Software
Houzz Logo Print
petalpatsy

Too many eggshells?

19 years ago

I have a little compost pile inside a 3x3x3 square wire cage. I add and turn and add and turn until it holds pretty steady at 3/4 full before I let it finish and harvest, and I just did start a new pile with twiggy leftovers from the harvest of the old pile. Now that winter is coming, this little kitchen pile won't get so much feeding and being so small activity will slow way down.

Roughly how many eggshells would be okay to add before the pile gets unbalanced for use as a soil amendment to general flower use? A dozen seems fine to me, but a hundred seems like too many. Or is this like the leaf question?

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    Don't count; just add them to the compost pile. Egg shells are primarily calcium carbonate which is soluble in water. They will take a long, long time to disappear from the soil so the annual contribution is very small.

    There is the concern that the calcium carbonate will increase the pH of the soil but this may be overstated.

  • 19 years ago

    When you're talking about compost, you're dealing mostly with micronutrients, so you really don't have to be concerned with 'balance' in your pile. As the seasons change, the components that you add will change, but if you're regularly turning your pile and it's breaking down it all becomes the same nice stuff. During winter you won't have grass, but you can add coffee grounds from your office or from the local coffee bar, cafe or restaurant. You can find leaves on peoples curbs on trash day. You may have some veggies that get lost in the back of the reefer and go 'bad' but they're not really bad in the compost world, they're just closer to being composted. There're still plenty of things to go into the pile in winter. Newspapers, cardboard boxes, paper grocery sacks, junk mail, etc.

    I keep a little covered pot on my kitchen counter that fills up daily with the compostable waste from each meal. Vegetable trimmings, peels, cores, stems, napkins, paper towels, egg shells, popsickle sticks, things that fell on the floor that the dog won't eat, and anything leftover that was not eaten within a few days of cooking.

    Things I don't add: milk, meat, bones, grease, or plastic-coated paper, everything else is fair composting game. Cheryl

  • 19 years ago

    Alrighty! Eggshells away!

  • 19 years ago

    My compost pile doesn't get that many egg shells since I grind them up for my worm bin.

  • 19 years ago

    Since any nutrients in egg shells are not very available you can add tons of them before they start having an adverse affect on your soil. Any nutrients in egg shells are very slowly made available to the soil. Many years ago, when the retired school teacher sisters behind us hired me to help with their yard work (1950's) they would take all the egg shells from their breakfasts and other meals and put them in a 5 gallon water jug (carboy) to soak for about a year. One of my jobs was to pour this onto the flower beds, eeeuuuh, something I could do for a while. I don't think I ever emptied on carboy fully at one time. But even after that year in a carboy full of water the egg shells were still there, whole. Whether any nutrients were leached from them or not this then 10, or so, year old never really found out, and I did not see much difference in the growth of their flowers versus my mothers which were given a dressing of cow manure, from uncles farm, each fall.

  • 19 years ago

    as long as the eggshells arent bigger than the compost, they will be fine but remember to stick em in the middle using something like leaves or grass clippings to heat it up faster.