Software
Houzz Logo Print
morrisnoor

How about 'The Old Rose Advisor'?

18 years ago

I think I "need" this book (....hate Amazon!!!! LOL).

But also like to hear about it to you ;o)

Seems to be one of the most comprehensive books on old, reflowering Roses. I was looking for a book about Teas, chinas and related, but nothing seems to be available about...

So.... HELP!! :o))

Grazie mille!

Maurizio

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    You need it if you are seriously interested in old roses and rose history. It is a compilation of the contents of a large number of old nursery catalogues and other sources contemporaneous with the roses themselves. No pictures. Some information is scant because of the lack of sources.

    I don't have this volume but I have the sequel on the old European once-flowering roses, 'The Old Rose Adventurer'. I use it very often especially when I come across an unknown rose. I am taking part in a national Swedish project to collect and record unknown found roses. I also check it when I find a dubious modern description of a rose, like that of the HP La Reine sold today. I am very fond of Brent Dickerson's old-fashioned style of writing, too.

  • 18 years ago

    I have the original editions of both the Advisor and the Adventurer and they are a masterwork by someone who had access to phenomenal library collections, who used those collections to produce a summary that is simply wonderful.
    Unlike many rose books, these are clear in their source material, so it's possible to read more or to read in context.
    Both originals do have plates copied from the sources.

    I have read that some corrections and additions were made for the second edition of the Advisor. Has anyone bought both editions, and is there enough new info to merit my buying the 2nd edition of the Advisor?

    Because the dollar is low versus most European currencies, I've linked to a site advertising a reprint of the (totally wonderful) chromolithograhps from the Journal des Roses from the late 1800's early 1900's. I have the first three volumes that are wonderful and opulent and the colors are breathtaking. I've seen images of some of the chromolithographs before, but in these books there is a true-to-the-original vibrancy that is simply unequaled elsewhere. The quality translations of the text are also well done. They are the perfect collectibles for me.

    (I felt the same way when I opened my first BCD Advisor, which was the beginning of my addiction to rose literature.)

    Here is a link that might be useful: THE Encyclopedia of Antique Roses

  • 18 years ago

    Wow! I would sure like the Encyclopedia one! Thanks Ann for letting us know about it. Wonder how much it'll cost.

  • 18 years ago

    I have both the Advisor and Adventurer, and wouldn't be without them.

    Jeri