Software
Houzz Logo Print
misssherryg

Mystery Tree/Bush

18 years ago

There's a plant that came up next to a clump of iris fulva, a copper colored Louisiana iris, in a very wet, boggy spot on my property. It has multiple trunks, some of which are leaning over, probably due to crowding with the iris clump, but one trunk grows straight up and is about 5'-6' tall, which would be a little under 2 meters, I think.

At first, I thought it was elderberry/sambucus canadensis, since there IS some that volunteered in the same wet area. I noticed yesterday that the mystery plant has got buds on it that are quite different from the big clusters that elderberries make. The bark is also different - the new growth is brown with white spots all over it, and last year's growth is light brown, somewhat similar in appearance to devil's walking stick/aralia spinosa but without the thorns or big flower clusters that makes. The flower buds are sort of reminding me of American beautyberry/callicarpa americana, but they haven't opened yet, so that remains to be seen. The leaves are somewhat like buttonbush/cephalanthus occidentalis, but without the cute little round flower clusters - my buttonbushes are making their flowers now.

Here's a picture -

{{gwi:358342}}
Anybody know what this plant is?

Here's a picture of the nearby sambucus for comparison -

{{gwi:358343}}
Sherry

Comments (31)

  • 18 years ago

    You are showing two different plants. Sounds like you already know what they are, have become confused by thinking it is all one plant instead of a tall one growing out of a shorter one.

  • 18 years ago

    Like I said, the second picture is of an elderberry - it's the first one I was confused about. However, after looking at some American beautyberry/callicarpa americana, I think this is what it is. It looks very different from all the other American beautyberries on my property that grow on dry sites - the dry site callicarpas have much bigger leaves that are much further apart, they have a different, dryer, thinner feel, and the white spots on the new growth bark aren't as prominent as the ones in the first picture.
    It's amazing the difference environmental differences, especially drainage, can make!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Your account makes it sound like you have an elder (or whatever) growing out of a beautyberry (or whatever) and think it is all the same shrub. Someone posting about a bush and then showing pictures of two different ones is not unheard of here. The top one certainly does look like a beautyberry, the bottom an elder. It continues to appear you have it figured out.

  • 18 years ago

    lol you guys hate each other huh? Oh well can't help you, but thought I'd bump it up for ya!

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think he read my account fully, since I said up front that the bush/tree in question was growing out of a LOUISIANA IRIS, and that the elderberry is just in the same area.
    Bboy has a brusque, sarcastic, "I'm never wrong" manner that really gets under my skin - I try not to let it show.
    Guys probably think it's not cool to be too nice! :)
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Can't hate someone I've never met, obviously found the original post hard to follow.

    Like I said.

    Even if the reward for attempting to help them figure out their problem is insults. But that seems to be par for the course around here.

  • 18 years ago

    ...

    The original post seemed clear enough to me. I cant help with the identification because I am so far north that there is a rain/snow mix forecast for tonight (AARRgghh)

    But I agree sherry, environmental differences make a huge impact. What you are describing for the dry site versus wet site difference in these plants, assuming they are indeed the same, seems odd though. Usually dry site plants have a thicker, smaller leaf with shorter spaces between the leaf. Think of the difference between sun/shade leaves.

    But then again, these characteristics on the plant in the first picture may be due to individual variation?

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Sherry: Your question was clear to me. You want to identify an unknown plant that is growing next to a clump of Louisiana iris. Your hypothesis is that it may be American beautyberry/callicarpa americana but it looks quite different from other callicarpa americana on your property. You wonder if the differences may be caused by growing in a wet area.

    So far, you haven't received much constructive advice, although you've received a big helping of unwarranted criticism.

    I'm sorry I can't help re: your mystery plant. Did you figure it out?

    Pam

  • 18 years ago

    It looks like the same weed that grows on my land. I have no idea what it is.

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, I think it definitely is American beautyberry, Alabama, but I'll keep watching it. If it makes berries like callicarpa (that turn purple later on) I'll know for sure that's what it is.
    The only other plant that I know of, Fledgling, that shows such differences in the leaves due to the environment it's growing in is flowering dogwood. FD leaves in deep shade are bigger than those in the sun and farther apart. The differences between the leaves on this beautyberry and others relates to water - in this case, the water seems to have made the leaves smoother, not rough like the ones in dry areas, but I don't know why the leaves would be smaller and closer together.
    You really gotta love trees to post on this forum, Pam! I'm down right scared of some of the posters here who like to argue and insult, not my style at all! I hope all those newly planted seedlings of yours are growing!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Sherry, might I offer the possibility that this is not the American beautyberry? The only reason I mention this is that the length of the stem between the branch and the flower buds (quite long on yours). Supposedly, a characteristic difference between the native one and the asian one is that stem length.

    Although my beautyberry has not yet put out buds (way behind you), the remains of last year's flower/berry structure is still there and that stem is much shorter. Take a look at the linked picture.

    At the very least, this one could be a hybrid of the two.

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:358341}}

  • 18 years ago

    I went outside and checked it, and I found a branch of the mystery plant that hangs over a verifiable beautyberry, which looks just like yours esh_ga, as do all the beautyberries on my property. Now I think you're probably right about it not being a beautyberry. I made a picture of the two - you can see the huge difference in leaf size with the small-leaf mystery plant being on the left and the big-leaf beautyberry on the right -
    {{gwi:358345}}
    The trunk of the beautyberry is 4' from the trunk of the mystery plant, I measured it. The beautyberry is on a slightly dryer spot, but it's still wet, so I don't see how the environmental conditions could apply here - they both get the same amount of sunlight.
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, I do think that the asian one has somewhat smaller leaves as well which your photo illustrates quite well.

  • 18 years ago

    Hmmm....I ordered the Louisiana irises from some mail-order nursery, can't remember which one. I don't remember planting anything but one single plant, which has multiplied big time, but there could have been a root or a seed in with the original plant.
    Anyway, it'll be interesting to see what the flowers and fruit look like on the probable Asian plant - I'll keep you all posted.
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    I agree, you have a volunteer Asian Beautyberry, most likely the Japanese Beautyberry (Calicarpa dichotoma). This is the most commonly cultivated species of Beautyberry and is in nursery production all over the Eastern US. It has leaves which range between 10cm x 4cm (about 4" x 1.5") and only lightly pubescent beneath and the peduncles(flower stalks) are 8cm to 12cm(about 3" to 4.7") long, while the American Beautyberry has leaves which range as large as 20cm x 10cm(8" x 4") and are (more) pubescent beneath and peduncles which are mostly sessile(right snug up on the branch).

    My Japanese Beautyberry has seedlings popping up all over within about 15'(4.5m) of the original plant and I've read similar reports of it spreading by seed in other parts of the USA. I've actually read a nursery account of it popping up by seed in pots all over the greenhouse that the Japanese Beautyberry was in, so much so that it was being discontinued because the problem was getting to be too much for the grower to deal with. So, I think you got it right in that it probably hitched a ride to your place as a seed in the pot/soil along with your Louisiana Iris.

  • 18 years ago

    I hope this isn't going to be another Asian invasive!!!
    We're already overgrown with Japanese honeysuckle, Chinese privet, and in some areas, Asian kudzu.
    I think I better pull this stuff up!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Forgot to mention Chinese tallow trees - I pull them up every day. Sometimes I feel like giving up and letting the various Asian invasives battle it out! :(
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Sherry: Yes, I do love trees but I have far more experience responding to people who send angry, nasty emails.

    We have several web sites so I've been answering email from strangers since the early 1990s. Ninety-nine percent are neutral or favorable, one percent are the opposite - sarcastic, belittling. I've met some of these folks later - they are angry and obsessional. Because they have to be right, they blame others ("Your message wasn't clear.").

    The anonymity of email or forums changes the nature of communication. Because people do not communicate face-to-face, it's easier for bullies to do their thing. Once you recognize the personality type, it's easier to ignore them or write them and their comments off as more of the same. If you try to placate them, it just makes things worse.

    RE: the seedlings - I planted over 1,000 in late March. If all goes well, I'll have a large single species grove of bald cypresses and two single species groves of longleaf pines. Some seedlings have leafed out, others still look like sticks. It's mid-May so this concerns me. I'm hoping that some are just slow by nature and take longer to leaf out than similar trees that grow naturally here - like the tupelo, swamp tupelo, dogwood, some oaks. If I'm wrong, I'll have many gaps to fill next year!

    I'm thinking about posting a progress report and asking for advice from folks who have more experience with various seedlings.
    Pam

  • 18 years ago

    I agree Pam, text is so impersonal that people dont feel constrained by social norms. I mean really, its rare to find someone who will insult you to your face (in my experience) but people are more bold when they do it behind your back. The internet and its insults are also easy in a behind-the back sort of way.

    I like to consider myself knowledgeable on some plant aspects but I try really hard not to come off as a know-it-all. I know I fail sometimes but compared to when I first joined this place I think I have made good progress.

    I would love to see you post a progress report. I was wondering how your plants were doing because last I heard you had too many to get in the ground fast enough.

  • 18 years ago

    I have nothing to add other than bboy came off sounding like a jack*ss.

  • 18 years ago

    That must be challenging, Pam, dealing with people on all those websites. I assume the websites are part of your work.
    Yes, fledgling, the internet is great in some ways, but it has given some people free rein that they didn't have before. If you get a few jerks on a forum, they can intimidate others from posting.
    I dug up the callicarpa dichotoma as well as I could, but the trunks were so imbedded with the iris, most of the roots are still there. At least I got up all the top growth, which will keep those flowers from making fruit/seeds. I may have to dig up the whole iris clump later if it keeps resprouting, which I'm sure it will.
    I don't need ANOTHER Asian invasive!!!!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    fledgeling & Sherry - When I see your posts and responses, I always read them. You are knowledgeable, curious, observant people. (Sherry, I'll never forget those photos of loggers you posted). You are also helpful and kind to people who have questions. When I first came here, Spruce was kind and asked many questions - this helped open my mind to new possibilities.

    To fledgeling, who lives in the Arctic (almost), and to Sherry, who lives in the tropics (almost) - thank you!! I've learned so much from you.

    Pam

    PS: I need to take photos before I post a progress report. I'll try to do that tomorrow. We had very high winds and heavy rain for several days, still having coastal flooding. The field where the seedlings live is like a bog but it drains fast. Things should be better tomorrow.

  • 18 years ago

    You're welcome, Pam! There's a core of people whose posts I enjoy also - yours, fledgling's, AlabamaTreeHugger's, esh_ga, jqpublic, and others, all from the old Confederacy except fledgling. Maybe we should secede, with fledgling as our honorary rebel! :)
    When you say coastal flooding, I hope you don't mean that salt water is washing up on your seedlings! I'm eagerly awaiting your progress report with pictures!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Wow, MissSherry! You were right about the Tree Forum having some "undesirables" or one undesirable here. Just had to check it out. We run into an "undesirable" on the Butterfly Forum frequently, who never asks a single question, knows the answer to everything about butterfly raising, and yet has never done so herself. Quick to put people down, etc.

    MissSherry, you definitely has a Japanese beautyberry. I have one, too. They do reseed, but I never find them doing so prolifically. I'm almost fed up with mine anyway. They like lots of water, or they flop on the ground, and it doesn't seem like the birds are really crazy about them anyway. You have so much land, though, that it may be hard to tell how invasive they might be.

    Don't worry - we love you on the Butterfly Forum!!!

    Susan

  • 18 years ago

    What a surprise to see you here Susan!
    I post on this forum some, because I'm still so involved in the hurricane recovery of my property, which involves mainly trees. I mainly post here in winter, when I'm planting trees and not doing much of anything butterfly related.
    There's more than one jerk on this forum - if you need to know who they are, I'll tell you in a private e-mail.
    I spent most of the day working in my garden, and, among other things, I spent a lot of time pulling that bleeping Japanese climbing fern off the fence, the fence that supports the pipevines, hops vines, passionvines, milkweed vines, Mexican flame vine and climbing roses. That's another Asian invasive I forgot to mention - they're everywhere in this part of the country. Neither American or Japanese beautyberry have much wildlife value. I found a hornworm on a native one several years ago, and the birds occasionally eat the pretty berries, but that's about it. This Asian beautyberry is certainly not worth the risk.
    Thanks for the kind words!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    The butterfly forum is weird because of its lack of arguments. I can say that I have been on several forums across the internet and the gardenweb butterfly forum (and gardenweb in general)is by far the most mellow.

    Here, I try to avoid reading any of the 'controversial' species posts. Most of the strife occurs over just a select few plants.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with fledgeling - these forums have far less conflict than most. Go to a few political forums or blogs! You'll realize how fortunate we are.

    Here are a few suggestions for dealing with the occasional hostile person you meet online.

    Don't try to placate them or re-explain your question or statement. They don't care about you or your problem, nor are they motivated by a desire to help. They will view your attempts to explain as a sign of weakness and will attack you again. They are not introspective (they don't wonder, "what did I do wrong").

    When they offer advice, the underlying message is usually a putdown - that you are stupid for asking the question. Ignore them. Completely. They can't fight with air. They are usually embroiled in battles with several other people. If you don't take the bait, they will move on to easier prey.

    You have more control over how things evolve than you realize. If you know a person has a history of hostile, negative responses to others, don't solicit their advice. If they do offer advice, say "thank you," and nothing else. When you see a post by them, don't respond. If you receive an email, hit the delete key.

    Nothing bad will happen if you don't take the bait.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with that Pam!
    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    in defense of bboy (and no disrespect to sherry), i just don't see where the replies are insulting/hostile. it appears (as he wrote) that he "did not follow the original post" as was intended. that statement should have suppressed the negative remarks that have followed. it's not always easy to read someone's tone through text only and i think this one has been misinterpreted.
    his replies are normally succinct and technical in content rather than placatory as some folk (usually newcomers) seem to expect from a post requesting information/help.

  • 18 years ago

    I find these forums to be pretty peaceful. I have no enemies here.

    Yahoo News had a very popular comment section under each news story but the acrimony was so bad, Yahoo stopped it entirely. A shame because you did occasionlly find a "back story" or perspective that was not necessarily politically correct but still interesting.

    Someday I want to get into moths and butterflys.

  • 18 years ago

    You guys are obsessed over nothing. I've been beaten up many times on the Hot Topics forum, I let it bead up and roll off my back. I dare anyone to post on the Kitchen/Bath forum and criticize granite, go ahead.
    Wouldn't this be a boring place if everyone was like Polyanna? On American Idol, did you ever hear of anyone quote Paula Abdul? The only opinion worth quoting is Simon Cowell.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals