Software
Houzz Logo Print
just1morehosta

Thompson & Morgan Seed

17 years ago

Hi every one,

Ok, i addmite, i am new to ordering seeds,i ordered -Primula-'You and Me Blue', from Thompsom & Morgan,i just opened the pack, i was so excited,i prepaired a nice container of soil,in a milk jug,thinking i would get a good sized planting,HA!

Do you know how many seed were in this pack,,FOR $5.95!

20,YES,COUNT THEM,20!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I want more than 20 of this flower,it's beaytiful,and unusual,i guess that is why so much$$$$, huh?

Is this a common pratice with seed companys?Are there some out there better than others, ( other than you guys ) :0)

I am so in shock right now.

Carol

Comments (21)

  • 17 years ago

    Carol,

    Actually, I think you got a bargain. Consider the fact that if all those seeds germinate, you will have paid .30 cents for each plant. If only 50% germinate, then it's .60 cents.

    OK, Carol, I just googled it thinking I might be putting my foot in my mouth, but I'm not. That is a precious gem if I've ever seen one!!! Well worth it!

    In the last few days I have been checking out Gardens North and writing my 'wants' from them. Lots of seeds are 15/$3.50 or 20/$4.25. Yes, the price is a bit off the cuff, but I know that if I go to the exchange forums I will likely not get any response for the seeds I want and if I do, the trader cannot guarantee me that there was no cross-pollination so in essence I may not get a true plant.

    I won't tell you the amount of my present GN wants, but will say that I'm going to have to make choices... Oh, that hurts!! :O)

  • 17 years ago

    Oh my gosh! If you got 20 seeds, count yourself lucky! The site says 12 seeds! When you consider shipping into the equation, that is an outrageous amount of money for 12 seeds, and not much better for 20! I just hope they all sprout for you, they really are beautiful!

    I try to justify spending way too much on seed, by thinking of how much I am actually saving by not having to buy the plants. At least that's what I tell my husband! It's a darn good thing he loves me!:)

  • 17 years ago

    I use these same justifications for buying seeds as mentioned by Tiffy and Nancy.

    Trading is fine for some common open polinated seeds, but it's nice to treat myself to a few new purchaced gems, too.

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    Thompson and Morgan always gives more seeds than the packet lists. Their 'cherry brandy' rudbeckia pack of mine, 141 seeds. Should have been 50. Now don't get me started on the ripoff that Park Seeds has carried out with me. In one pack of what was supposed to be 100, there was only 22. And a 50 pack that had 11. Just be sure to baby those suckers until you can collect your own seeds.

  • 17 years ago

    Don't get me started on Park Seed either! I've ordered from them since before 2000 and this past year's order is the last one I'm ever placing with them. Bleah - what a fiasco! Never ever again. And this is from a customer that used to really like that company.

    Carol, one of the reason a lot of those seeds are so expensive is because people expect to buy cleaned seed when it comes from a commercial seed supplier. A lot of the types of seed that you can save by the bag full (with a little chaff) and trade by the thousand on garden web can be very costly to process and sell as cleaned seed - especially when the seeds are very small.

    Some other types are expensive because there might be only a very short time between when the seed ripens and when the plant drops the seed. You might have to pay a good deal for just a few seeds, but get the plant going in your garden and it will pop out seeds and self sow them faster than you can find them. :)

    I also think there are some plants that are very popular, germinate easily, and are super easy to seed save so the seed companies know that you are only going to buy them once and they better get your money while they can!

    Lynda

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks all,
    The seed is the size of pepper,so you think it was a good buy then,ok,now i feel "a little better"

    Tiffy,i think i understand,i planted these seed,so i know they will be ture,correct?
    What about the seed i collect from these plants in the fall,will they still be concidered true?
    I am not sure how i will even do this,as,like i said,they are so darn TINY.

    It is a very pretty plant isn't it. :0)
    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    T&M seems to be hit and miss both in terms of how many they give you and how good their germination is in my experience. My best experiences have been with Swallowtail and Pinetree and select seeds.

    You still will end up with gardens looking like you spent thousands of dollars, and you'll have spent far less than that even if you indulge in some expensive seeds.

  • 17 years ago

    Carol.

    Yes, they will be true. The seeds you collect may not come true since the bees will have loved them and possibly cross-pollinated them with other primulas. Now you may not have other primulas in your gardens, but maybe a neighbour does and those bees aren't fussy when it comes to going from one place to another and rubbing their little derrieres in pollen. :O)

    They are a lovely primula. Reminds me of the Blue Himalayan Poppies.

  • 17 years ago

    I know Tiffy,
    They reminded me of H.Blue Poppies also,i hope i will be able to collect the seed,this is all so much fun,and so new,AND,so much to learn,it is a good way to look at the seed count,like you said,30 cents if all germinate-60 cents,if 1/2 do,way cheeper than a plant bought from the nursery,i was just in shock though when i opened the pack and saw so few seeds,they did not even fill a corner of the envie.ha ha
    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    I've been burned by Park's with the low seed counts, too. Between that and their exhorbitant shipping/handling charge, I've about had it with them. I didn't order anything from them this year.

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    I ordered from Parks last year, and although the germination was pretty good overall, I agree that they were skimpy on the quantity of seeds. Especially in the case of something like Snapdragon 'Black Prince', which made a lot of seeds per stalk, and was easy to collect. I probably won't be ordering from them again either, unless I get an irresistable urge for a few seeds that aren't available anyplace else.

  • 17 years ago

    Glad to see it's not just me with Park. This was my first and last time ordering from them.

  • 17 years ago

    For their prices, I do think T&M can be a bit stingy with seed counts, but their selection is so fabulous, and customer service is great too - I probably finance their employees' summer vacations. I also assist Tiffy in doing the same with Gardens North - worth spending the money on!

    One place I've always gotten high seed counts - usually enough to trade many times over - is Swallowtail Gardens. And Pinetree Gardens usually packs a small seed pack (peas and beans excluded, you get lots of those) but adjusts their price to reflect that. The theory is most likely that the average suburban gardener doesn't need 100 of any one kind of marigold - so I order a lot from them, too.

    Hope that helps,

    Kim, who is off to make a Gardens North wish list now...

  • 17 years ago

    Then there are places like cheapseeds.com. 7,000 gloriosa daisy seeds for $3 and free shipping.

    I've had excellent germination of the seeds I've tried from them, though they are pretty much limited to easy, no-brainer types. Can't beat the price/seed, though.

    Sometimes it's nice to have a few huge stashes to give away without breaking the bank and without the work of growing, harvesting, cleaning, packing them.

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    I just left the Gardens North website. Spent quite a bit of time there, since they have a huge selection, including many rare perennials. I could live with paying about $4 per pack, but then it was going to be another $12.50 for shipping and phytosanitary fee. So I would have paid over $50 for 8 packets of seeds! THAT COMES TO MORE THAN $6 PER PACK!!!

    So Carol, maybe $5.95 for 20 seeds isn't that bad afterall, LOL.

    I may have a serious seed addiction, but I could not justify that much money, for that few packets, no matter how rare and unusual they are. I do realize it's a little cheaper for those who live in Canada, but sheesh.

    Bonnie

  • 17 years ago

    $12.50,just for shipping?Highway robery!

    Ya sure better pay attention to every thing eh?
    I guess we should order the more unusual ones,collect the seed,and trade for other unusuall ones.

    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    Some of our nurseries carry a few T & M seeds so I have been able to support my local nursery and avoid the shipping costs.

  • 17 years ago

    googled up a picture

    {{gwi:349597}}

    yummie

  • 17 years ago

    mlcom, it's very pretty. What is it?

  • 17 years ago

    Primula-'You and Me Blue' via Thompsom and Morgan

    sorry for life of me cant figure out how to edit my last post

    YUMMIE

    ML

  • 17 years ago

    I ordered from a site that got horrible Watch Dog reviews and then panicked, since I had promised them to seed traders, and ordered duplicates from a number of other sites, including T&M. Happily, ALL orders arrived within days on one another. The T&M order had WAY more seeds then expected, and way more then the other vendors, expect for one pack, which had the same amount as the other vendor.

    I hope my rambling makes sense. Based on my direct comparison and although shipping seemed steep, I am very happy with T&M.

    BTW - their new catalog has some WONDERFUL varieties

Sponsored