Software
Houzz Logo Print
sam0738

Favorite Red

19 years ago

What is your favorite red? I like Chrysler Imperial ,Mr Lincoln and Flaming peace.

Comments (44)

  • 19 years ago

    My favorite is Veteran's Honor. Its blooms are long-lasting and fragrant. Wonderful, cut flower (especially with my Elina blooms). I did see a beautiful red at Heirloom this summer called Velvet Fragrance which I am planning to get soon. Since they are a no-spray garden, you can tell how well the rose does and this one was one of the best, disease-wise. There was also a rose called, Charlie's Rose -- red with a white reverse. Looked beautiful. It's on my list for next year. CJ

  • 19 years ago

    I sound like One-note Nelly, but I can't help it. Again I say Braveheart--big, full, rich-red bloom that stays red. In cooler weather, William Shakespeare 2000 is a dark, breath-taking red also.

    Kate

  • 19 years ago

    LOL, here we go again - one of my favorite subjects.(apricots are my other favorite color)

    If kate is one note-Nelly, I am like a broken record: Papa Meilland five times, then
    Rouge Royale, Taboo, Erotika (it stars growing after two years!), Black baccara, Grand Gala, Velvet fragrance (the most productive besides having great perfume),Royal William, Red Intuition, Lavaglut, Europeana (wasn't too good this year)

    WS2000 (in cool weather, otherwise it's pink), Prospero, Louis XIV (getting better and better). The squire would be here too but it is stingy! Black lady is nice and fragrant but I cannot get her to grow a long stemmed flower. Deep secret is improving - both of them.

    Oh, yes, and Baron Giraud de l'Ain - in spring

  • 19 years ago

    My favorite is L.D. Braithwaite and then Liebezauber.

    LDB has scads ofgorgeous flowers that just keep coming and coming. Sigh.

    Carol

  • 19 years ago

    Without a doubt ... 'Valentine'.

    Randy

  • 19 years ago

    CJ
    Velvet Fragrance Is Great. I looked it up on helpmefind roses.
    Ceterum,
    You must have a masters degree in red roses.
    Kate
    I know how you feel. I have My Favorite Mr Lincoln. I like so many other reds too.
    Lately I have notice an appreciation for the Dark ones.
    Carol
    L.D. Braithwaite is A perfect dark red rose.
    Randy
    Valentine ,looks like to me, has lots and lots of blooms. Does It?
    Samuel

  • 19 years ago

    First, these are what I have. Crysler Imperial, Mr Lincoln, Ingrid Bergman, LD Braithwaite, Shakespear 2000, Tess of D'Urbanbille, Loving Memory, and Scarlet Knight.
    Favourites: Crysler Imperial, Loving Memory, Mr Lincoln and LD Braithwaite. (LDB has virtually no fragrance). Fragrance is HUGE with me, but I just love the blooms and colour, so it is a keeper, and I pretend it smells devine!:)

    Pauline - Vancouver Island

  • 19 years ago

    I love reds!
    Mister Lincoln, in this cooler weather, it's super dark red.
    I have Falstaff, gorgeous, smells incredible.
    Chianti, I saw it last summer in bloom, WOW! Got it this year.
    I have a baby Braveheart, it is showing promise already.
    Would like to get WS 2000, Properso, Trandescant and Dragon's Blood next year.

  • 19 years ago

    WOW! A red thread and non of us mentioned Francis Dubreuil. I am so ashamed that I stop right here.

  • 19 years ago

    Ceterum, you mentioned
    **Erotika (It starts growing after two years!)**

    I'm currently in my 2nd season with it and have been somewhat disappointed. I was seriously thinking of giving it's space to another rose. I've gotten exactly 2 blooms from it that were deep dark red with really good form. The rest have been shapeless, slightly faded, smaller than expected, and short-lived. The fragrance has been terrific, though. Please tell me it gets better. Fragrance alone is not enough for me to keep this one, especially when I have Deep Secret already (small but wonderful) and am planning on getting Papa M.(which YOU enabled me into) and Chrysler Imperial (to replace the $4 body-bag virused one I ditched a year ago, lol). Is Erotica/Erotika/Eroica really worth keeping? How does it compare with....say, Royal William?

    My favorite red is currently Deep Secret--now in it's second season. It's better for me as a cut rose than in the garden. Still maturing, though.
    I luuuuuuvved Mr. Lincoln when I lived in the cool Pacific Northwest, but down here it blows too fast it is more often a murky purple-red. Plus it's 8 feet tall.

    Veteran's Honor was my best red but it got so vigorous and spreading that I had to adopt it out (Darn my little potted garden!!) It went to a nice home where it could spread out.

    Ingrid Bergman is a non-stop bloomer with intense true red color. Blooms have not been the exhibition-quality form I like, though. Olympiad is even better form-wise, and it's almost as prolific. Opening Night has even richer red coloring than either of those parents, but for me it was only a cool-weather rose; blooms weren't so great in mid-summer.

    I could go into minis now, but I won't. Over a third of my current 3 dozen roses are red. I'm kinda partial to that color.

    I'd like to get Beloved, Firefighter, Red Masterpiece, and Loving Memory, but I'm afraid all would be too large to be happy in pots. : (

    Mike

  • 19 years ago

    Red Fountain
    High Flier
    That Jazz
    Princess Margaret
    Taboo
    Velvet Fragrance-least favorite, full of bs.

  • 19 years ago

    Here in SE FL., reds do very well. But after sitting here thinking about all the red roses I've grown or have watched in other gardens, NOTHING can out perform or be as astonishing as a healthy Don Jaun.

  • 19 years ago

    Papa Meilland
    Taboo
    Corpus Christi
    Jennifer Hart
    Royal William
    Scarlett Knight
    Griff's Red

  • 19 years ago

    Veteran's Honor - big, beautiful, long lasting, non fading, and fragrant flowers; a very vigorous plant with nice foliage and lots of blooms.

  • 19 years ago

    Oklahoma so fragrant and such a dark beautiful color
    LAvaglut truly glows, great shrubby plant
    L.D.Braithwaite good rebloom
    Louis XIV this might be my #1 due to dark garnet color and rebloom

    Red Eden is looking promising..good rebloom as a new plant in a pot, very healthy, gorgeous...just no fragrance

    Fields of the Woods also looking good

    Linda

  • 19 years ago

    Lavaglut
    Mister Lincoln
    Papa Melliand
    Uncle Joe
    Liebeszauber
    Vetern's Honor
    Let Freedom Ring
    Black Magic

    Bill

  • 19 years ago

    ceterum ~ Do you think Francis Dubreuil would grow in the Pac NW? It's one I really want to try!
    Randy posted gorgeous picture of it in the gallery this summer.
    Heirloom sells it, I was very tempted to get it when I was there a few times this summer.

  • 19 years ago

    ROUGE ROYALE (Hybrid Tea, Michèle Richardier, France 2000) is my favorite red rose. It produces very large flowers on long-strong-straight stems (something that can't be said for most reproduction roses). Flower form is tightly quartered in the Old Garden Rose style with a center of bright yellow stamens. Glowing ruby red color with a satiny reverse. Deep, rich intoxicating fragrance that will make you swoon. Extended vase life. Reliable repeat bloom. Nice busy shrub. Dark green leathery foliage is a perfect counterpoint to the passionate blooms. Like most Hybrid Teas it is somewhat prone to black spot and the flowers don't age well if left on the bush (scorching summer sun tends to fade them out and cool/wet/damp ruins the centers). Good news is the flowers don't have these problems if removed from the bush and brought indoors. A top notch cut flower rose.

    MISTER LINCOLN was my late father's favorite rose, so I'm sorta sentimental about it. The petals really do look like red velvet and the very strong Damask fragrance sets the standard for what a dark red rose should smell like. The high centered flower form is nice while in bud. Fully opened flowers attractively frame the bright yellow stamens in the center. Good vase life and long stems are other pluses. On the minus side, the upright growth habit is downright lanky and the repeat bloom could be better, but all-in-all a classic red rose.

    I've been interested in VETERAN'S HONOR for years but I'm waiting for it to be offered own root. FIELD'S OF THE WOOD is an exceptional red climbing rose with superior disease resistance and lushly fragrant blossoms.

  • 19 years ago

    SAM, I have'nt grown any reds yet, but for what it's worth,
    I think William Shakespeare 2000 is awesome and the climber
    Parade is great. I've seen them in person and they are really
    something else. Let us know what you decide to grow, good
    buddy.

    Your Friend,

    Devon

    Check Out This DA Catalog Pic Of WS 2000

    {{gwi:336959}}

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Devon, I want to get WS2000 very much.
    Thanks Patrick Molineux, I guess the plant Mr Lincoln is Lanky just like the former great president. Also , I had to get a few Mr Lincolns To get the satisfying amount of blooms.

  • 19 years ago

    Mister Lincoln has been around for a long time with it's velvety petals. It has been sniggered at as it is so common, but I like it and is probably my FAV red.

    VH looks like it is going to be a great rose. It has been popular with the judges. It looks like it will be a good garden rose also.
    Talking of taller roses Liebeszauber is no slouch. Climbers? Altissimo is outstanding, although it often has an extra half formed petal that needs to removed to have that perfect flower. It is not that hard to tip or do a modified tip for your climbers in zone 4-5.

    Ingrid Bergman is a bloom machine.

    Through Patrick's enabling ROUGE ROYALE is still on my list.

    If you like Floribundas and don't mind spraying Europeana is a nice rose.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Europeana

  • 19 years ago

    Papa Melliand by far, its so hot here most reds look hot pink, but not Papa! He's a gorgeous deep red and the bud form is beautiful, with a wonderfully fragrant bloom...He's my favorite red around.

    ~Rose

  • 19 years ago

    Black Magic, Veterans' Honor and the mini-flora, Memphis King

  • 19 years ago

    I don't recommend ROUGE ROYALE for zone 5a. I had one die from cold because I left it out one winter in a micro-climate at the bottom of my garden where frigid air tends to pool. Thusly, she is hardy only in zone 6. Iowa-Jade, if you must have this rose then make sure to site her close to a south facing wall in a raised bed.

  • 19 years ago

    Loves Magic is nice.

  • 19 years ago

    I didn't mention Mr. Lincoln that I have and love but I replaced an old chain store variety that was 8' tall already with a multiflora grafted one from Pickering this spring. This rose is very slow to establish to begin with but in this year drought it is just sitting there and does not do too much. It is not the roseÂs fault, it is not Pickering's fault - they sent me a very good plant -, but in this weather I am happy that Mr. Lincoln is alive at all.

    Mike, as to Erotika, someone (maybe roseJennifer - spelling?) from Maryland has said that this rose is disease free, can be grown in full sun without burning and grows to 6'. I knew that it has a strong damask fragrance - so, what else do I need to get a dark red rose? My plant from Hortico was, however, not of first rate, to say the least. I also have the suspicion that it was not grafted onto multiflora but onto canina that is supposedly much slower; but proof I do not have.

    Erotika gave me a couple of delicious blooms in the first year but the entire plant stayed under 2'. Well, it was planted behind Jardins de Bagatelle that is a medium size rose but JdB grew minimum double of the size of Erotika both in height and width. I kept forgetting about having this rose so much was it lost behind JdB and in the huge bush of black and blue Salvia. But, it stayed alive so I decided to leave it in its spot. It is still less than 3' but yesterday I harvested two sinfully fragrant blooms of this plant and it had one or two new basals - in this year I cannot expect more of a rose, especially if it was not a great starter plant; and this one was not.

    I will get out the salvia from that place (although it was sunk into the soil in a pot) and next year I give extra attention and more fertilizer to this plant. Rain, rain and rain would also help a lot! I may get another one from Appalachian roses - I know that Ron hasa good clone but I am running out of place (what am I talking about? I run put of place three years ago!).

    How Erotika compares to Royal William? It is a difficult question and in case of my plants it isn't a fair comparison. My Royal William came from Pickering and it was a great healthy plant with good roots and lot of canes. Planted in an eastern exposure in a back row, it grew like weed to get more sun. Royal William is a huge and very productive rose and the big blooms have very good HT shape flowers while Erotika has, so far, more old-fashioned flowers. RW is fragrant but you canÂt mention its fragrance on the same day as you talk about Erotika. Erotika is that more fragrant.

    So, patience.... I assume it is worth it.

  • 19 years ago

    Proud Land because it's my only red and it was a gift. It does have a nice fragrance to it too and I like the shade variances depending on temps.

  • 19 years ago

    My favorite red HT is Papa Meilland. Exceptional strong damask rose fragrance and red/burgundy velvet petals:

    {{gwi:336961}}

    My favorite red OGRs are:

    1) Souvenir D Alphonse Lavallee (A Hp that is dark red in early stages and turn deep royal purple. Fragrance to die for on a compact bushy plant:

    {{gwi:336962}}

    {{gwi:336963}}

    Another smaller HP I like is Souvenir Du Dr Jamaim: Wonderful heavy old rose Fragrance from burgundy red flowers:

    {{gwi:213445}}

    For ease of growth (gets huge) HP Hugh Dickson has a very strong old rose/raspberry scent:

    {{gwi:336964}}

    Also the Gallica Tuscany is a sight to behold... Red glowing velvet turning/burgundy:

    {{gwi:336965}}


    Best Red Austins ...tie between WS 2000 and Othello:

    Ws 2000:

    {{gwi:313397}}

    Othello: Maybe the worlds most fragrant rose?

    {{gwi:336966}}

    I also like Mr. Lincoln, Crimson Glory, Oklahoma, Rouge Royale, Hanne, Erotika, Taboo, Isabel Renaissance, Ingrid Bergmann, Deep Secret, Taboo, and Eugene Furst.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you Niels (Cupshaped) . What a wonderful slide show. It shows why many people like Papa Meilland as their Favorite.
    Ramblin rose
    I want to get Loves Magic also. AKA as the Kordes HT Liebezauber which is also the favorite of many.
    Leslie
    It looks like Proud Land is a great rose coming from Great parentage like Chrysler Imperial Which is also the favorite of many.
    Samuel

  • 19 years ago

    Griff's Red surprised me last weekend with some large fragrant red blooms. This rose is disease resistant and survives the winter unlike so many others. William Shakespeare 2000 is not hardy here.

  • 19 years ago

    CRIMSON GLORY. Fragrance can't be beat.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh, I love this thread! Red, red, red- my favorite! Mine are all babies, so cannot really contribute, but I have Dame d'Coeur, Dusky Maiden, Deep Secret, Fields of the Wood, Altissimo (I like the bloom), Home Run, & Red Cascade. Arriving soon- Alec's Red, Illusion, Raven, Royal William and Chrysler Imperial. On my future list- Taboo, Papa Meilland (thanks to ceterum! and now cupshaped's great pic) , probably Braveheart (thanks to Kate!), Red Intuition (ceterum strikes again! and this time w/ a rose that is not even available!!!), Valentine and Eutin.
    Note that all these are for a no-spray garden, so some may not make it.
    The only one I can give you feedback on is Robusta- thumbs down for bs, unfortunately. Brandy

  • 19 years ago

    I also love red roses. I like the deep, rich colors like Mr. Lincoln, Chrysler Imperial and Oklahoma. If big, red and stinky appeals to ya...

    {{gwi:216811}}

    William Shakespeare 2000 is another great red:

    {{gwi:209850}}

  • 19 years ago

    Shame! I forgot to mention Crimson Glory!!! The mother or father of all fragrant reds. I have it; it is OK as far as disease resistance goes but not a great cut flower - for me. ItÂs OK, most fragrant reds do not stay in the garden if I spot them on time, they are cut and brought in. But Papa M is even better as fragrance goes; in addition it is a great cut flower.

    I also have Ena Harkness that was a one cane wonder from Hortico. I almost discarded it after reading Cass' very negative opinion on it. But, instead, I potted up, got some alfalfa in spring and voila, she has 3 canes and blooms very nicely. And fragrant. I think I will keep it in a pot - it looks like it is a smaller red like Deep Secret.

    I too have Veterans' Honor but so far it is not among my favorites though it is a very productive rose. If you all say that it is fragrant, I believe you but compared to the rest, well...

    I didn't mention Vino Rosso either that is a florist rose and in its first year was gorgeous. Then it seemed to decline. Again, it was dug up, potted up and now it is improving, no scent though. The other strange thing about it is that being a florist rose always blooms on short and weak stems.

    Brandy, if you want Red Intuition, order it now  for next year from Steve. I think Calvin also has it grafted on fortuniana.

    I wanted to order a stinky red from Vintage (along with other roses) but in this drought and often being incapacitated, I doubt that I could manage any band to survive.

  • 19 years ago

    Did anyone mention Mirandy?

    Brandy, you may want to ask Donny about that one. It is a very fragrant, very purple red and Donny swears that it is "no spray". Mine is in too much shade so it does not bloom often enough but the fragrance is to die for.

    Brandy, Red Intuition may not be so good in a no-spray garden. The foliage is OK more or less but it gets canker; or, this year it got canker even in the worst summer heat, so maybe it is not so bad that it is not available to you this year. Maybe, just maybe if we get a better weather next year, I can give you a better report. Or, since you must live close by, you could come and visit me to see a few roses you plan to get. But this year I don't accept visitors except if they are willing to weed.

    (I am looking for a stone sign that Brian has in his garden that say: "weeds are free. Pick your own". I would even give free perennials or roses to those who are willing to help me out. No such luck.)

  • 19 years ago

    I guess Mirandy and Chrysler Imperial are "no spray" because I don't spray and they are the healthiest of the bunch. I just took a bush shot of Mirandy. I could smell their divine fragrance just standing next to them!

    Mirandy
    {{gwi:336967}}

  • 19 years ago

    Ceterum- I am willing to weed. I am nearly desperate to actually see some of these roses, instead of just looking at
    them in pictures! I am out of town (in Wilmington) at the moment, but will be returning Fri. Brandy

  • 19 years ago

    Brandy, you must be kidding. We live in the same town. LOL.

    My roses do bloom that is a miracle in itself but the weeds are absolutely awful.

    How about this weekend? LOL.

  • 19 years ago

    My grandmother grew 'Mirandy' way back in the day and I remember the bush always having at least a flower or two whenever I would go to visit her. It is the only rose she had that she knew by name. The fragrance was to die for. It seemed to be quite winter hardy, too.

  • 19 years ago

    Alright, Rainbow, you and ceterum have enabled me into Mirandy. (I was fortunate to see enough to actually see it among ceterum's gorgeous rose collection.) I will put her on my list. I have already ordered Chrysler Imperial. Brandy

  • 19 years ago

    Samuel, yes, 'Valentine' is almost always covered in blooms.

    Valentine (Click on me to enlarge){{gwi:329245}}

  • 19 years ago

    And the incomparable Francis Dubreuil, one of the most fragrant roses of all time.

    Randy

    {{gwi:282270}}

  • 19 years ago

    IT is both a beauty and very fragrant red Randy! Even though mine must be grown in a pot and winterized in the basement I grow it for the fragrance.

    And Harry: your pictures of Oklahoma and WS are really good!!!

    Rainbows Mirandy look incredibly healthy for a HT!

  • 19 years ago

    Niels, I've also had good luck growing FD in a large container (even though he can easily be grown in the ground here).

    Randy

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH