Software
Houzz Logo Print
banders_gw

Acidic soil, revisited

19 years ago

I haven't gotten my soil analysis back yet, but a rose society buddy has tested several areas of my beds/pots with a meter that is much more sophistocated than mine and supports my El Cheapo meter's results of high acidity. His results ranged from 4.8-5.5 in 5 dfferent spots.

Now, I'm not a chemist, but I've been doing some reading and it seems that ammonium based fertilizers can contribute to soil acidity. I feed my roses well, with 10-10-10 and Miracle Gro, both of which are ammonium based, if I'm interpreting things correctly. And please correct me if I'm not. Also alfalfa tea and I've been adding chelated iron this year. They got Rose Tone in the Spring, as well as Osmocote one time.

Anyway, I need to feed--at least my potted roses--and I usually feed them mid-month with Miracle Gro. If my conclusions are correct, what else can I use until I get my soil tests back? I don't want to worsen the problem if it is indeed as acidic as I fear. If Miracle Gro won't hurt, that's a good thing, since I already have it ;-)

Thanks,

Barbara

Comments (21)

  • 19 years ago

    Organic fertilizers take longer to act but don't affect the Ph much. Manures, manure tea, fish meal, fish emulsion,
    Milorganite, Mills Magic, and others that are organic.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks!

    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    How about some alfala now?

  • 19 years ago

    I do alfalfa tea once a month.

    Thanks,
    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    Try some Alaska 0-10-10.

  • 19 years ago

    I've really been wanting to try fish again but the one time I did raccoons tried to dig up the roses. Can you get this at Lowe's or Wal*Mart?

    Thanks,
    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    MiracleGro is technically a urea-based fertilizer. In the soil, urea is first hydrolyzed to ammonia and then oxidized to nitric acid. This results in a temporary and localized acidification of the soil, which is why urea-based fertilizers are often applied to acid-loving plants. When a plant takes up the nitrate part of nitric acid, the plant also neutralizes the acid part, resulting in no net change in the soil pH. However, if an excess of urea is applied, the nitrate eventually gets leached away and no neutralization of the acid part occurs. So, if you feed just enough MiracleGro, you should see no soil acidification, but if you over-apply MiracleGro, a gradual acidification will be the result.


    Ammonium ion is an acidic material and fertilizers, such as Rose Tone, which contain direct sources of ammonium ion (typically, ammonium sulfate) can directly lower the soil pH. Nitrogen leaching will also lead to further acidification if an excess of an ammonium-based fertilizer is applied.

  • 19 years ago

    As I recall, Barbara's soil is straight manure.

    Ordinarily, chlorosis on new growth is caused by alkaline soil making iron or zinc less available to the plant. Chlorosis in acid soil might be caused by a great excess of other nutrients tying up or displacing the deficient element. This is just a guess. But I wouldn't fertilize except with trace elements pending the results of the soil test. If you are still seeing chlorosis on the new growth, I would try foliar feeding of trace elements to bypass whatever is the problem in the soil. I've had burn from foliar iron, so I'd use less than the recommend dosage and repeat as needed.

    Please post the results when you get them.

    The fertilizer ingredient that contributes most to soil acidity is ammonium sulfate. Other ammonium salts and urea have little effect on pH unless you are applying more nitrogen than plants can use. In that case, any form of nitrogen, manufactured or organic, contributes to soil acidity. Maybe Mike_R will check me on this.

    The material you are using as soil will continue to release some nitrogen for many years, I think, so there is no need to be anxious about deficiency in the soil. What I would be worried about is excess.

  • 19 years ago

    Most nitrogen fertilizers can decrease soil pH by the leaching mechanism. The reason why organic fertilizers usually do not change soil pH is, first, they usually contain low concentration of nitrogen and aadding an excess is less likely, and, second, they tend to release nitrogen gradually, giving a plant time to take it all up and minimizing loss by leaching.

    Synthetic fertilizers containg nitrate ion, such as calcium nitrate, do not form nitric acid in the soil and actually tend to increase soil pH.

  • 19 years ago

    michaelg, NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, my soil is NOT straight manure. Not sure where you got that notion, but not from me ;-) All of my beds are raised and most are filled with bagged commercial topsoil with SOME composted manure (both bagged and hauled from stables) added over the years. I've also added my compost, coffee grounds, alfalfa sludge, etc. Until last year, all of these beds were used for vegetables and did just great.

    I've been reading (university agriculture sites) that acidic soil can prevent uptake of nutrients just as alkaline soil can. I did foliar feed with chelated iron once this season and did see some leaf burn/loss on several plants. Since then I've used it as a drench.

    I sure will post the results when I get them. I'm anxious to see them, to say the least.

    Mike Rivers, it's certainly possible that I've overfed with Miracle Gro. I use it according to package instructions, though. You say there's a temporary acidification to the soil. How temporary? I last put it on July 4. Would it be still showing up now? I also used RoseTone this past Spring. Since it's slow acting, could I be still seeing the acidifying results from it? I also throw down some 10-10-10 several times during the season. Which also contributes to it, right? Would trying to neutralize the soil acidity reduce the nitrogen uptake? I assume as long as it got to the optimum range it would be OK? So many questions.

    Last night I decided to use my meter on the spots that my friend tested. All were pretty close to his results. Then I tried it on some unused potting mix (ProMix). It showed it at a solid pH of 7, which surprized me with all the peat that's in it. So, at least the potting soil is not the culprit, it's what I do to it, it seems. If my meter was accurate. My unused bagged topsoil was on the acidic side, but not super low. I'm going to get samples of both to my friend to test with his meter.

    This has been/will be an interesting journey.

    Thanks to both of you!
    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    Mike Rivers, give me some examples of calcium nitrate fertilizers, please. That makes sense to me, BTW ;-)

    Thanks,
    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    Calcium nitrate can be hard to find. It's usually sold in separate bags because the soluble calcium in it will convert soluble phosphate fertilizers into insoluble calcium phosphate. It's commonly used in hydroponics and also (because of the soluble calcium) to prevent tomato blossom end-rot. You might find it at a local nursery.

    Truthfully, I think it's useful to know all this stuff, but any respectable complete rose fertilizer, organic or synthetic, at label amounts is hard to beat and if your soil pH needs adjusting, raise it with lime or lower it with sulfur.

  • 19 years ago

    Barbara, pardon my misstatement on the manure issue, I must have read one of your previous posts carelessly.

    If we are talking about interveinal chlorosis (yellow against green veins) on new growth, the likely deficiencies are iron, zinc, and manganese, all of which should be highly available at low pH.

    If it is interveinal chlorosis on old leaves instead, it could be deficiency of magnesium , which is less available at low pH. Maybe Epsom salts would help in that case.

  • 19 years ago

    Yeah, I did a Google search for it and decided it's not a viable option ;-) If the results come back as expected, I'll be using lime.

    Thanks again. It *is* interesting to know "how it works".

    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    michaelg, it's definitely on new growth only. Old growth is very green. It's interesting that 2 doses of chelated iron drench at package recommendations at monthly intervals have done little to nothing to reverse it.

    I find this entire discussion to be very helpful. Thanks.

    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    It sounds like the chlorosis may not be caused by a pH problem, then.

  • 19 years ago

    What are other possibilities?

    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    Iron deficiency in the plant might be caused by an excess of phosphate or manganese in the soil, but I sure don't know. Let's see what the soil test says.

    Sometimes iron deficiency symptoms seem to crop up randomly. That's usually in spring, when soils are cold and overly wet, but I have a hideously chlorotic shoot on a young St. Cecilia plant right now that I can't explain.

  • 19 years ago

    Ok, I'll post my results as soon as I get them.

    Barbara

  • 19 years ago

    That's a pretty low pH for potting soil. I thought my pots had gone acidic because I saw moss growiing on the tops, but when I tested out the soil after turning out some roses and very carefully avoiding roots, pieces of undissolved fertilizer and organic matter, the pH was in the mid 6 range.

    Calcium nitrate is readily available out here at agricultural and landscape supply places that supply amendments in 50 pound bags to farmers, cheap - $9.50 for 50 lbs. I think I needed a tablespoon or two for each large rose in the ground. But you don't want to use it if your soils are deficient in magnesium. I'd hold off.

    Leaching in pots is uneven. I've had trouble keeping my potted roses evenly fertilized. Time-released ferts over-release when it gets brutally hot, just when the plants don't need a nitrogen hit. The thing that really works for me in the summer is frequent (every two to three weeks) very dilute liquid fertilizer. I rotate everything I can think of - alfalfa tea, fish emulsion, dilute Miracle grow (one third to one quarter strength), Sam's Club, whatever I found on sale in November. I steer clear of granulars in the pots except for a single shot in the early spring.

    I'll be interested to hear your results and how high the nitrogen levels are. In acid soils, excessive micronutrients can block nitrogen uptake. Of course the excessive micronutrients have to be there to do the blocking....

  • 19 years ago

    Cass, you can be sure I'll post the results--and hope for advice.

    Barbara