Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19696490

Does soil create too much pressure in an unmortared bed?

18 years ago

With a bed in an area that is not all all level, and is stacked stone, but not mortared, would the soil create so much pressure, especially when wet, that the wall would be unstable and move around?

This bed would be only about 6 inches in the back and as much as 25 inches in the front, to keep it flat. I am not worried about the expense of the soil but the need to add a mortared footer for the wall would add a lot of expense.

Does anybody know what I am talking about or is my description too confusing?

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    Have you considered using stackable blocks?
    Those are very, very stable. We've used them all over the hillside.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    Given a hilly, rocky lot, I've done a fair amount with what I call teeny-tiny retaining walls. The tallest is maybe a foot. Personally, I'd drop the height so the back is level with the native soil. Given a slight slope down, which will help both visually and with drainage, that makes the front wall a little less than 18" tall. Dry stone walls aren't usually very stable by nature, so the idea is to make them short enough that all disaster means is you have a bit of work to do. At that height, large stones are quite stable, smaller stones that I can deal with have to be messed with every now and then.

    Something to keep in mind if you decide to do this, is that a lot of people plan for planting pockets in the wall. If you want hanging plants, keeping spaces open for them from the beginning really does help with the planting.

  • 18 years ago

    Mad G, if the back is level with the soil, do you mean that there would not be any rock back there at all? Wouldn't that make the wall look unfinished?

    I thought the top had to be flat or I would have more of a problem with drainage, i.e, the water would all run down there, is that not the case?

    Jeri we can also consider the stackable blocks but our driveway walls are creek stone so we wanted it to match if possible.

  • 18 years ago

    According to Robert Frost,

    Something there is that doesn't love a wall,
    That sends the frozen-ground-swell under it,
    And spills the upper boulders in the sun,
    And makes gaps even two can pass abreast.
    . . . . . . . . .
    No one has seen them made or heard them made,
    But at spring mending-time we find them there.

    Robert Frost, "Mending Wall"

    Don't know myself--just taking Bobby at his word about unmortared New England walls.

    Kate : )

  • 18 years ago

    Depends on the stones. The thing about unmortared is, if the wall blows out you can always restack it.

    Try asking over at the Landscape Design forum. They have pros over there that can tell you. Kind of a tough crowd over there, though, so be prepared for a different tone of answer that what you would get here.

  • 18 years ago

    None of my stacked stone walls have footings. Many are taller than 25 inches. Done right, there will be no problems. I have stacked stone walls that are 36 inches tall. We use a local rock known as Sonoma Field Stone, not the flat rock you see back east.

    The taller the wall, the larger the stone at the base. The 36 inch walls have boulders at the base. Stacking isn't just a matter of sticking rocks on top of one another.

  • 18 years ago

    Berndoodle, do you have any pictures of your walls by any chance? I am just trying to learn how to go about it. Thank you.

  • 18 years ago

    Here are a few rock walls, not the tallest but enough to show these principles. Stone is completely modular and recyclable. If you build any walls, you will surely get a black fingernail (or two) and hurt your back. I'm too old for this work, being more in the preservation mode, myself.

    1) You create a "footing" which puts the base layer of rock slightly below grade. Our footings are nothing more than loosening a slight trench in native soil a few inches deep. We don't use gravel or rock fines. Our soils drain fine, and we often fill with imported topsoil.
    2) Field stone comes in sizes. Smallest is called cobble, which is useless for anything except the bottom of a streambed and other surface decoration. Next size is called boulder. That's what you need. You use big boulders at the base and also larger rocks than you might think for the tops if you need them to stay in place. Some of the top rows of rocks here don't have to do much work and will be obscured by plants, so not much work was put into making them secure. Other top rows are quite stout.
    3) The wall is not vertical, even though it might appear vertical. It actually has a very decent slope away from vertical. Think of the pyramids. You fill behind the wall with soil as you build.
    4) Rocks are placed roughly in the brickwork pattern known as running bond, where the joints never line up.
    5) It's harder than it looks. Craftsmen-built walls last centuries, which you can see in ancient cities around the world.

    The first four shots are various portions of a long drainage swale that is a key feature in my landscape. The river cobble in the bottom is from native rock found in the garden. The last few shots are a variety of small or large field stone retaining walls.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rock Walls

  • 18 years ago

    redsox..if you're worried about it, why not just line the sides with landscape fabric? it would be invisible, and allow water to drain out, but not the soil..that's what i would do. donna

  • 18 years ago

    Redsox, in your zone, you will probably need to dig a little deeper, and fill the trench with sand, gravel and/or stone chips to stabilize everything, because of the frost heaving that might occur. Around here, we see a lot of crooked, crumbling creations because people didn't take that little extra step in preparation. By the way, have fun lugging those sacks of chipped rock, sand and gravel around - it nearly killed me!
    Judith

  • 18 years ago

    A poured footing will not make the wall more stable. It will just inhibit drainage. The purposes of a footing are (1) to get below the frost line and prevent heaving and (2) to spread the load and prevent sinking.

    To achieve (1), start the stacked wall in a trench at least 6" deep. Here we haven't had frost deeper than that for 25 years. It takes a week or more with lows consistently between 5 and -5 and highs in the 20s.

    Settling (2) won't be a problem with an unmortared wall 18" high. Unmortared walls can stand a little shifting.

    As berndoodle says, the stability depends on the size of the rocks. If they are around 12" wide (thickness of the wall) I think the mass would be enough to resist the lateral pressure of 18" height of soil.

  • 18 years ago

    redsox,

    I think for a dry stacked wall you need some sort of footing. But as michaelg says, deep freeze isn't really going to be a major problem. I would dig that shallow trench-- 6 to 8 inches deep about 4 inches wider than the wall-- be sure to compress the soil at the bottom of the trench and fill it with 4-6 inches of compacted wall/paver base. (use the same stuff that they sell at home depot or lowes for the stackable blocks) then start laying your wall.
    be sure to stagger the joints as you build and level the stones as you go. its important to use small stones wedged between the larger ones to 'lock' things in place-- to keep things from shifting.

    I'm not sure if you are building on a slope with a wall only on one side of the bed, or if you are building a bed over an uneven site where one side of the bed might be a course or two higher. But either way you have to deal with the pressure or the dirt in the bed pushing the wall out.
    To counter act this problem, builder use a "batter"-- that is the wall leans back into the bed rather than being completely vertical-- this is a angle od usually less than 15 degrees. Over time the dirt will shift and cause the wall to bow out (as this happens you just rebuild the wall--the virtue of dry stack method)

    Other things that help are using big stones at the bottom, and increasing the drainage behind the wall with a backfill of gravel- be dure to isolate the gravel with landscape fabric so that the grave doesn't fill in with dirt and stop providing drainage. Even on the stort wall that i have (under 18 inches) i notice the problem of shifting after about 3 years and have to rebuild a bit. but i work in
    heavy clay soilmon low walls with no footings or additional drainage-- I know what the solution should be, just don't feel like doing it all over again. i would suggest that you take the time to do the proper 'foundation' and installation
    to avoid continual maintainance repairs.

    the folks at landscape design forum are often professionals, the people at the gardening with stone forum
    are much less intimidating and usually are doing the work themselves.

    diggerb2
    diggerb

  • 18 years ago

    The soil in my area is sand so I have a natural base as long as I level it. A 40' wall I built three years ago out of 6x12x8" stackable blocks sits directly on this sand. My soil freezes each winter and the wall has held up with no heaving or loss of soil. I used no landscape frabric or other material to prevent soil loss from drainage. The blocks are made so that each one sits back an inch more than the one under it so the wall leans a little into the slope it holds back. This slight lean is not noticable. The wall ranges from 6 to 36" high and does a great job holding my hill back from the greenhouse and parking area it protects.
    I might add this area gets watered daily and is in the shade so it usually has wet soil. It is not mortared

  • 18 years ago

    We've been away, which is why I haven't gotten back to this thread earlier.

    Robert Frost is right that an unmortared, stacked stone wall isn't really a permanent fixture. So they get rebuilt every now and then. For small walls it shouldn't be a big deal.

    If the wall fades into the hill, it doesn't look like a well, it looks like an extension of the hill. If we didn't have snow, I'd show some pictures of my walls, and how they end into the ground. Something that may or may not matter is that mine are built with extremely local stone. The longest wall in the back is made of stone that moved about 5 ft, up and over. So it acts as a neutral material and doesn't stand out at all.

    In my heavy soil, water will puddle on a flat surface, so beds tend to be made with some sort of slope. Most times, you have to look very closely to see it, but it is there. The whole point of this is, that for several reasons you don't want to be building the Great Wall of China. There are walls around here where the point is the craftsmanship and materials of the wall, so the wall itself is very much a design element. I'm not getting the idea that that is what is wanted here. The wall is simply meant to be something holding up the plants.

    Around here, they sell something they call wallstone. It's flat stones that are thicker and smaller than paving stones. It looks larger than I personally am comfortable working with, and also costs money. The shorter the wall, the smaller the stones it can be built from.

Sponsored
NME Builders LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Remodeling Company in New Albany, Ohio