Software
Houzz Logo Print
nuri_gw

Does composter have to sit on soil?

18 years ago

Hi,

I have a black enclosed compost maker (similar to the one on http://www.cleanairgardening.com/composter.html). When I placed it on the ground, I decided to put a plastic sheet and cover it up with sand/gravel since we have a big ant problem here in Texas.

Should I have it sitting on the grass/soil? Is having the plastic and gravel going to prevent it from composting quickly? Will this prevent the worms from coming into it to help speed up the composting process?

Also, how fast does it compost? Do I need to add compost liquid/powder to help speed up things?

Thank you,

Nuri

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Whether or not your composter sits on your soil has little or nothing to do with whether the materials you put in will compost. Some people think it necessary to have a composter on the soil so earthworms, who have little to do with composting, can get in and since they are not necesary for the process there is no need for them.

  • 18 years ago

    I use two of these bins for large amounts of coffee grounds and food waste here at the office. The grounds are so wet that even with the use of sawdust as a daily cover, the bin is too wet sitting on the ground. We put them on pallets so they can drain a bit when they need to. No problems with composting here.

    I would say that the mix of materials, moisture content, and turning will affect your compost much more than whether it is sitting directly on the ground.

  • 18 years ago

    It has it's pros and cons. More soil contact usually allows more organisms to come in contact with your compost and allows it to compost fast. And in the even that it get's to dry or wet or not the right material they can move back to the ground. BUT you also have the problem if you have fire ants moving in when it's on the ground and if it gets to moist or you leave the lid open during a rain it can wash some nutrients out into the ground. I have two compost bins. 1 sits right on the ground and can't really be moved easily. This was my first one I built. It does a good job but I've notice the grass behind it is supper green! I left the lid open once or twice when it rained and it must of washed out some of the good stuff and the grass is just loving it. Also when I dig from the bottom I can't tell where the compost ends and soil starts. Don't know if that's good or not. My second compost bin is made from a 55 gallon drum It also sits directly on the ground but has a bottom with some holes. But I have it sitting in an area that I have tilled up and planning on planting strawberries next year. Over the winter I plan on moving it closer to the house in a flower garden. That way any moister that comes out will help next year.

    I've seen more then enough compost bins sitting on blocks or other things because of different reasons ranging from tree root problems and a neatness factor. If you are concerned you can always throw in a few shovels of dirt in on occasion.

    As far as adding compost liquids or powders that's not really necessary. They just add N or Cs to it and they may have some organisms in them that you can get from a normal compost pile and dirt if you want to.

    And don't worry about the worms. Depending on how hot you have your pile they may not want to be there in the first place. They are only a very small part and can be done with out. People use tumblers that never touch the ground and no worms and they compost fine.

  • 18 years ago

    yes, there's pros and cons for either way. If the pile is apt to get wet and drainage is kept to nil, then the pile may stink.
    If you allow it to drain away those times when rain and heavy snow-melt causes it to be soggy, then the pile works better.
    Besides, I do believe there's worms and other insects that should be invited in to take a bite. A half-on, half-off floor might satisfy.

    But if its a big bother to give it a floor, forget it and watch how you dampen the pile.

  • 18 years ago

    Am I the only one who thought that the subject of this posting was a lead-in for something hilarious?

  • 18 years ago

    The organisms that will digest your material do not come from the soil, they are already present on the material you will put in the composter so there is no really good reason for the composter to be in contact with soil. There are no pros and cons, however many of use do have our compost piles on the soil, but that is because it is much easier than trying to build something to keep the compost off the ground. With my compost bins building something to keep 1 ton of compost off the soil would be much more work than I would want to do.

  • 18 years ago

    Quote: The organisms that will digest your material do not come from the soil, they are already present on the material you will put in the composter so there is no really good reason for the composter to be in contact with soil.

    I beg to differ, like often someone talks about how good a soil is if there is worms present, those wigglers can have a lot to say about how well a composter works....after a time.
    Drainage of any composting is important especially if the pile is under a kitchen or dining room window.
    Bacteria aside, there's a lot of different action going on in a garbage pile that results in good compost.
    And I wouldn't say a tumbler is a preferred way to compost.

    If you can .....do....
    If you cant.....teach!

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you to all those who have replied to my post and those planning to reply.

    Nuri