Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeanz5il

Rose Defense and Nematodes

18 years ago

I ordered this product since a few fellow forumers recommended it. The label directions are 2TBs per 1 gallon of water. It is the concentrate formula. Is this accurate from your experience? Can I add fish emulsion to it? I want to use it this coming Monday.

I also bought nematodes for the soil and would like to know how much to add per rose bush if anyone has experience with this product also. Both purchases from Planet Alive. Thanks!

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    Jean, Rose Defense is clarified hydrophobic extract of neem, which amounts to saying it's the residue left when crushed neem seeds have been extracted with alcohol or other solvents to remove the good stuff containing the insecticde azadirachtin. Rose Defense is basically a vegetable oil, analogous to Mazola corn oil or canola cooking oil. Like many other oils, it will smother fungal spores or insects or their eggs. There is no evidence that it is especially better at this compared to other oils, and it is certainly more expensive. At any rate, all oils can burn rose leafs if sprayed in high concentration in hot weather. Two TBS per gallon will produce a solution containing less than 1% oil and this is usually safe with most oils. You can increase the margin of safety if you water your roses thoroughly the day before you spray and don't spray at all if the temperature gets close to 90 degrees.

  • 18 years ago

    So I wasted my money? I thought it maybe better than my Cornell Formula I used last. The salesperson at the Plants Alive said it contained a good percentage of Neem and a better deal than getting strictly the Neem Oil. She recommended the Scan Mask (Nematodes) too.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't know what you are trying to control but these are results reported for blackspot of roses at the University of Delaware Botanic Garden:

    Unsprayed Control: 33% leaves infected.

    Triact (sprayed as a 1% solution of clarified hydrophobic extract of Neem): 23% leaves infected.

    Sunspray horticultural oil (sprayed as a 1% solution of oil): 4% leaves infected.

    I don't think you wasted your money exactly but I think there are better organic sprays for blackspot than neem oil.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the replies. I wanted an organic, fungicide and safe pesticide for my roses. I THOUGHT the Rose Defense product had Neem Oil in it with a fungicide. I wanted to benefit from the Azadirachtin but it does not look like I will. I had made a post about my Earth Song rose not getting many buds and I researched Azadirachtin as a possible product to help.
    I emailed the customer service where I bought this product and of course will ask them what did I really buy? Maybe I should buy straight Neem Oil?

  • 18 years ago

    Neem's original use was as an insecticide and insect repellent. Much of this is due to the presence of azadirachtin. I have checked most of the stores in my area and the only form of neem they sell is the clarified hydrophobic extract which contains no azadirachtin. If you want the original extract, Safer Bioneem is one example (see link). Bioneem is not a fungicide and won't help at all with blackspot. I think Sunspray horticultural oil, micronized sulfur and Greencure (potassium bicarbonate) are among the best organic sprays for blackspot.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Bioneem