Software
Houzz Logo Print
jim1961_gw

? For MichaelG and others.

MichealG and others : Ok, the subject is Neem Oil. I'm posting a article below. After reading this article please give me your comments and thoughts. Thank You!

----------------------------------------------------------

Effects of Neem Oil on

Honey Bees and Beneficial Insects

Does neem oil hurt honey bees and other beneficial insects?

Insecticides kill insects. That's why they are called insecticides.

Usually pesticides make no difference beween pests and beneficial insects.

But neem oil is different.

As explained on the page about neem insecticide, neem oil is not really a knock down, kill-on-contact insecticide like the chemical poisons. Neem must be ingested (eaten by the bugs) to be effective.

If bugs don't eat leaves they don't get hurt. Simple.

In reality it is a little bit more complicated than that, but the fact remains that neem oil is impressive: it really does hurt bad bugs while sparing the good bugs.

Researchers have looked at it and found that neem oil is non toxic for example to spiders, butterflies and to insects that pollinate plants.

Scientists looked especially at how neem oil affects honey bees, since bees do eat plant matter, the pollen.

That's why reaseachers studied what happens if flowers get sprayed with neem oil.

And what they found is very reassuring. To see any effect the scientists had to use very high concentrations of neem. They used a lot more than you would ever use for pest control.

Only if they constantly hit the flowers with a very concentrated neem oil spray did they see an effect, and only in some small hives (medium sized and larger hives were still unaffected.)

What happens is that the bees carry contaminated pollen back to the hive and feed it to the brood. In the small hives some of the new bees could not emerge from their cells (Schmutterer and Holst, 1987).

Weekly use of a neem oil spray at a normal concentration (0.5& - 2&) will not hurt honey bees at all.

You can also rest assured that while neem hurts aphids, whiteflys and the like, it does not harm ladybugs and other predators that eat the aphids, or the tiny wasps that are parasites on many pests.

In one field trial researchers collected and counted aphids and their parasites and predators from fields. In the neem treated field there was the same amount of predator activity as in the untreated fields, and the aphids carried even higher numbers of parasites!

As I already mentioned above, the reason is that the beneficial insects don't eat the leaves and so never consume enough neem to be affected.

But you still need to be careful when you spray neem oil in your garden.

Any oil spray can smother and suffocate insects, and in that respect neem oil makes no difference between good and bad bugs.

So when you spray neem oil, please do it first thing in the morning or late in the evening, when the good bugs are least active. That way you won't hit any bees or other beneficial insects directly. The neem oil spray will dry before they land on the plants, and only the insects trying to eat your plants will die.

Read more: http://www.discoverneem.com/neem-bees-beneficial-insects.html#ixzz0NcmwccFG

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Not bad considering it's an industry-funded puff.

    Neem oil, like any oil, can smother beneficials such as good mites and ladybug larvae that don't come and go like bees.

    The risk of bees from polluted pollen would probably be limited to whole neem oil and not products like Rose Defense that have had the insecticide (azadirachtin) removed. These latter may not be significantly different from corn oil or mineral oil in the garden.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks MichaelG! Very much appreciated!

    JIM

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jim and for anyone who wants to lessen any thrips damage, another option is that I have used hot wax pepper spray just on the outside of the bud while it is developing and before it opens. This seems to protect most of the flowers By only spraying the outer bud, my hope is that the bees will still visit, since only the sepals and green are being sprayed and not the inside parts of the flower. I will still get a few markings on some blossoms, but for the most part it can alleviate things about 70%-100% clear depending on the color of the rose. The biggest concerns is that I am scaring off the bees with this hot wax pepper-- I haven't seen the native bees rolling in the pollen only landing and then taking off and it's important that bees have a good food source to survive. This is the reason why I leave my companion plants alone to help feed the bees and later when I get more prolific blooms I will try to "share" more unsprayed blossoms with them. I am truly hoping that by getting a prolific rose like Lyda, they cluster, and thus no one would be able to tell that my roses are being eaten by thrips since all they'll see is a wall of pink and white, LOL!

    Another creative idea is to tie a bamboo pole (the ones seen at Home Depot, etc) and suspend a few wax paper cups from it and put yellow or blue sticky traps inside; cover the open cups with some netting from a fabric store rubber-banded in place and letting the miniscule thrips get inside.. The netting should be small enough that ladybugs can't get in and neither can the bees.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Plant lemon basil at the base of your rose bush and you will have no thrips, but lots of bees, works great. A garden tip from P. Allen Smith.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the tips ramblinrosez7b and serenasyh!

    JIM

0