Software
Houzz Logo Print
leftycatcher

Smelly soil from Lowe's

18 years ago

Hi All ~

Need some quick help here on my new raised lasagna bed.

I purchased bags of soil mix with fertilizer ("Stay-Green Flower & Veg Planting Mix) from Lowe's to top off the new bed. The smell was pretty pungent as I was driving home (son complained the whole way home that it smelled like manure).

After spreading over the bed this morning, I thought it smelled like a cow barn. Read the ingredients, and no mention of manure (is it classified as something else?). The smell then permeated the house, coming in through windows. (I don't mind the smell while I'm visiting the farm, but don't want to bring it home into my bedroom.)

I phoned the company "United Industry" in GA. I was informed the product is not supposed to smell, and that I should't use it, "It may be contaminated". "With what?" I asked, and kept getting the party line, don't use it, don't plant in it.

The company offered cash refund after I mail receipt and UPC labels from each bag, and suggested I have the soil tested.

Investigated the soil testing. Aside from the $9 cost (almost the cost of 2 bags soil), and the 2-3 week time lag (it's mid July, for Pete's sake!), the soil test does not test for hazardous materials or contaminants-only heavy metals, nitrogen, etc.

Called company back and complained louder, and now they've offered to mail me a UPS label so I can send them a soil sample to have THEM test it. That made me feel a little better, but when I asked if, in 3 weeks when I'm ready to pick zucchini, could they tell me then if the soil was hazardous or not, they were very wishy-washy as to if and when I'll get a report on the findings.

So now I'm angry! After all the work of building my new garden...! Even if I do plant in it, which I will, I'll always be worrying it's tainted.

The place that does the soil testing said it's probably fine, and the company is just covering its butt. But it made me start wondering how these soil mixtures are made, if/how manure is added, and could they possibly be tained with salmonella? Where can I call to find out? Should I contact the CDC or whatever gov't entity that is investigating the current tomato/pepper/cilantro crisis?

The clock is ticking, July is half over and I want to get this bed planted!

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    It's all going to depend on how comfortable you will be using it. Personally, I wouldn't have any problems with it at all.

    Anaerobic odors like this are common with mixes sold bagged in plastic and stored where they can get wet and exposed to the sun but can't get air. Same thing can happen in a compost bin, with any garden soil bagged and stored the same way, bags of dried leaves stored in plastic bags, etc. In fact the same thing can happen in the garden itself under certain conditions.

    With a bit of time to dry out and some air exposure the odor disappears and the mix is fine to use. Mix it in well with the other ingredients and plant.

    If manure isn't listed on the bag as an ingredient then it is a pretty safe bet that there is no manure in it. But even if there was, it isn't a problem as it has been composted. The only prohibition is using fresh, uncomposted manure in vegetable gardens but many of us use well-composted manures in the garden all the time.

    So it's up to you. If it is going to worry you too much then it isn't worth the hassle for you. But no, I do not think you should call the CDC. ;) We have all had stinky soil bags at one time or another and all they need is air exposure and drying out to be perfectly fine and safe to use.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    ya i totally agree with that one!! i don't like them vege one's. had the same problem. so now i only use the stay green but i get the aqua control. its in the green bag. i like it much better don't stink AND>>>>> its 3cu ft for 10.99 i LOVE that!! LOL and of course, you know, it feeds for 9 months. so that's a plus for me!! LOL ~Medo

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the replies, guys! This site never disappoints.

    I've bought only Mir Gro bagged soil in the past, and never encountered this smell. It smells like fresh dung. There were also several (not a lot) soft, moist, brown clumps that looked suspiciously like manure.

    If the manufacturer had said all the same things you said, Dave, I would be totally fine. But twice I called, talked to two different people, and twice told not to use the soil. "Possibly contaminated" was their choice of words, not mine. Made me wonder, contaminated how, and with what? I can't imagine the garden soil industry is closely monitored or even frequently inspected; who knows what goes in the stuff?

  • 18 years ago

    I've encountered bagged mulch that smelled like pretty nasty manure. The other half once stockpiled bags of grass clippings (hidden in with the bagged leaves) an I kept wondering where the strong manure smell kept coming from till I discovered the bags of nasty grass clippings. I've even caused alfalfa pellets to smell like manure by adding water and leaving in a bucket for a few days. Attracted flies and maggots and everything. Most any strong source of Nitrogen can very take on a strong, nasty manure smell if placed in a wet, airless environment.

    This is why most of the $$ soil mixes are bagged up quite dry and you have to wet them well before planting. If they bagged them moist, they would not keep well.

    Personally, I would use it but if you are worried, then scrape it off if you can and plant without it or get some other bagged stuff and replace it. Another option might be to plant crops where the edible portion doesn't contact the soil. Tomatoes that are trained up off the soil, corn, beans, okra, eggplant, other climbing vining crops like cucumbers that you can train up off the soil.

  • 18 years ago

    If the "soil" you purchased smelled like cow manure there is a very good reason and that is because not completely composted cow manure was put into the mix and the "soil" got wet and was anaerobically digesting while you were driving home.

  • 18 years ago

    Kim,
    There was no manure listed on the ingredients!

    TC,
    Good idea re: planting crops that don't touch soil. But wouldn't whatever is in soil still be absorbed by the plants?

  • 18 years ago

    In my (mercifully limited) experience, anything anaerobic starts to smell like bad barnyard. (There is a good barnyard smell, too, in my opinion.)

    If I were you, I would let it air out for a few days and see what happens. This might comfort you, or it might not: if it were contaminated with, for example, lead or arsenic, it wouldn't smell funny. And if it were contaminated with industrial chemicals, it would smell like industrial chemicals. The "do not use!" instructions from the manufacturer are almost certainly because they don't want to get sued.

    But, if you'd rather feel extra safe than sorry, then do not use. Or if you can't sleep at night without worrying about your zucchini. Whatever level of risk you, personally, you, yourself, feel comfortable with.

  • 18 years ago

    I purchased the same stuff recently. I don't think anything is wrong with it. Think about it, you have organic materials breaking down in a very closed environment. It is going to smell. If it smelled like mold or ammonia, I would worry. Manure? Even though they do not list it, I am sure it is indirectly put in there. I Do not remember what is listed as ingredients on the bags but if it has composted materials (or a general vague dsecription), there may be manure in there.

    That stuff is all I used last year, and I had great results! Actually, now my neighbor is using it.

    I will never buy the Miracle Gro soil ever again after finding pallet chunks, rocks and pieces of plastic bags, from competing mulch companies in the bag.

    I think you are making more of a situation out of it than it really is.

  • 18 years ago

    Greengardener,
    I essentially agree with all you said. Just wish the manufacturer had not used the word "contaminated".

  • 18 years ago

    Lefty,

    I really think what that smell is coming from goes back to what I said before, a closed "environment" (the bag), with organic materials breaking down. Think of a bunch of grass clippings covered up, they can really stink!

    I feel your concern too. That contaminated comment would make me concerned, but they maybe be following "the book" when it comes to those type of complaints. You had a test done and it seems fine.

    Like some others said, you can remove it and put other stuff down, but it is entirely your choice. The bags that I bought (same product) last week smelled like that when I got them. I put them in the garage to dry/air out and now they smell fine. I have been using them to no ill effects

    Good luck with what you decide.

  • 18 years ago

    Some people think any putrid odor is a manure smell but if this material did smell like manure it had manure in it. If it was some other putrid odor that would not be a manure odor. As Alfie alluded the odor would indicate what was in that stuff and different materials do have different odors.
    I am aware that there are many people so disconnected with anything rural that they do not know what manure does smell like, just as there are many people so disconnected with nature that they must spray something for any insect they see.

  • 18 years ago

    OK - here's the f/u...

    My dog is now eating the clumps in the soil (which to me signifies manure), and this morning I noticed it has begun growing MOLD across the top of the soil.

    Is this normal?

    BTW - I am quite familiar with using manure in the garden. I live near a farm, and one of my children actually attends an agricultural high school. But there is just something a little different about this smell...something a bit more offensive than just natural "farm" smell, which I happen to kind of like.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio