Software
Houzz Logo Print
gretzky099

Hardy yellow rose recommendations?

14 years ago

Hi folks, haven't posted on garden web in a loooong time, so good to be back. I'm hoping someone can help me out with a recommendation or two. I'm looking for a yellow rose that would do well in zone 4/5, ideally without a lot of winter protection. The rose will be planted on the east side of my new home next spring, so will be protected from the worst of our central Iowa winter winds. I'd like to find one that's more or a dark or golden yellow color, stays somewhat compact, and is a repeat bloomer. (Not asking for much, am I?) I've been looking at the Golden Unicorn Buck Rose, but not sure if that's quite yellow enough. Any thoughts on that rose or any others that might fit the bill? Thanks! Mark

Comments (16)

  • 14 years ago

    Hi gretzky,

    I have a suggestion that you might want to consider. It's the most YELLOW rose I've ever seen, Rosa foetida 'Persian Yellow'. It is hardy to zone 3b. I got it this year myself, and although usually said to be a once-bloomer it gifted me with a small second flush which was a nice surprise. I don't know that it would do so in a colder climate. This rose is supposed to be susceptible to blackspot, so if that is a problem in your area.... I had some roses blackspot in my garden this year--a rare occurence. However, although the blackspotted roses were near Persian Yellow, it didn't get a speck of disease. I am under no illusions, as there are multiple varieties of blackspot, and whichever one(s) that Persian Yellow is susceptible to just may not have been present. You might not be so lucky. This is a rose I hadn't ever seriously considered before eventhough the pictures of it in books always showed a very intense yellow that appealed to me, there was also the consistent comment of "unpleasant fragrance". I'd never given much thought to what that meant, just assumed it was something unpleasant to me (like the rotting flesh smell coming from gingko biloba fruit!). But this year I saw Persian Yellow growing at a nursery and took the opportunity to sniff. Was I ever surprised. Unpleasant meant the scent of linseed oil. Well I like that smell. Persian Yellow came home with me.;) I would love to have 6 or 7 of them growing in my garden, and if I learn to propagate, I will!

    Melissa

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rosa foetida 'Persian Yellow'

  • 14 years ago

    Westerland is more an apricot/orange than a true yellow, but it is a bomb-proof repeater, disease free. I grow one on an exposed wall and it gets large enough to climb into my willow tree--very pretty. In your colder zone it might well stay smaller.

    For a true golden yellow, that might need some protection in your zone--My mom grows Graham Thomas in southeastern WI (5a) with relatively minimal winter protection (some mulch over the base and bud union buried). Hers is about 3 feet tall.

  • 14 years ago

    None the Dr. Buck yellows that I've grown or seen hold their yellow color well. 'Carefree Sunshine' might work for you, fades some & only needs a little winter protection. I've had good luck with 2 yellow floribundas if you plant the bud union 2-4" underground & give them a little winter protection, 'Sunsprite' & 'Julia Child'

  • 14 years ago

    The only hardy rose I have is Morden Sunrise. It's a yellow blend but beautiful all the same.

  • 14 years ago

    I got Prairie Harvest from Pickering. This is the second year for it so it started to hit its stride this year and it performed well. Morden Sunrise is a blend, not so yellow but I have had it for several years so it is tough, but smaller. Carefree Sunshine is in its first year here but performed well. I did not cover it with a cone this year but as I think about it, that might be a good idea. But the yellow I have high hopes for is High Voltage out of Bailey's Nursery in Minnesota. It is part of their Easy Elegance collection. Bailey's does not do mail order so you will have to find a nursery in your area that can order it for you. Supposed to be hardy. Did pretty well this year for the first year and I think it has the potential to be my best yellow. I am encouraged because of the really good performance of Bailey's other roses for me, Survivor and Sigrid. My winter so far is unusual in that I don't have any snow cover here in Michigan's upper peninsula yet. I usually can count on a white Veteran's Day. I had to force myself to stop gardening and start battening down the hatches in preparation for the cold and snow.

  • 14 years ago

    Yellow Submarine, an Easy Elegance rose, has been hardy for me in zone 5 without winterizing and is an excellent re-bloomer. I really like Morden Sunrise too - it has a wonderful fruity scent and is a good re-bloomer. Golden Unicorn is a lovely rose but doesn't hold its semi-double blooms well - they often fold up in a day or two. Carefree Sunshine has been hardy for me - it's in a semi-shady spot so it's stayed small but healthy.

  • 14 years ago

    Here are pictures of some of my yellows:

    Prairie Harvest (dislikes)= short bloom life & fades out quickly in warm weather, (likes)= reasonably hardy in z4a, good disease resistance, one of my favorite rose fragrances & in full bloom perfumes the whole front yard.
    {{gwi:324439}}

    High Voltage (Easy Elegance rose)seems to have decent hardiness, good disease resistance but fades to cream color very fast
    {{gwi:246532}}

    Centennial (EE rose) decent hardiness & disease resistance but short for a Grandiflora, good for cut roses, kind of a different yellow color--I believe some describe its color as "apricot"
    {{gwi:246529}}

    Tahitian Moon (EE rose) a short climber for me & one of my most tender EE roses, I just mulch it with wood chips & it dies back to the crown, grows back to 3' tall at first bloom cycle & reaches 6' tall by second bloom cycle for me, good disease resistance & holds its yellow color well
    {{gwi:339538}}

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks for the recommendations everyone! I should be able to find something that will work well for my location out of all the suggestions. Thanks again!

  • 14 years ago

    Second the Persian Yellow idea, and I'd add in Harison's Yellow...perfectly hardy in your climate and very very yelllow; see link below

    Here is a link that might be useful: Harison's Yellow on Garden Musings blog.

  • 14 years ago

    The rugosa 'Agnes' is extremely hardy, but I don't believe it repeats much. David Austin's 'Crocus Rose' is light yellow fading to cream.

  • 14 years ago

    Harison's Yellow is a once bloomer.

  • 14 years ago

    Sorry, I missed the repeat blooming request. Try Golden Celebration...Austin rose that should do well at least to zone5...good repeats and it is certainly yellow enough. I blogged on it as well.

    Here is a link that might be useful: golden Celebration blog

  • 14 years ago

    What about the Kordes rose 'Golden Fairy Tale'? The main page on HMF lists it as hardy to zone 5b, but i noticed that there were several gardens in zone 4 that grow it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Golden Fairy Tale on HMF

  • 14 years ago

    I really like my "Julia Child's" roses. I know the colour is described a buttery gold but for me it is a beautiful yellow. It has easily survived my zone 5 winter multiple times.

  • 14 years ago

    I would be careful about golden celebration. Mine did not make it through the first winter. Charlotte is much hardier.