Software
Houzz Logo Print
cheri_in_maine

What never grows for you WS?

17 years ago

Just curious to see what you have tried winter sowing and have had no luck with.

For me, that would be Perennial Phlox and Delphinium. I try every year with the same results - natta - zilch!

My best success has always been Lupine. After planting tons of WS seedlings, there are always a couple of containers that get left behind when I'm tired of planting - through the sopping wet and bone dry, it seems the Lupine don't care.

Comments (18)

  • 17 years ago

    Well, in 5 full years of WS, on #6 now, I haven't found anything that didn't WS for me.

    Only slight glitch would be coleus. they need really warm temps to germinate and are slow to get growing, but, once planted out they do take off.

    I tried starting some inside last year, and that didn't do any better for me. Far too much of a pain to harden off the seedlings first so I could plant them outside.

    Once both where planted out though, the WS ones grew more quickly, and actually grew larger than the indoor sown ones.

    So I will start the coleus seeds outside again and be happy with those.

    Fran

  • 17 years ago

    Cleome defeats me. No sprouts, nothing. All others at least give up a few tiny sprouts.

  • 17 years ago

    Nothing.

  • 17 years ago

    Joe Pye weed and Rose of Sharon

  • 17 years ago

    Kiss-Me-Over-the-Garden-Gate. This is my sixth or seventh year trying, and not single seedling yet.

    Astrantia and Centranthus.

    These are the big three that I've been trying for years and have never had any germination.

    :)
    Dee

  • 17 years ago

    Perennial asters, the only ones I have gotten to germinate are the ones from my own seed.

  • 17 years ago

    It's my first year wintersowing, so I'll have to get back to you on that.

    Fran and Bakemom, care to share all the things you grow? I'm just curious to know what such successful gardeners grow. It'll give me someone to look up to!

  • 17 years ago

    Not everything sprouts in every year, but mostly I'm in Fran's & Bakemom's boat. I think it's strictly a matter of timing, which is not graven in stone - trial and error helps you determine what works for you. Coleus, impatiens, and others I'm not thinking of off the top of my head - work better if I sow them in late April or before. Cosmos, nasturtiums, and dahlias have a better survival rate for me if I sow them after mid-March, even though they will germinate if sown earlier. Experiment, experiment, experiment!

  • 17 years ago

    Hey littleone when did you sow the coleus? I had them on the inside list until I saw your post. I guess I will try them now. Do you remember when? Thanks.

  • 17 years ago

    There are things that were successful for me in my first year of WS that I've not been able to germinate since - columbine, coneflower and cleome immediately come to mind.

    And along with Dee, KMOTGG is a mystery to me.

    But others have been able to grow them, so I know it's not impossible.

    I just keep trying.

    PV

  • 17 years ago

    I always "try try again" and I usually hit pay dirt eventually. The only thing I haven't succeeded at yet (to my knowledge) is Japanese Flowering Cherry. But considering some of the other seeds I've been able to start by WSing, that's not a bad average.

    Delphinium...Two years it didn't work for me, three years (including this year) have. I already have sprouts in my jug of Delph' seeds (which surprised me).

    I did learn that Delph's like it dark to germinate. But mine were in Southern exposure...so maybe it was that I sowed them in the beginning of winter, rather than later in the season?

    If some things don't germinate, I always do the "Strategic Dump". Dump the container where you wouldn't mind seeing the plant grow. I was very surprised to find a "Coral Bells" had sprouted for me that I thought was dead, and come to find out, thanks to Tiffy, she identified it correctly as a Ligularia that I thought never germinated. It showed up the following year where I dumped the container.

    Linda

  • 17 years ago

    Both delphinium and cleome need 2 weeks of cold strat to germinate. Sometimes one just needs to use different seed and throw away the packet that doesn't germinate.

  • 17 years ago

    I always have a few jugs each year that don't sprout, but not necessarily the same things each year. This year is my 4th try for Platycodon, never had a sprout yet. It's possible I don't hold on to the jug long enough. I get sick of falling over jugs and do the "strategic dump" as Linda described by early summer. If the playtcodon has sprouted there, it didn't make it. But maybe I thought it was a weed and yanked it.

    Echinacea has grown for me but germination rate is usually low. Sometimes more do sprout after dumping. Lavender is another with low germination, but usually a few sprout and grow. They don't like our clay soil, though, so don't make it through our wet winters. Last year only 2 sprouted but did well. I can't swear to it but both look like they might be putting out new growth now. I'm cautiously optimistic on those.

    I agree with Drippy that timing can be everything. I keep a list of what I've sown, date sown and (approximate) date sprouted. I keep those records from past years, and if something doesn't germinate, I might try sowing it earlier or later another year and see if that gives better results.

    Karen

  • 17 years ago

    Coleus where WS April 15th and germinated May 15th.

    As for what I have sown over the past 5 years. That list is huge but here it is, in no particular order

    PERENNIALS

    1. hibiscus
    2. malva
    3. columbine
    4. lupin
    5 poppy
    6. delphinium
    6. dwarf balloon
    7. tall balloon
    8. lychnis angel's blush
    9. babies breath
    10 coreopsis
    11 dianthus

    1. candy lily
    2. blackberry lily
    3. foxglove
      15 daylilies
    4. hosta
    5. chives
    6. garlic chives
    7. oregano
    8. russian sage
    9. money plant
    10. hardy geranium
    11. oregano
    12. sedum
    13. hardy iceplant cooperi
    14. alyssum gold dust
    15. verbascum
    16. edelweiss

    ANNUALS for my area
    1. balsam impatiens
    2. annual poppies
    3. toadflax
    4. blue thimble gilia
    5. chinese forget me nots
    6. scabiosa
    7. dwarf dahlias
    8. zinnia
    9. gazania

    1. salpiglosis painted tongue
    2. bachelor buttons
    3. various types of basil
    4. parsley
    5. petunia
    6. snapdragons
    7. cosmos
    8. marigolds
    9. lobelia
    10. livingston daisy
    11. portulaca
    12. nicandra splash of crea
    13. nigella
    14. pink babies breath
    15. tomatoes
    16. bell peppers
    17. cukes
    18. zuchinnia
    19. summer squash
    20. beans
    21. snow peas
    22. 4 o'clocks
    23. nasturtium
    24. pansies
    25. viola
    26. coleus
      36 sciznathus
      37 easter egg plant
    27. cucumbers
    28. dozens of types of morning glory
    29. sweet pea
      41.alyssum sweet
    30. sunflowers
      43.datura metal
    31. cleome
    32. birdseye gilia
    33. gilardia fanfare solid gold
    34. california bluebells
    35. monkey flower
    36. godetia
    37. painted daisy
      51, gypsophilia
      52.lychnis vesuvius
      33.glacer fruits
    38. moon flower vine
      55.lavender lady
    39. salvia

    I"m sure there are some missing on the list, but you can get an idea.

    Fran

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Fran, Your list is helpful to this z5 newbie.

    Blessings,
    Dea

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I don't know if this counts or not, but I'll add Swiss Chard (of all things). I first tried DSing it last year, twice, and got one sprout. So, I figured WSing would be the ticket.

    Sowed two bottles back in January. I have one sprout in each bottle. Maybe it's just a bum pack of seeds, but I'm about done with this. "Bright Lights" my butt!

  • 17 years ago

    prof, don't blame the variety, it may be your pack of seeds as I had good germination with my Bright Lights the last two years and plan to sow more this year (all from same pack).

  • 17 years ago

    Of all things, I can't get larkspur to grow (so far). I had a few sprouts last year in a jug but they promptly died after I tried to transplant them. I direct sowed a bunch this winter and haven't seen anything to date. I am hoping the next few weeks proves me wrong and they sprout with a vengeance!

    Lois in PA

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting