Software
Houzz Logo Print
agardenstateof_mind

Commercial Soil Amendments

I read recently about two soil amendments that are supposed to be superior to peat moss with respect to soil structure and water retention. I'm wondering if anyone here has any information or experience with either/both of these.

SoilSponge is mostly coconut coir and Zeba is a cornstarch-based product, that the manufacturer claims also helps with fertilizer retention.

I realize that good old homemade compost is probably the #1 choice product for this purpose in outdoor gardens, but am considering this type of produce for use in containers indoors and in a small greenhouse.

Thanks!

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Compost is the best choice for soil improvement, in the garden or the greenhouse, and if you make your own compost there is no good reason to spend money buying some product that you already have on hand.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd disagree - compost is best for outdoor soil improvement but it is not a desireable component for a potting soil. Too degradable and with the degradation/decomposition comes compaction which is anathema to drainage and container growing. For a container or potting medium, coco fibre/coir is an excellent choice and is typically used as a substitute for peat. Zeba is an organic water retaining product, much like the polyacrylic granules (SoilMoist). Because it has an ability to absorb and retain water, it will also hold soluble nutrients, but I'd not exactly term it a soil amendment. More like a soil additive. And not something I'd recommend using on an inground situation, either.

  • 18 years ago

    Although I agree with gardengal I do use 20% finished compost in my greenhouse soil mix. Everything else in the mix is sterile and I wish to add some microbial activity. My basic mix is so well drained I have not had a problem with my pots draining. Al

  • 18 years ago

    It is a misconception that compost is not a good potting medium. Compost has been used by many nurseries and gardeners for years for seed starting with really good results. The people at ATTRA even have a whole web site devoted to making organic potting mixes.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Organic soilless potting mixes

  • 18 years ago

    Your best answers are going to be found through the sales reps of the manufacturers. Most of the people who familiar this forum are #1) not professional growers and #2) wouldn't spend money on soil products to save their life.

    As far as comparisons of container media components, most research is done by companies themselves. They have a problem, be it lack of consistent supply or quality, or they don't like a certain aspect of a component (using rice hulls as a substitute for perlite because of dust), so they seek out alternatives. they may look to a university for a lead, but in the end, their primary reference data is going to come from mulling over the data presented by the supplier.

    There is a certain amount of university research, but it's mostly done to support a culture recommendation for growing a crop or how to use a commodity that's locally available rather than import a component. (Do you see an underlying theme of economics?)

    One could make the argument that most nurseries use compost in their potting mix. One could also make the argument that the same nurseries most definitely do not use "compost", they use an engineered media as perfected as possible. Indeed, in CO, cut flower growers do not qualify as ag producers...they are viewed as a factory. Anyone want to propose a theory as to why you'd want to be viewed as a factory when it comes to the production of plants?

    In general, nurseries would not say they compost. They would say they blend their own media, not soil. The potential risk of pathogen is simply too great. Ever try to return your plant container? Most places I've been, they'll take it, then put it in the trash. Same reason.

    As regards the products mentioned, I've not heard of Zeba at all, and I've heard of/discussed coir, although not actually used it. Comments have been positive, although generally comparable to peat. Mostly, it comes down to local factors and cost input data.

    If it were me, I'd ask the reps if I could talk to people who have used them, and perhaps even run a batch of each and see how things turned out. This is trade show season...go, look, listen, chat...and from it all, make your own decision. That's the only one that counts.

  • 18 years ago

    I do anywhere from 50 to 100 potted starts every year in one quart to 15 gallon sizes. I use a mix of 25% screened compost and 75% native soil which for me is very sandy and even has some find gravel (beach sand size particles). Works wonderfully. I have often wondered though if I wouldn't do just as well with all native soil and a compost soil mix only for the top 2 inches which would be more like a true soil.
    food for thought, and now that I'm thinking about it, I may just try a few that way this year.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you for the responses. You're right, gardengal, "amendment" wasn't the best choice of words ... I really struggled with that title :-) Additive or conditioner would have been more appropriate.

    Since there seems to be some difference of opinion on using/adding compost in a potting mix, I just might do a little experimenting this winter and see what results I get.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd challenge anyone to take the notion that compost is a suitable component for a potting medium to the Container Gardening forum and see what those folks have to say. Many are folks that specialize in container growing (bonsai enthusiasts and others) and have done considerable research into the best mixes. Container culture is vastly different from inground growing conditions and the same rules do not apply. You may be able to get away with it for a short term situation, but compost will continue to degrade/decompose and collapse, thereby reducing pore space and contributing to compaction and poor drainage. Poor drainage is worst enemy of container planting.

    For any sort of long term container situation (longer than 2 growing seasons), a container mix that is primarily inert material or organic product that is very slow to further degradation (bark fines, coir, peat) is most often recommended.

    For those of you unfamiliar with Zeba, I've posted an informational link. I received a sample of the product from the vendor early last season (2006) and used it in one of my container plantings. It did seem that container required somewhat less frequent watering, but with some 3 dozen permanent container plantings, I didn't notice a real obvious difference :-) It was easier just to water them all as needed. I think I would see more of difference in any hanging container or basket, which tend to dry out very quickly in summer because of more exposure to air.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Zeba