Software
Houzz Logo Print
rjlinva

compicata seedlings....what to expect?

18 years ago

Greetings. As some of you may recall, I've been trying my hand at starting some open pollinated seedlings. I'm curious about what to expect with Complicata. I recall reading somewhere that Complicata may even be a species rose. And, it's my understanding that species rose seedlings often come true to type. Am I totally wrong about this?

Robert

Comments (7)

  • 18 years ago

    species would breed true to type if they were self pollinated or pollinated with like species. Your open pollinated could end up either self pollinated or outcrossed by whatever other rose that might have pollinated it. It is my understanding that roses were meant to be single or semi-double, and it mutations that form the full and doubles. I would guess the majority of your seedlings would probably be pink and single, the most common rose combination, but for those few mutants, who knows? But I doubt it will be blue.

  • 18 years ago

    Your seedlings are almost certain to be once-bloomers like the parent since that trait tends to be dominant, but that's about all that's certain at this point (besides their not being blue, quite right, len!) Species only breed true if they breed with their own kind or self-pollinate, in which case, you'll bring out all kinds of recessive alleles -- some, or probably most, of which will be detrimental to the seedling's health; others may prove beneficial but you almost have to take the good with the bad at first when breeding with unknowns/unfamiliars. Nothing is for certain; this is part of the learning process!

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks. While I have your attention....Would you think that my open pollinated Frau Dagmar Hastrup seedlings will also be once bloomers since she is a repeat bloomer? I'm supposing that, if the male's pollen is repeat blooming (or carries an allele for repeat blooming), there's a good chance that the seedlings will repeat.

    Also, I'm wondering why it's likely that seedlings will be less healthy than the parents...especially if they are open pollinated with other healthy roses? My reasoning would suggest that two healthy parents would produce an even healthier offspring. I suppose time will tell. So far my seedlings are looking really good and really healthy. At least most of them.

    FWIW... Having roses repeat is way low on my list of priorities. Health is number one. I adore singles and semi-doubles and hope I will get some of them!

    Robert

  • 18 years ago

    When you consider how roses are selected that make it to market, it is beauty and uniqueness first, and everything else second, with exceptions of course, like exceptional health or hardiness. A much common single pink seedling that is named and marketed would have a much better chance of producing healthier offspring than a Soleil di or that introduced yellows into the ht's. My guess is if there ever is a true blue naturally occuring rose, it's going to be very sick, because it would almost certainly have to have something amiss because there has never been a blue rose, but it will be kept on life support and bred prolifically.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Robert,
    Are you talking about the single pink, thornless "gallica" variety called Complicata? I have usually seen it referred to as a gallica hybrid. And just recently (can't remember where) saw it referred to as a possible canina/gallica cross. If it is a hybrid, then it would not be a true species so you may get variation. Healthy to healthy should produce healthy but there can always be some recessive lurking in the background that links with another and.... it's a roll of the dice basically.
    Jim

  • 18 years ago

    I would definitely expect your 'Fru Dagmar Hastrup' seedlings to be remontant, although chance pollination by once-bloomers could get in the way. In my experience, rugosa seedlings can take a few years to mature and bloom for the first time and may not repeat right away, so don't give up too soon.

    I would expect some lovely seedlings from both plants (lower petal count also tends to dominate strongly, although with each repeated crossing to double-flowered roses you'll see the number go up).

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, for the comments. I have patience with these seedlings. And, yes, Jim, it's the Gallica Complicata.

    I was trying to find the parentage of some of my seedlings' parents...but, most are listed as "unknown parentage." So, I don't know who went into their make-up.

    Robert