Software
Houzz Logo Print
ann45305

Best compost for fertilizer

18 years ago

We are planning on using mushroom soil for mulch this year.

I was also thinking my roses and some other plants might benefit from some compost as a fertilizer. Will the mushroom soil work for both purposes, or is there another

type of compost I should use to nourish my perennials and vegetable garden?

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    Well to start, if you have done some reading here you'll have run into the statement that "compost is not fertilizer, it is a soil amendment". That is true. Compost feeds the bacteria and micro-organisms in the soil and the soil feeds the nutrients it contains to the plants. ;)

    Compost is also not the same thing as mulch. And to really confuse the discussion, mushroom soil isn't the same thing as either compost or mulch. ;)

    So what you have is nutritionally exhausted compost that was used to grow mushroom - at least that is what "mushroom soil" usually is. It will be a great soil amendment for improving the tilth and texture of your soil if worked into it. But as a mulch, which goes on top of the soil, it is far from ideal because of its fine texture. What are your goals for mulching? Weed control? Moisture stabilization?

    And it isn't a fertilizer so for your perennials and vegetable garden, what is best to use depends on what the soil they are growing in needs in the way of nutrients - nitrogen, phosphorous, potassium, micronutrients. Have you had your soil tested? If so, and it shows good levels of nutrients, then a good layer of fresh, unused compost on top the soil will be of great benefit.

    But if your soil is lacking in nutrients then other sources such as alfafa meal, cottonseed meal, greensand, bone meal, etc. need to be considered.

    I hope this isn't too confusing? If so, think of it this way - add the mushroom soil to improve the soil texture, or add fresh compost to improve the soil over all, but add the other sources of nutrients if that is what is needed. Ok?

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    . DO NOT use mushroom compost or "fresh" manure when planting bare root roses, as it will burn the roots. Neither mushroom compost nor manure should be used to hill up roses in the fall either.

    Compost has too many "ifs" "ands and "buts" to be considered a fertilizer. Better to use what you understand to help your roses and other plants by the use of inorganic fertilizers made for such explicit uses.
    But, do use compost to amend the soil and thereby help the plant by improvement of soil structure and air and water retention.

  • 18 years ago

    Compost, in any form, is a good soil amendment and all plants will benefit from having compost added to the soil. In clay soils the compost gets in between the clay soil particles, seperates them, and greatly improves the soils workability which will allow both water and nutrients to get into the soil easier and the plants roots will be able to move around to find the necessary moisture and nutrients so they will grow better. All that said there can be differences in compost and not all "mushroom compost" is all that good, but if the compost you buy smells like good rich earth it will be fine for you to use.

  • 18 years ago

    You can use mushroom soil as a soil amendment anywhere on anything - including roses and veggies. It may have a fair amount of peat in it, so if you're using it as mulch on top of the soil, watch how it behaves when wet after you spread it.

    That said, I think soil benefits from having different types of organic material applied from time to time so, mushroom soil this year, horse manure or alfalfa pellets or leaf mulch (etc., etc.) next year.

  • 18 years ago

    I will beg to differ with those that say mushroom compost or any compost is not fertilizer. It may not be fast acting soluble fertilizer but it does provide slow nutrients though maybe not that much nitrogen.

    Do a little research about your mushroom soil since they can vary quite a bit from source to source and the type of mushrooms being grown. The methods will vary from farm to farm.

    Here is the experience I have had with the mushroom compost I get from the mushroom farm a few miles from me. It is horse manure composted with straw and some other additives. After composting (probably not very long) they load it into the beds in the building and steam sterilize it all. They grow mushrooms in it for a while and then steam sterilize it again before hauling it out of the building and selling it really cheap ($5 for a big trailer load here.) This stuff is not that far from having been manure, hay and straw. It still looks much like it did when hauled away from the horse farms. It is still a bit smelly. That said, I have used it extensively in my gardens and the plants have grown great!!! It is probably not good to mound up a steamy pile of it around a tender plant but the herbs, sunflowers, squash, zucchini, cucumbers, melons, broccoli, onions, carrots, spoon mustard, turnips, parsnips, bananas, papayas, sweet potatoes, marigolds, bamboo, soy beans, and snow peas have all grown famously with it as their "soil". The beds that were mostly mushroom compost with little other mulch materials grew great this past season with no extra fertilizer.

    I lasagna garden, all my beds started out as cardboard covered weedy lawn covered in layers of mulch, compost and mushroom compost. My natural soil here is sand and fine sand, the joke around here is that gardening in the native soil is like hydroponics, the sand holds the plant up and we have to provide everything else. However, planting in the mulch, especially the mushroom compost has worked very well for me.

    I don't know what your "mushroom soil" is like but I say test it out a bit and carefully see what it does for you.

    Here is a link that might be useful: TCLynx

  • 18 years ago

    As has been exhaustively mentioned elsewhere, mostly by me and now tclynx, compost is a fertilizer. Those disagreeing, please feel free to explain how one can use compost as a medium and never add extra fertilizer. You aren't amending soil, so what are you doing? Compost tea is sometimes used as a hydroponic nutrient solution alone and a lot of people use it to supplement existing nutrient solutions (like me). Why? BECAUSE IT'S HIGH IN NUTRIENTS!!! And amending soil (which means changing it's composition to increase fertility), by the way, includes fertilizing so how have some people gotten so confused that they are different things? Not all soil amendments are fertilizers, but fertilizers for ground applications are certainly soil amendments. I still say marketing has heavily influenced too many people to dupe them into buying more product than is necessary.

    I would add the mushroom soil to compost. So, why mushroom soil anyway? Is it used or fresh? I don't really see why you couldn't use it as a dressing at all. If you till it into the soil, I'd do so in the fall or several weeks before planting. But that's only if it's fresh and not been depleted. I grew mushrooms once and the used soil went right on my flower garden. The flowers flourished better than the rest of my flowers. Could have been coincidence, though. Didn't try a controlled experiment.

  • 18 years ago

    Not to start another semantics argument, but I do not really consider mushroom compost as compost. The process is that compost is made to grow mushrooms in; it isn't composted mushrooms or anything of that sort. The compost is loaded up with urea, pesticides etc. to grow the mushrooms. After a number of crops of mushrooms the quality and quantity declines and it is then hauled out as 'spent' compost which is what gardeners buy. It is so loaded up with synthetic fertilizers that it is considered 'hot' and will burn plants if used heavily. 'Aged' spent compost (meaning it sat outside in a pile for a year or so) is considered more desirable because rain will have leached out much of the soluble salts (nutrients)making act more like compost. The down side is that aged spent compost tends to have more weed seed. This is also why there is so much variability in the nutrient analysis. In summery, spent mushroom compost is not comparable to what gardens make. It is more of a compost fertilizer mix (and by fertilizer I mean concentrated soluble salts).

  • 18 years ago

    Joe, I don't believe anyone is specifically disagreeing with you that compost or other organic materials are indeed valid plant nutrient sources. They just do not conform to the accepted horticultural, or for that matter, legal definition of a "fertilizer". I think we are all tending to get hung up on semantics rather than understanding the intent. Any organic material is a potential plant nutrient source, some better/more concentrated than others, i.e. compost, mushroom compost, composted manures, etc. I'd not consider any of them especially high in nutrients - they are not in comparison to commercial synthetic ferts - but they do supply a wide range of necessary nutrients and typically in quantities more than adequate for healthy plant growth. They simply most often lack the NPK guaranteed analysis that qualifies them as a true "fertilizer" and allows them to be labeled and sold as such.

    Maybe we should just refer to all of these - ferts, both organic and inorganic, as well as most common organic matter - as nutrient sources and skip the specific designations of 'fertilizer', 'soil amendment', whatnot, that seem to be causing so much confusion/dissent.

  • 18 years ago

    No experience with mushroom compost. But I do grow my vegies in almost 100% compost, and they are so big and healthy and fast growing that I am afraid they will grab me sometimes when I walk by the biggest raised bed. :-) Jeannie7 for some reason doesn't like compost, so most of what she says about compost should be ignored completely.

    I can assure you that my compost is providing exquisite fertile soil for my vegies and some flowers. They are as happy as can be, and I NEVER apply inorganic fertilizer, evidently because I am not too dumb to understand compost, that seems to be what Jeannie7 is saying?!? She always puzzles me.

    Marcia, compost defender

  • 18 years ago

    I will be the first to say that one needs to check out any purchased "compost" or "mushroom compost" before investing too much in it since compost from one sources is going to be very different than compost from another source. This is why I gave an extensive description of the mushroom compost I get here in central Florida and my experiences with it. I have to say sometimes is it not only perhaps chemically still hot but because of the sterilization, I have unloaded physically hot mushroom compost before (that was a steamy morning of work too.) This facility only grows 1-2 crops of mushrooms on a batch of compost. I think this may be more do to issues with competing fungus and bacteria than the compost being spent. Perhaps using mushroom compost isn't really "organic" but it is a pretty good option in my location since the mushroom farm is only a few miles away.

    I say use the mushroom compost if you have it on hand this year. Definitely home made compost with a variety of materials is a better balanced compost and better as fertilizer but few people have as much compost as they would like.

    Here is a link that might be useful: TCLynx

  • 18 years ago

    I agree that the issue is partly one of semantics but it is an important distinction to make unless one is going to go into a long, detailed explanation.

    Compost is not fertilizer in the conventional sense and labeling it such only adds to the confusion for those who don't understand those finer distinctions. Nutrient-poor soil isn't going to suddenly develop adequate nutrients for anything planted in it simply because some compost has been added to it. Over time, substantial time with substantial additions of compost, of course. But quick fix nutrients is the role of fertilizer be it organic or inorganic, not compost.

    So the terms "Compost" and "Fertilizer", as that label is conventionally used are not interchangeable.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, I get what you are saying, but I have to disagree with the "substantial time" part of it. If you make a raised lasagna bed you have excellent soil in almost no time, and it sure doesn't need any 'fertilizer' added to it, assuming the initial ingredients had some good variety. So you can be growing in a nutrient rich compost-soil with no waiting.

    For some reason I thought of a good analogy today for compost and fertilizer while at a child's birthday party. Compost is your healthy diet with lots of fruits, vegies, and whole grains. Fertilizer is the vitamin you have to take if you eat a lot of junk and don't eat your vegetables. You don't need the vitamins (fertilizer) if you are on the healthy diet (lots of compost in your soil) in the first place.

    This analogy helps explain why what jeannie7 is trying to tell us is silly. She thinks that since we don't know the exact nutrient value of any particular orange, we are better off taking a vitamin C tablet, and not eating the orange.

    Marcia

  • 18 years ago

    if compost is not for fertilization, then (1.)what is the purpose in compost tea???

    plus, i don't know if any of you ever watch Gardening by the Yard, but the host, (2.)Paul James says he uses only compost tea to fertilize his container plants.

  • 18 years ago

    "Compost tea" according to Dr. Ealine Ingham takes the nutrients and other best parts of your compost and converts that into a foliar food that you plants can utilize faster, although the whole concept of foliar feeding is somewhat suspect anyway. If someone is just getting their soil properly prepared, making and spraying compost tea may be something necessary, but if ones soil is in good condition there will be no difference and making and spraying that tea would generally be a waste of time and energy.

  • 18 years ago

    My take on it is compost used as a noun is really not a good distinctive concept. It is so ambiguous one could say it is this or that. Compost used as a verb for a particular material is much better. All composting really means is allowing an organic material to decompose for eventual use of growing something else.
    One could use a term like well bended compost that may include grass, leaves, wood ash, coffee grounds, tea bags, kitchen scraps, egg shells, weed vegetation etc. This material provides an all around medium for most crops. The problem for me is getting enough of it and since I recently moved I had none from the year before the first year. I do have bone meal and blood meal that I use sparingly especially because of this.
    In some cases the compost my be considered so rich like guano or worm castings it is added as a "fetilizer". Fish emulsion is essentially composted fish and it certainly not really a soil amendment. American Indians are said to have used fish to fertilize corn. This however feeds the soil organisms as well just like compost. Composted fish is really a fertilizer for intended use.

    Here is a recipe in this forum.

    http://faq.gardenweb.com/faq/lists/organic/2002080041031662.html

    The opening statement reads.

    "As you may know fish emulsion, fish meal, seaweed/kelp meal, and liquid seaweed/kelp are some of the most powerful natural fertilizers and soil amendments in the world."

    On the flip side leaf mold is composted leaves. This material creates a soil that holds moisture etc and only a little nitrogen. So its the material being composted that is important as well as the intention of its use. Mulch is only mulch when used as a mulch. Leaves in a compost pile are not mulch but then again leaves or partially composted leaves may be used as a mulch which will eventually become part of the soil.
    So as far as I am concerned compost ranges from a soil medium to a fertilizer and anything in between depending on what is being composted and how it is intended to be used. If composting occurs in the garden depending on what it is it may range from burning plants from too much nitrogen as in hot horse manure to nitrogen depleting wood chips.