Software
Houzz Logo Print
tumblenes

Inoculants

19 years ago

Inoculants for compost? Or are leaves, coffee grounds & kitchen waste plus the little remnants of the previous compost enough to provide bacterial & fungi diversity? Well I do know that will give me temperature, but diversified? Anyway, the batch I started last Sunday I decided to add 1 shovel of garden soil, mixed seaweed & fish extract to the rain water, 1 shovel of commercial lobster compost, 1 cup of commercial worm castings. I also figured, what could go wrong here? Then again, how would I know if I have more diversity? Would diversity equate to speed of decomposition? I suppose the major ingredient I purposely have omitted for various reasons is cow manure; & it would be a pain to collect this anyway. I thought I would do things a bit differently this time.

Comments (12)

  • 19 years ago

    Sounds good enough to eat! I too have questioned the diversity of my compost, but short of testing it, how would we know? I have never used an inoculant or added soil. (to tell the truth I wasn't aware of this process when I first started). I'm thinking that enough stuff got picked up with the leaves/grass/plant to start the process. And as you stated there is always some left after emptying the tumbler to start the next batch. I have never put any manure into my tumbler, not against it, just never really gave it much thought.

    Would be cool to get a test done on the compost though.

    Lloyd

    P.S. Got any pictures of your tumbler?

  • 19 years ago

    Just my laymans opinion based on what I guess would be an attempt at common logic. All those things that you mentioned are good for making compost, as well as adding some diversity to be sequestered in the compost, but totally unnecessary as far as getting your pile innoculated with the microherd that does the grunt work.

    It is there in the bacteria on the leaves that you gather, the bit of dirt associated with them and all the other things that you add. I can just pile up damp, shredded leaves and they will start to heat up almost immediately.

    Perhaps I am confused by your question, if it is diversity of your compost when finished, or finished to the poing where you use it, or something about cooking it. You said that you know how to get the heat, therefore, with that you can compost a few simple ingredients, or many complex ones if you stay within the ball park of the C N ratios, moisture and air.

    After reading that a study indicates that the more diverse the ingredients going into the pile, the better, and that those nutrients and elements are sequestered in the compost for plant food on demand at some future point after being mixed in with your soil, I can't help but believe that the more diverse the ingredients are (within reason) the better off you are. That is just my opinion and the reason that I posted a couple of times and put some pictures supporting that opinion in the thread linked below.
    That is my .02
    Bill P.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Thread mentioned above

  • 19 years ago

    it was a link provided by blutranes that got me thinking.

    My wife gave the 18 bushel ComposTumbler as a present last September & we collected about 200 bags of leaves & lots of coffee.

    Soilfoodweb.com will test compost for about $200, too rich for me.

    And yes Bill, i usually read your posts.

    Here is a link that might be useful: afore mentioned

  • 19 years ago

    I wasn't trying to sell you on reading my postings, per se, just trying to contribute an opinion, and why, in response to your query. And at the time, it seemed like a valid thought. Hopefully some one can provide the answer that you seek tumblenes.
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    I've never applied any inoculant to my compost. Many years ago, I read a suggestion to toss a little soil from the garden in for the bacteria, but everything I've read more recently indicates that isn't needed, because the bacteria are in the air, anyway. If I remember correctly, if you have a hot compost process, you tend to get more bacterial action, and more fungal with a colder process. I may be wrong on that, though.

    I don't know that having a diversity of raw materials gets you a diversity of bacteria and fungi. It may, but my understanding is that you're more likely to get a diversity of micronutrients that way.

    If you have limited access to compostables, though, I think you're better off composting whatever you have. No matter what's in it, it'll help, even if it's almost all coffee grounds and shredded paper.

    I think tree leaves tend to have a lot of different nutrients in them, some pulled from deep underground, so they're always a good addition to the mix.

    I mostly use what I have (and that's free). Every once in a while, I'll buy a bag of shredded pine shavings if I've been getting lots of UCG and have run out of leaves and paper, but other than that, I try to keep it to what I have on hand. I find that buying a big bag of shredded pine bedding in the pet department is usually less expensive than getting something similar in the garden section, and it works just as well.

  • 19 years ago

    Sometimes a question is too broad to answer. Therefore I will pose a very specific one.
    LetÂs say that one wants to produce compost that will aid in the growing tomatoes with the highest vitamin content (and not be concerned with yield, looks or even taste). Now maybe the answer to that is unknown, and a strategy would be diversity in compost. But maybe there is enough knowledge on how vitamins are produced by tomato plants and that will lead to compost with specific properties, undiversified yet engineered with inoculants. Maybe the answer is weed & marigold compost as that will have the right minerals for the bacteria, is that so farfetched & silly?

    Bill, I read your posts because you seem more accomplished as a gardener than I, it was meant as a complimentÂ.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh.

    When you put it that way, I have absolutely no idea. I'm more of a macro-composter than a microcomposter. I suspect you may need to do some testing of your own to find the answer to your more specific question.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh, thanks. Ditto bpgreen's comment.

  • 19 years ago

    All organic matter has the bacteria that will digest it in place from the start, however they will not necessarily become active until certain conditions are present. The "compost starters" are primarily a very expensive Nitrogen source, look at the list of ingrediants. So if you build your compost with roughly the right 30:1 ratio of C:N and have just enough moisture the material will get digested quite rapidly without adding soil (the soil bacteria have little to do with making compost) or a "compost starter".

  • 19 years ago

    Inoculants for compost would be the compost starters you can buy to start things composting really hot really fast. Some people swear by them...some at them...take your pick...

    But, to answer your question obliquely...

    Ranchers in South Dakota have found that their soils are high in selenium. Absorbed by the grasses and forage their cattle feed on, it is deposited in the meat of the cattle themselves. There are specific advantages to having trace amounts of selenium in your diet, something that these ranchers are capitalizing upon and utilizing in their marketing campaigns.

    What does this mean for you?

    If you specifically seek out those compostable materials that are high in certain nutrients, vitamins and minerals, the possibility is that you could acheive your desires. Or maybe what you do is get micronutrient package...or become a gourmet of produce. Not a bad option.

    That's about all you can do, practically. The rest is up to the plants to grow, to absorb those nutrients you have sought to make available. Without lab equipment...you just can't confirm.

    There are many issues that CAN arise. pH can affect solubility, excess rains can leach nutrients, combinations can achieve unintended components and subsequent compounds.

    On one hand, what you propose makes a certan sort of sense...but on the other...

  • 19 years ago

    There was a thread awhile back where someone expressed the opinion that composting diseased plants from the garden, instead of sending them to the landfill as many suggest, would tend to make your compost a sort of an innoculant against those diseases after it was incorporated into your soil.

    I really have no idea if that is just theory, or if there is any fact and truth to it, although it does sound kinda logical. I always shred and compost mine without regard to any indications of disease, and each passing season my garden gets better, more productive with healthier plants and perhaps seems more disease and pest free, or tolerant. However, that could be just because of my continued program of turning under green manure, good home made compost, horse manure and shredded leaves every winter, I dunno.

    I think that we have to try things to see what works best for us in our little corner of the world, if for no other reason than to satisfy our own curiousity. Sometimes we see tangible results, sometimes we do not. Like someone else stated, I think that you would need some lab test run under the right conditions to compare against a controled set of plants to see if you achieved the desired result.

    With regard to your statement "growing tomatoes with the highest vitamin content (and not be concerned with yield, looks or even taste)."
    Personally, I would prefer to swallow a vitamin pill that I could not taste than eat an ugly, foul tasing tomato, but that is just me and I do not know about you or anyone else.
    Another .02 to total .04, which still ain't much nowdays. ":^)
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    Hmm, Bill. I have posted this link here several times.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dr Leon Hoitink on Disease suppression

Sponsored
Schlabach Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars22 Reviews
Franklin County's Reclaimed Wood Professionals