Software
Houzz Logo Print
melissa_thefarm

Will I ever have 'friable' soil?

16 years ago

I was out checking the soil of the Damask bed (it started as the Gallica bed but most of the Gallicas wouldn't grow there and met more or less unhappy ends), and sure enough the ground under the decaying hay mulch has deep, wide cracks in it from the last few weeks without rain. Now, this bed has been religiously mulched with thick layers of hay ever since we started the bed back in 2005; in fact, at the start I dug out much of the ground and layered it with great armloads of hay, optimistically thinking it would help. It didn't help particularly as far as I could tell. This was admittedly poor ground even by the standards of our garden: a gray clay so nearly pure that even Bermuda grass had a hard time growing in it, and moldable when wet. So now, five years later, how is this ground? It has cracks, and is hard, and although underneath the hay there's a thin fine layer of composted hay, clay and organic matter seem to remain separate and not meld together into dirt. Here and there the clay looks a little more porous than it used to. So who knows what it takes to make friable dirt. But plants grow in it now, old roses and aromatic plants, iris, pinks and peonies and surprisingly a couple of clematis look happy. So I guess it's all alright.

Melissa

Comments (32)

  • 16 years ago

    Well yes Melissa, it is. You are a gardener through and through and you do know what you are doing - which is to make the very best of what you have. This is what differentiates you from either a collector or a mere shopper. We all start with hopes and dreams but hopefully learn that a true gardener will grow plants which thrive in the conditions we have. We can always try and muck about with soil (ha ha) but can do nothing about climate, geography (and finances, usually) so even the most optimistic (delusional) ones will eventually realise that they, and their plants are suffering from innappropriate lust and unreasonable expectations (apart from those of us in denial) And anyway, roses, as you know, are perfectly happy in clay. If you had sand, you would be growing burnet roses and maquis plants and if you were in damp peat, you would find yourself craving rare rhodies, meconopsis, primulas, ligularias....and so on. Unless we are either REALLY dim, have hearts of stone or bottomless sources of hard cash, we have to either find imaginative solutions (bodges) or transfer our affections to a more forgiving object of desire (unless, of course, we have unresolved masochistic tendencies). So hey, I guess it is alright.

  • 16 years ago

    Campanula has said it all--and rather perfectly. May I copy it and pass it around.

  • 16 years ago

    *** a true gardener will grow plants which thrive in the conditions we have.

    *** inappropriate lust and unreasonable expectations

    Thank you, Melissa, for mentioning Damasks. You made me look which made me want. And Suzy, you presented the dilemma. HOWEVER, helpmefind offered the rescue... Autumn Damask. It is successfully grown in Florida. Can it possibly be part burnet rose?

    Melissa, keep workin' that hay.

    Well said, Suzy.

    Sherry

  • 16 years ago

    Hm, I wonder what I should be growing in decomposed granite. Rock roses?

    Campanula, we're indeed fortunate to have you in our midst.

    Ingrid

  • 16 years ago

    Melissa, I think it takes years and years to make poor clay soil into great clay soil. The same is true for sand soils, of course. It could be a lifetime's work. Meanwhile you are getting great results from your soil, and it is slowly improving.

    Rosefolly

  • 16 years ago

    If you dug hay into the clay the cracking might even have been due to settling. Just keep loosening the soil when you plant and maintaining a thick mulch at all times. It will improve if this state of affairs is kept up - same as in nature, where soil is built from raw ground by organic debris falling onto it and adapted plants growing in it, invading it with their roots. Very deep topsoil layers were built on the prairies just by grasses growing on them for a long time.

  • 16 years ago

    oh sherry - 'made me look, which made me want' - I am soooo familiar with that syndrome.
    Hey Ingrid, Rock roses? seriously! why not....and sun roses too. I have several cistus on my rubbish sandy 'soil' (I know, why am I persisting with roses).
    aaah Catsrose, you sweetie.
    Rosefolly, soil amendement is probably gonna take much longer than you or I will still be around so we should enjoy it while we can.
    Bboy, true, but it sounds like Melissa has acres and acres to maintain - blissful idleness trumps industrious virtue sometimes....but we have to try, i guess.

  • 16 years ago

    Suzy,
    I know exactly what you're talking about. I know that "Good soil is soil that will grow the plants the gardener wants to grow" (my own words). And as it happens I love roses and lavender and peonies--Heaven help me if I ended up in acid sandy terrain and had to make myself happy with heathers, or whatever it is that grows there. Or camellias and ginger lilies in Florida, though they're light years ahead of heathers.
    Our garden currently covers about an acre. In the past two years we've used over forty tons of hay in it, plus every bit of organic matter the garden has produced; and we've planted hundreds of plants, perhaps thousands of them. It's having an effect: the plants are growing, growing better than at the start; and the amount of recyclable organic matter it produces should increase exponentially. My initial post is an expression of impatience with my young, immature garden, the oldest portions of which are eight years old, but most of which has been planted since the beginning of 2005. And it's an expression of my desire, my longing, my lust for good dirt, to the point that sometimes I think the garden is just an excuse for soil improvement. Bboy, ALL our soil has cracks, not just this one bed where I dug the hay in. The ground does this every year when the dry season sets in.
    Patience, patience, patience. Patience is the word.
    Melissa

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Melissa

    It's very interesting to read your posts, and I try to remeber all the good solutions you find. It looks like you have great success already. It's very inspiring for us with not so ideal soil.

    I have a friend since childhood that has been gardening on a belt of clay since the late 70's. True clay is pretty rare around here. He and his wife started out with adding dried ground up seaweed to the soil, and cocoa shells from the near by chocolate factory. The cocoa husks are no longer available, since the factory don't dehusk the cocoa beans themselfs any more. Still my friend contributes the improvement in soil manly to the seaweed and other available organic material every year for decades. When his wife was still alive they used to grow red clover, lupines and grasses in lots continuously for several years to improve the soil. I still get inspired when I hear him talk about his garden and how things are growing.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Melissa, first of all, I think Campanula put it very well.

    Otoh, while the organics that you've added are feeding your plants wonderfully, if you're looking to improve the condition of your soil, I agree with bboy about the necessity of working the organics into the clay. What would be excellent is a riding tractor (lawn size) with a disc furrowing attachment to work in the organics when it's wet and workable. Or a large rototiller if it can dig in. Perhaps you have a neighbor or someone in the community that would have such a thing that you could trade services with so cost wouldn't be an issue.

    Growing clover or other cover crop is also an excellent idea, letting nature's roots open up the ground for you and add nitrogen if they are leguminous.

  • 16 years ago

    My point was rather that surface applications (mulching) should continue to be relied on instead of digging in soil amendments.

    "The Bottom Line
    Â Ideal soils, from a fertility standpoint, are generally defined as containing no more than 5% OM
    by weight or 10% by volume
    Â Before you add organic amendments to your garden, have your soil tested to determine its OM
    content and nutrient levels
    Â Be conservative with organic amendments; add only what is necessary to correct deficiencies and
    maintain OM at ideal levels
    Â Do not incorporate organic amendments into landscapes destined for permanent installations;
    topdress with mulch instead
    Â Abnormally high levels of nutrients can have negative effects on plant and soil health
    Â Any nutrients not immediately utilized by microbes or plants contribute to non-point source
    pollution"

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Myth of Soil Amendments, Part III

  • 16 years ago

    Melissa:\
    I remember the breathtaking photos you posted following your garden party. You certainly may not have friable soil yet but your gardening skills are making oodles of happy roses.
    Enjoy your garden.
    Jeannie

  • 16 years ago

    bboy, that's a great link/info and I wouldn't dispute any of it....

    However. I think that there's more than one issue of interest with the problem of 'cracked soil'. If I may say, your comments pertain to plant nutrition. What my microbiologist brain was thinking more of was soil tilth and condition. Not to mention, in California we worry a lot about watering and run-off. I know Melissa's not worrying about rain run-off, but I was thinking of it any-hoo.

    I found this article on my first click looking for info that reflected what I want to say. I can't say that I've verified all of the scientific info, but it pretty much reflects what I'm trying to do bit by bit with my decomposing granite (except for the cover crops) and what might help Melissa. The gist, is that it is a two part process, short and long term. Turning the soil with organics is only used in the very beginning to improve workability and discouraged later for the reasons that you mention. Cover crops are encouraged to let nature 'work the soil' in a better way than we can, etc.

    I hope everyone enjoys at least some of it as much as I did:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Improving clay soils

  • 16 years ago

    Here's a neat old idea

    Here is a link that might be useful: soil ammending made easy

  • 16 years ago

    I gave up day 1 as I had "rock" clay under 4 inches of house contractor "earth" ... digging holes would of been a major undertaking. So in came garden ties and "black earth". Now it is those 10 years old trees that are shrinking the garden through shading, root competition etc.. At one time I use to turn my peat moss used for protection into the earth but found quickly it decomposed to nothing and therefore did not added anything to "friablilty". Now I do not rake the leaves from the trees in the garden and just let them rot and turn them in every now and then. I must say even though shallow, I like how the texture has changed in some areas of the garden with the rot.

  • 16 years ago

    Good for you, Melissa! You've been talking about your hay mulch for a number of years and I am glad it is paying off. At any rate, if your plants are growing, that is true satisfaction for a gardener. Creating beauty where there was nothing before.

  • 16 years ago

    I've given up hope of ever having friable soil. I used to watch gardening programs on TV and envy the black soil the presenter could dig with her hands only and plant in. I've imported soil for the vegetable garden because no root vegetables could grow in my very heavy clay. But everything else seems to do okay and one comfort of clay is that it's rich in nutrients and holds water well. Fruit trees, roses, clematis, irises, even some of the less fussy lilies thrive.

  • 16 years ago

    An old trick for very compact heavy soil, is to grow potatoes. Next year the soil is easy to dig in, and amendments like compost or whatever one chooses blends in much easier. Potatoes might not be the most desireable plant, but the green leaves and white flowers doesn't look bad, and most people use potatoes now and then. When earth worms live happily in the soil, conditions are not that bad any more.

  • 16 years ago

    I think, with clay soil, a tool choice makes a lot of difference. I can't imagine gardening in clay without heart shaped hoe and clay fork.

    {{gwi:282399}}
    The heart shaped hoe usually is attached to a long handle and is very good to work between the bushes, to loosen the top layer of clay, also differently from normal hoe, it is a push tool. I found it to be very nice to mix in compost into the top layer of clay.

    {{gwi:282401}}

    Is what I use for digging, very useful tool and as well slices clay really easily. Can't imagine gardening without it in clay,it is so much more easy work than with a normal fork or shovel.

    Here is a link that might be useful: DeWit Tools

  • 16 years ago

    This is what we use in decomposing granite:

  • 16 years ago

    hehe I will need that if I ever decide to redo paths in clay, especially in dry season. x)

  • 16 years ago

    Cracking of dry clay is probably inevitable--it just swells and shrinks more than other soil types. However, I'm a little surprised that 5 years of heavy mulching hasn't done more to change the soil--I'd have guessed that for 2-3 inches down you'd see darkening and some crumb structure. But it will happen.

  • 16 years ago

    "However, I'm a little surprised that 5 years of heavy mulching hasn't done more to change the soil--I'd have guessed that for 2-3 inches down you'd see darkening and some crumb structure."

    I'm not surprised at all if it's 'soooo clay' that she can mold it and there has been no mixing between layers. Reason being, the organic layer is so very dissimilar to the clay layer. It's like layered cocktails, but a different principle. The drinks are layered because of different specific gravity and the soil is layered because of physical boundary - clay is not 'open' enough to integrate even minute organic particles, ergo, no mixing.

  • 16 years ago

    Even for heavy clay, growing alfalfa, red clover, various buck wheats and grasses for a five years in a row can absolutely change the soil completely. There are machines that can work even the heaviest and most compact of blue clay. Adding amendments are a must, and it does cost a bit, but it's not unreasonable costs. Renting big machinery might be the best way to go about it the first time, but it's only once and it does pay off.

    What makes the big difference is starting out with the plants that will grow and they absolute do great work on the soil. These are the weeds, like perennial red clover, dandelion, alfalfa. If things are, really difficult look for what kind of weeds and grasses that grow there naturally; and add them to the mix.

    There are different types of clay, some are naturally full of nutirents that makes a fertile soil that are easier to work with. Some types of clay are poor in available minerals and nutrients, and will require more fertilizer to start with.

    If larger roses and other bushes will grow in the clay these plants can stay around as ground cover, and it's really not a bad combination.

    Improvement will come within three years, and within 7 years things have improved a lot. It is a lot of work, and it takes time, effort and money, but if you live there it's all worth it. It should not take a life time, but accordng to some studies it will take 5-7 years.

  • 16 years ago

    I have some clay, and something I call "naturally occurring cement." It's really strange stuff. I've taking to buying bags of cheap topsoil, because at least the following year I can get my tools to go in to break up the soil and weed. I incorporated lots of horse manure, so now there are lots of worms. They drill strange holes in the naturally occuring cement. You dig up this chunk, which is similar to a rock, and there are holes drilled everywhere. I've never gardened anywhere where the dirt was this strange.
    There is a French name for it. When you want to work, you water the day before, then wait. The following day you can dig the soil.
    We're close to a river, and my mother used to say river dirt is dead dirt.

  • 16 years ago

    Lagomorph, as I understand it, mixing of organic matter into the topsoil isn't done by a passive sifting so much as by the action of earthworms and other soil fauna. Of course, if the soil is extremely dry for months, that would cut down on both the decay of the mulch and the presence of critters.

    There could be some physical sifting as OM causes soil crumbs to form at the surface of the soil.

  • 16 years ago

    Melissa, I'd say you are doing very well, if roses and other plants will grow in your amended soil after only 5 years. My garden is 105 years old, and the soil in most of the flower beds and other places where it has been cultivated is indeed wonderful. I didn't even realize we were on clay until one time I (I forget why) I tried to dig in a little area at the corner of the house where nothing had ever grown. Solid clay, I mean you could have made dishes out of it!

    Also, when we finally got around to doing something with the strip of land out between the street and the sidewalk we discovered our own cement. That area had been used for parking, and nothing had been done to it except weed killer and gravel. Impossible to dig, pick axes bounced off, it killed the rototiller, until finally my husband (who is a general contractor, thank heavens) got out his Jack hammer (as illustrated above). He put a shovel bit on it, and for 5 days he jackhammered the 6 ' x 60" area, mixing in redwood soil conditioner. Then I planed it all with ground cover roses, and they took off. Now it is 15 years later, the roses are still doing fine, and the soil under them is actually plantable - I stick in some bulbs in front of the roses. So, I think clay is a great foundation for good soil, but it certainly can be a chalenge! Keep doing what you are doing, and I'm sure it will get better over time, time being the most important ingredient.

    Jackie

  • 16 years ago

    "Of course, if the soil is extremely dry for months, that would cut down on both the decay of the mulch and the presence of critters. "

    michaelg, that's exactly it. If the inorganic layer cannot physically mix with the organic layer, then no progress is made. Optimally, in moist soil bacteria are *wicked* into the soil below and as you say earthworms do their great work.

    When Melissa described cracked soil, that is dry soil. Here in So Cal, we have something called 'adobe' clay which sounds a lot like that. While nutritious from a mineral standpoint, it is impossible to work with when dry and her question was friability. My point, was that if one does a starter intercollation (sp? ;-) of *coarse* organic matter into the surface layer, the organic **fiber** will draw even small amounts of moisture into the clay which will also bring soil bacteria and even earthworms down into it. If there is not even a small amount of moisture, there is still the organic matrix that the bacteria and worms can feed on. As the bacteria and worms go back and forth progress begins. (sorry about the *'s, I dunno how to html underline ;-) After all, bacteria and worms don't digest inorganic soil components.

  • 16 years ago

    Well. I appreciate this lively and informative commentary, some of which is slightly beyond me: that's why I hesitated about writing another set of remarks. I guess the case is that I want the soil to be able to support plant life more than I want it to be friable, though that would be, oh, "magical" may be the right word. Like Marianne said, soil you can plunge your hand into. Taoseeker, I hope you'll continue to find my thoughts worth reading! The suggestion of potatoes to break up the soil is interesting, but here the wild boars would get them for sure; still, I like the idea of plants and their root activity doing the work for me. I've been rethinking grass recently. Much of ours is annual, and it occurred to me that removing the grass from the beds and then mulching with hay is logically inelegant. This spring in many places I cut the grass and let it lie between the roses; now that it's dead we're mulching with hay again, but the roots will, I hope, stay and turn into food for earthworms and company. I've also been rethinking our practice of plowing our beds and then mulching them before planting. We've had two rainy winters and, in consequence, three slides close to or in the garden, and one large, nasty slump. In every case the ground had been disturbed by our gardening activities, and I am becoming quite cautious about disturbing the soil on a large scale.
    I wouldn't put a few years into soil improvement with cover crops, the reason quite possibly being my shortsightedness and impatience. I think these are valuable suggestions, for those who plan far enough ahead to do it. I do believe that to have almost anything growing in ground is better than having nothing growing in it. Some native plants I like and welcome in my beds; in other cases I'm just trying to get more plants planted, whether purchased or grown from cuttings or seeds. We do work with a modest budget and on a large scale, and the land is steep and difficult to work: it has to be done by hand or with a tractor. We left the tractor work to others after my husband nearly killed himself when the one we once ran away with him. Never again!
    This is a very interesting discussion and I appreciate all the input.
    Melissa

  • 16 years ago

    Taoseeker, I forgot to mention this in the message I just wrote, but your neighbors' garden does sound wonderful! I hope that one day, many years from now, I too will have beautiful soil!

  • 16 years ago

    Wild pigs rooting up potatoes can be used to mix organic material into the soil.

  • 16 years ago

    Michael,
    That thought had crossed my mind too, but you didn't see what it looked like when they got the species tulip bulbs I planted. I don't want to give the wild boars incentives to come and check out my garden.
    Melissa