitrogen in it. Does anyone have experience with using Urea and is Nitrogen beneficial? I have sandy loam mixed with horse manure.

Thanks

Comments (9)

  • 19 years ago

    Of the three major plant nutrients: nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium; nitrogen is the one most likely to be deficient and the one most likely to give a boost to plants. If you are feeding the label amounts of Rose Tone, your roses should have more than enough nitrogen. Even so, a common practice is to supplement Rose Tone and similar fertilizers with fast-acting water soluble fertilizers, added at maybe half or a quarter of the label rate. Most water-soluble fertilizers contain urea as the principle source of nitrogen. The old Miracle-Gro bottle that I have in my garage, for example, contains 25% urea by weight. Urea does have a lot of nitrogen, 46%, but all that means is you add half as much of the stuff as you would with a 23% nitrogen fertilizer.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you Mike. I think I'll be cautious and add a 1/4 of the amount. :) 14 of my roses were shipped bare root this year and I'm fairly "green" as far as roses.

  • 19 years ago

    Cheri, just more blather on the same subject: I have a bottle of Vigoro water-soluble with an NPK of 24-8-6 and the label rate per rose is 1 tbs every 14 to 28 days. The whole idea of supplementing with a a water-soluble is to even out the supply of nutrients, compared to slower-acting fertilizers such as Rose Tone. I'd figure once a week is too much work and once a month is too far apart to serve the purpose, so I'd pick biweekly and if I went for 1/4 the rate, I'd add 1/4 tbs of Vigoro per rose. If I decided to feed the same amount of nitrogen and forget about the phosphorous and potassium (not a bad idea in my clay soil, which doesn't leach potassium easily and has probably been over-fertilized with phosphorous in the past), I could do that by adding 1/8 tbs of urea per rose (roughly 1/4 tbs X 24/46). It doesn't take much urea, does it?

  • 19 years ago

    O.K. Basically I have never paid attention to whether my garden needed Nitrogen, Potassium or Phosphorous, and I really do not want to put any energy into testing my soil.. (toooooo busy - or that's my excuse.)
    In my previous home I used Miracle gro and in my limited experience it did nothing for my garden.
    Now I gather wisdom from everyone here on the GW and purchase the "popular" products in a frenzy. So, I should "nix" the idea of urea or use it in small doses with a water soluble fertilzer that includes all the beneficial ingredients. My biggest concern was over-fertilizing. Living in Zone 5, I am very impatient with the growth of many of my plants so I continually want to feed them. My roses look very healthy and lush. I actually have several buds on my both of my Tree Roses and buds on one english rose. Very good I think, considering I planted them bare root on June 4?
    Now who's blathering? :)
    You mentioned you have clay. Roses can thrive in clay? I have a lot of clay in my backyard and have been avoiding planting anything it other than my foolproof perennials.

  • 19 years ago

    Clay with organic matter added to the topsoil is very good soil for roses if you can avoid compacting it while wet. Don't dig unless it's dry enough for clods to crumble rather than mash. Install stepping stones and keep your feet off the soil unless it's dry.

    1 TB of urea per square yard is about the most you should ever apply, and that's when there isn't already a lot of available nitrogen in the soil. 1 TB of urea with no other fertilizer is about a month's worth of N . As Mike said, N is the nutrient plants are most likely to run short of, but it's also the nutrient people are most likely to overdo and cause damage.

    Please note-- Mike is not recommending that you apply urea in combination with a soluble fertilizer. Soluble fertilizers already contain plenty of available nitrogen (often in the form of urea). Urea is what you would use as an inexpensive substitute for soluble fertilizer, when you think N is the main nutrient that is needed. If you get no benefit from Miracle Gro, you wouldn't get any benefit from urea.

  • 19 years ago

    What MichaelG said, and a final piece of blather: Everyone agrees that a soil test is a good idea, but I suspect very few actually get one. In any case, a soil test usually doesn't include nitrogen and the recommendation for nitrogen is usually based on experience and on the organic content of the soil, not on a direct test for available nitrogen. The recommended amount of nitrogen usually is pretty much identical to what you read on a package of rose fertilizer. My own prejudice is that a feeding of alfalfa pellets, early and in midseason, and a single feeding with 4-month Osmocote timed-release pellets is just about all a rose should need in my zone. The "just about" leaves me wiggle room to experiment with things like fish emulsion or Joy Juice when the mood hits me.

  • 19 years ago

    Sirs Michael, I am so novice at this nutrients, micro's,etc., but I so agree about the need to hold back rather than inundate. Not sure in our drought this year my gardne could even take the Joy Juice, but I normally use it and/or fish emulsion during the season, but without rain since first week in April, I am totally holding off anything but water hose.

  • 19 years ago

    Being an inexpensive source of nitrogen and water soluble, I put a 50 lb bag of 46-0-0 urea in a 50 gallon barrel and let my fertilizer injector apply it in my watering system.
    Having very sandy soil I can get away with this because nitrogen leaches very quickly from sand.
    If I had clay, I'd use it very sparingly.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Everyone - I will stay away from the Urea.