Software
Houzz Logo Print
roses_more_roses

Electric Blanket J&P RMV

19 years ago

This is so frustrating! About four years ago I purchased a few Electric Blanket roses from J&P they turned out to have RMV, I took the leaves to the County Master Gardeners program to make sure that it was RMV. Anyway it took a few years for the RMV to show on those roses. I really liked them for groundcover roses so this Spring I purchased them again, hoping that they were now using new stock. I was a little reluctant, but purchased them anyway. I was watering today and noticed the same markings on the leaves. I've only had these roses a few months. Here is where the frustration comes in; I purchased them again so I knew they may have a problem. But I decided to call Jackson & Perkins and the phone representative didn't know what RMV was, she put me on hold forever, and came back saying that it was highly unlikely the roses left J&P with the virus, since they heat treat their plants, then she went on to say that there was new research to show that RMV could be spread by spores and insects. I wasn't asking for a credit, they were purchased at a local nursery. I kept trying to tell her that it wasn't anything the nursery did, that this is in the tissue. Did she have this confused with another virus?

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    Obviously the person you spoke with at J&P doesn't know what they are talking about. RMV is spread from contaminated rootstock, or infected scions grafted onto the rootstock. If one or the other has the virus, the healthy tissue will get it also. Obviously these roses either were not heat indexed, or else the heat indexing didn't cure the disease. There are other rose viruses that can be spread by insects, but Rose Mosaic is not one of them. There is a very slight chance it can be spread underground with root grafting, but would be rare.

    Malcolm Manners is the expert on RMV. You may want to e-mail him. He posts once in awhile here, so if you go to the antique roses forum and do a search on no-spray roses or rose virus, you may get one of his posts to pop up.

    In my opinion, the nursery should refund your money or give you credit towards another rose. I would also insist on talking to someone at J&P that is "higher up" in management. You can always send some plant tissue off to a lab that does Eliza testing if you want to be absolutely sure and have proof. Washington State University does testing. Their number is 509-786-9382. I have used them a few times. Every sample I sent them that had symptoms was infected. I've even had a few with no symptoms test positive that had poor health or poor performance.

    Sandy

  • 19 years ago

    Sandy Thank you! You have given me some great information. I really want to make sure that this rose doesn't get into the hands of other gardeners; if it does in fact have the RMV virus. I was told that I was the only person to complain of any J&P rose having RMV this year. She said someone from their Executive service department would call me. I think I will call again and ask for that phone number. I felt like I was talking to a wall, we went round and round about how RMV is spread, she was very certain for someone who didn't know what the disease was a few minutes earlier. The basic idea she was trying to tell me was that it could have become infected once it left J&P, but didn't leave there with the virus. They must take a customer service training class with pat answers. There has to be something wrong for this rose to still be available with RMV after four years. She did mention that they have growing locations at many different sites and they would try to track down the lot my roses came from. I told her that I would be glad to send her part of the plant for testing, but I think she thought I was a real crazy. Oh No that isn't necessary! Well it might be if you really want to solve this issue. Anyway thank you for all of the information.
    Diana

  • 19 years ago

    Poor customer service, to pass on the blame. Too bad, the company is in transition, too. Get your satisfaction ASAP. Get you money back from the nursery and select another variety. Obviously there's a problem at J P. Don't you hate it when they treat a knowledgable customer like a nut bar?

    Don't engage in debate with Customer Service. It's been tried and failed. They persist in selling the Climbing Tea Sombreuil when it's been known for years that it ain't no Tea. They have argued with people who actually grow Teas (obviously no one at JP does). Nope, move on and protect your pocket book.

  • 19 years ago

    "representative didn't know what RMV was, she put me on hold forever, and came back saying that it was highly unlikely the roses left J&P with the virus, since they heat treat their plants,"

    I consider this as a positive development: they knew that only heat treatment could cure a rose from RMV. Three or four years ago when I asked them about RMV, the customer service lady transfered my call to one of their horticulturists who informed me that none of their roses could have RMV because they spray every plant before shipping, LOL. By now it seems they have learnt that spraying does nothing against RMV.

    Request your money back and do not order this variety again. Just MHO.

  • 19 years ago

    We have an Electric Blanket purchased around 2002/2003. It has the distinctive yellowish zig zags in the leaves that are indicative of RMV.

  • 19 years ago

    If one is, they all are.
    I'm only surprised because I had thought this rose was sold from the git-go own-root.
    However, they must have budded a generation or so up, to increase quantities.
    That's all it would take, on virused rootstock.
    But what a pity to do this with a relatively-new cultivar.
    It's almost unforgiveable.

    Jeri