Software
Houzz Logo Print
jacquierz5bmi

sick Hawkeye Belle

17 years ago

In spring 2007 I purchased an own root Hawkeye Belle from Great Lakes Roses. It grew well and was beautiful summer of 2007 and 2008 and made it through the winter 2007-2008. This spring it seemed dead and after I pruned it, it grew one tiny branch that seemed to come from the roots. I was hoping it would come back from the roots but now that branch seems to have shriveled up. What could have happened to it? Should I take the chance of planting another rose in that same spot? Thanks for any help.

Jacquie

Comments (3)

  • 17 years ago

    My Prairie Star had a similar problem. Grew OK last summer. Early this spring I saw a little growth around the base of the plant which subsequently shriveled and it is now dead as a doornail. I previously had another rose (The Prince) in the same spot and it died. It is in a raised bed and other roses within a few feet are OK. It is in the front (West most) part of the bed. Maybe the winter was just too much for it. I will experiment with a hardier variety in this location next year, although I was lead to believe that Buck roses survive the winter without protection.

  • 17 years ago

    You can watch it and hope it comes back but it doesn't look good. I have this rose grafted and it is a very strong and hardy Buck rose that I can't imagine having a problem with the winter under normal conditions. Could it be that it has much more trouble getting established on its' own roots? How well established was the rose? Did you prune away good cane or was it killed mostly to the ground? Was it vigorous and strong last year or did it limp along? I can only surmise that it wasn't doing too well last year and went downhill and barely got through the winter and now whatever the conditions were that caused this are still present. The answer could be almost anything.

  • 17 years ago

    I thought that it was doing well last year but can't find any pictures to make certain. I thought that having it on its own roots would make it hardier so it could come back from the roots if anything happened. Maybe that isn't necessarily the case. I'm very disappointed because I really liked it and now I need something else to fill that spot. I don't know whether or not to buy another Buck (maybe Quietness) or to get grafted or own root. I was also under the impression that Buck roses were very hardy. Helpmefind said zone 6b for Quietness. Yikes! How much winter protection do most of you do? Thanks.
    Jacquie