Software
Houzz Logo Print
kentucky_rose

J&P Spring Roses 2011 catalog

I received a Jackson & Perkins Spring Roses 2011 catalog in the mail. Anyone know what's going on?

Comments (43)

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, I received one today too and I'm wondering the same thing. It's as if nothing happened. I didn't think they even had any stock left. And there are a bunch of new roses, like the wine-themed ones on p.2.

    Terry/Rosibug

  • 15 years ago

    How odd

  • 15 years ago

    Weeks produced some of this last crop of roses for them (and didn't get paid for it, either).
    I don't think I'd place any orders, myself. If they don't come through, what are you going to do?

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    American bankruptcy laws go back at least a century and protect crops in the ground until the crops can be harvested - at two years.

    I stumbled on this when reading about Walter van Fleet's time at Ruskin Colony. The Colony self destructed and all of the descriptions of what would be put up at auction to satisfy the creditors excluded crops in their growing fields that would belong to the Colony until they were harvested and sold.

    (Van Fleet had left the Colony weeks before it self destructed. Seedlings he had created---I haven't been able to find out if they stayed in Tennessee or went with him to his nursery in New Jersey.)

  • 15 years ago

    I just realized that the new "Merlot" is the same picture as "Fairest One" (Snow White) from last season's Disney Princess collection. "Champagne" is the same as "Beauty Within" (Beauty and the Beast). Does anyone know if Cabernet Sauvignon is a renamed rose as well? I like the look of that one.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rare Roses Blog

  • 15 years ago

    The photo that they used for Cabernet Sauvignon is the same photo that they used in last year's catalogs for Heirloom. It's just been flipped over. The description of the rose is different, but the photo is clearly wrong. I wouldn't order anything on the basis of that picture.

    The photo on Rose' (rose-ay, like the blush wine) also appears to be wrong. I think that is really the same rose they sold last year as Love's Kiss.

    This catalog has got lots of problems, indicative of an inexperienced staff, which they clearly are, after firing their whole marketing team as part of the bankruptcy. I found amusing the note that was left on the far right side of page 2 -- "Sappho needs to write something to go here."

    Kathy

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for pointing that out Kathy. I didn't look that closely. It's definitely indicative of trying to make something out of nothing. I guess they're trying to dump what they couldn't give away before.

  • 15 years ago

    I received their catalog also. Note on page 11: Mesmerized is the NEW name for the older Spellbound (intro 2007 HT, ARS rating 7.5).

  • 15 years ago

    I sent an email to J&P inquiring about Cabernet Sauvignon and the others being renamed older roses. It turns out that Cabernet Sauvignon IS their new name for Heirloom, and now they are claiming it as an "Exclusive" new intro. Here's what they said:

    QUOTE:
    fromStephan Winterfeldt
    sender-timeSent at 5:51 AM (GMT-05:00). Current time there: 11:03 AM. âÂÂ
    to

    dateThu, Dec 30, 2010 at 5:51 AM
    subjectRE: Feedback Form for JacksonAndPerkins
    mailed-byparkseed.com

    hide details 5:51 AM (2 hours ago)

    Hi,

    Here is the info. we have available that we can share.

    Beauty Within is now called Champagne
    Fairest One is now called Merlot
    Love's Kiss - ? (trying to find out new name)

    It appears that last years "Heirloom" rose is now Cabernet Sauvignon as well.

    Stephan


    ________________________________________
    From: JP CustServ
    Sent: Monday, December 27, 2010 1:11 PM
    To: Stephan Winterfeldt
    Subject: FW: Feedback Form for JacksonAndPerkins

    Jackson and Perkins Order #

    Thank you so much for contacting us here at Jackson and Perkins! We value our customers� comments and questions highly, and we appreciate hearing from you.


    Again, thank you for writing to us. If you have any further questions or comments, please do not hesitate to contact us. To help us serve you better, please use the Reply button to respond so that all previous communications will be included. Thank you for gardening with Jackson and Perkins!

    Jackson and Perkins Customer Contact Team
    2 Floral Avenue
    Hodges, South Carolina 29653
    Telephone: 800-292-4769
    Fax: 800-242-0329

  • 15 years ago

    I wish I'd get my catalog soon. I'm dying to see it! Not everything is on their website. There's been a big discussion about this on another forum. We're pretty sure CRESCENDO is from the test roses in the 2010 batch, and possibly CHARDONNAY too. However, the codename on CHARDONNAY is for a rose from the 2006 test panel. The 2010 roses didn't have codenames on their tags, just numbers. So we're not sure if they are the same or not. Both roses were really lousy first-season bloomers. And in fact the one I've had for 4yrs has not been very impressive at all. The blooms are messy and don't last long... and don't repeat well.

    It's all rather interesting. I bet they changed the names of the Disney Princess roses due to royalties having to be paid to promote them.

  • 15 years ago

    The renaming of roses is nothing new for the industry, but particularly J&P. Remember Jadis? It didn't sell well here due to the French name. It was available in Canada but not to be shipped here because of patent right restrictions, until they renamed it Fragrant Memory. Remember Cesar E. Chavez? A nice red HT. It became Beloved. How many different roses have they sold as Habitat for Humanity? Each one has the year attached to the name as they were different cultivars. These are just a few examples of the established practice.

    It's always been common for European roses brought here. Who would know, or even care what Peadouce is/was? I understand it's the British "Huggies". Elina is a much more suitable name for it here. How about Garden Director Bartje Miller? For years the garden director of the Wrigley Garden in Pasadena and VERY deserving of a GOOD rose being named for her. Instead, she got this, and it's even currently also called Dark Night and Eddy Mitchell.

    The suggestion that the Princess series roses was likely renamed to avoid royalties probably had an element of truth, but I'd also bet they'd sold as many of them under those names as they thought they could move. At least "booze" names have a much wider audience!

  • 15 years ago

    A thought as I hit send, bankruptcy very likely voided the contract J&P had with Disney. Who knows? Perhaps Disney was one of the companies bankrupted against? Renaming the roses was more than likely necessary to continue selling better selling roses not possible otherwise. It also adds an air of "new and exciting" to the otherwise "left overs" selection.

    J&P raised millions of seedlings over the decades and created some interesting, even good, roses along the way. The Test Panel roses represented ones which they felt weren't good enough to promote with their limited advertising dollars, but too good to dump. The Test Panel allowed them to collect money on otherwise dead inventory. At least by pulling their marketing "promotions" over the years, we benefitted from some decent roses which otherwise wouldn't have made it. Too bad they didn't promote some of the better ones such as Gardens of the World.

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, roseseek, I realize renaming roses is common. But it is NOT common to rename them and then claim in your catalog that you have "EXCLUSIVE" right to sell them, which is what is happening here with Heirloom, a common cultivar available nearly everywhere. They even gave it a new IRAR code name. JACgedor as opposed to JACbloom.

    Sorry, I think that's fraud, and probably mail fraud at that.

  • 15 years ago

    Agreed, Kathy, it does feel like fraud. They can probably get around that though by being the ONLY one to be able to sell it by those names. I know you're going to find Heirloom (IF you really WANT it) under that name from other producers, perhaps even under the J&P label, but I'd bet you will only find it under the wine name from J&P. Offering the same product under different names is common in many industries. It used to gripe me no end about Ortho offering Home Pest Defense in the gallon RTU spray bottle for one price, and along side it Home Pest Defense Flea and Tick, for half again more, in the same package with the ONLY difference the inclusion of flea and tick on the label. There was NO difference in listed ingredients nor in application rates. They were (perhaps still are) identical in every way other than those words on the label and the flea and tick cost 50% MORE. We'd regularly sell out of the flea and tick while the Home Pest "regular" stuff sat there and many customers simply couldn't/wouldn't believe they could still use the regular stuff to spray for the fleas and ticks. It does feel fraudulent.

    Currently, there are two cleaning products from a manufacturer (which, I don't remember) I saw this week at Smart and Final. Both are to clean showers and both have Hydrogen Chloride at 9.5% concentration listed as their only active ingredient. All others as simply "other" ingredients. The one which is labeled to also remove rust and scale is a little over half the size of the "regular" product and sells for MORE than the other. There is nothing listed on the label as different. Both have exactly the same active ingredient at exactly the same concentration, yet one is labeled for rust and scale and costs much more for much less. I honestly don't see any difference in that and claiming an exclusive for an existing, out of patent rose under a new name. Both are misleading at the very least. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    "I found amusing the note that was left on the far right side of page 2 -- "Sappho needs to write something to go here."

    Kathy, I had to go look at my catalog. Holy crap. I can't believe they let that go to print. As someone who works in the mail-order/catalog business (not in the horticultural arena) that's an unforgivable sin.

    I just placed a small order to get an idea of what their operations look like. The only thing I really noticed is that their website didn't ask me for the CID numbers on the back of my credit card before processing it. As of last summer, that's kind of a requirement for credit card processors (to prevent fraud). Kinda tells me that they aren't putting any money towards being PCI compliant or the website.

  • 15 years ago

    Well, I finally got my catalog today, and I don't see the note on page 2... "Sappho needs to write something to go here." Apparently Sappho figured out what to write there and reprinted the catalogs!

  • 15 years ago

    Really???

    {{gwi:349888}}

  • 15 years ago

    I'm not buying one rose from them

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for posting the page Kathy. I missed it too and wondered what you were talking about. Now I see it under the header WINE and ROSES top right....Maryl

  • 15 years ago

    Kim -- Did they re-name the "Disneyland" Rose?
    If so, I wonder if they're going to again try to cheat John Walden out of his royalty rights on that'un.
    He had to threaten to take them to court, the last time around.

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    I don't know, Jeri. I wasn't aware he received the royalties. Standard practice is for them to be assigned to the nursery. I hope it makes him a bundle, but I wouldn't touch it. I love odd colors, but that one gags me. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    United States Patent PP15,114
    Walden , et al. August 31, 2004

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Floribunda rose plant named `JACmouse`

    Abstract
    Floribunda rose plant having unique flower color; compact, vigorous floribunda plant habit; dark green disease resistant foliage; and ability to grow vigorously on its own roots.

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Inventors: Walden; John K. (Loomis, CA), Zary; Keith W. (Somis, CA)
    Assignee: Jackson & Perkins Wholesale, Inc. (Medford, OR)
    Appl. No.: 10/697,612
    Filed: October 29, 2003

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  • 15 years ago

    CRESCENDO looks a lot like one of the test roses from 2010 that I have. The tag has no name just the code 02-01155.

  • 15 years ago

    LOL Kathy, I need new glasses! I didn't see the fine print!

    Well I definitely won't be ordering anything from them. I was very interested in that so-called CABERNET SAUVIGNON. But I already have HEIRLOOM. And I'm sorry, but I have never seen an HEIRLOOM bloom that looks like that photo. How I wish!!

  • 15 years ago

    I was pondering getting one of those two white blend roses, but I don't want a thrip magnet unless it is really great - both in scent and form. So, those of you who had them as test roses - how were they?

  • 15 years ago

    Since they are in bankruptcy any money they can make from this years' crops goes to their creditors, first bond holders, then everyone else. Sad how long this company was in business only to be destroyed by financial "wizards" through various financing deals.

    I love odd colors, but that one gags me. Kim

    'Disneyland' gags?!?!?

    {{gwi:242559}}

    {{gwi:349890}}

  • 15 years ago

    Yes ma'am, because it NEVER looks that brilliant and clean around here. Try muddy and barfy looking. IF I had ever come across it looking as beautiful as your photo, I would have probably bought it.

    Only Cinco de Mayo has looked worse at the nurseries in the past few years. Kim

  • 15 years ago

    This is truly a shame. I have received some of the nicest bare-root roses from these folks, but that was seasons ago. We'll have to keep an eye out this Spring at the garden centers and see what J&P Roses show up (if any) I would be very leery about ordering through this catalog now. Jay

  • 15 years ago

    Last year I bought one J&P rose from the best nursery in my area. I was replacing my Chrysler Imperial. When the thing bloomed, it was definitely not CI. Although the nursery said I could bring it back, the 80+ mile trip did not seem worth the trouble, and I found an 8.00 CI at a local box store. The J&P turned out to be a real dog, it had three single blooms, they fade fast, and I can't identify it. I will give it another year, but I suspect that J&P was unloading their culls on the nursery trade. I would never trust them again. I have discovered that roses grafted on huey do not like my Alabama humid, hot, dry summers, and I am now getting Palatine roses on multiflora. The Kordes roses seem to do especially well in my climate. Another reason I will no longer buy J&P.

  • 15 years ago

    J & P has posted -- on their website -- a blurb explaining the original picture (and the one that is in their 2011 catalog) was the wrong photo of the rose "Cabernet Sauvignon." Now they have a different, lighter picture of that rose, and not the Heirloom picture from last year, flipped over. I guess we caused some trouble over there, pointing out that Heirloom's old picture was used with the supposedly new rose. So . . . I guess Cabernet Sauvignon is not the older variety known as Heirloom after all.

    I still wish they wouldn't rename things like they seem to insist on doing. They confuse everyone -- even themselves.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The new pic of Cabernet Sauvignon

  • 15 years ago

    uh oh

    We just ordered 23 roses from JP.....including Peace... we used last year's catalog, it was all we had...we noticed that of about 24 or so roses, four had been discontinued, I found that odd. Stephen at JP helped us find replacements. As we (DH, I kill plants) don't follow Rose news, we had no clue. I just stumbled on this discussion, I'm usually on the Cooking Forum.

    order hasn't shipped yet.....

  • 15 years ago

    Now I'm confused!

    If I go to HelpMeFind.com and look up "Cabernet Sauvignon" I get that it is a synonym for Heirloom. Now J&P.com changes the pic and I'm thinking it looks a lot like one of the test panel roses they sent out last year. Which is it!?!

    For those inquiring minds that want to know, my experience with the rose is highly limited since the two that I purchased quickly died shortly after producing their first small rose (as a matter of fact one never got around to producing any roses before it died).

  • 15 years ago

    Jessy -- your roses will probably be fine. You could, no doubt, have gotten the same quality roses less expensively (J&P shipping costs an arm and a leg) by going to an Armstrongs or other local nursery, but I believe J&P will likely send you decent plants. This is a totally new crew that is doing their shipping work, but they could not change growers on a dime like that -- so it's the same plants you would have gotten under the old management. Growing roses for sale as bareroots is a two year process. The new J&P just didn't pay the growers (got out of paying for them in the bankruptcy, but got most of the plants anyway -- go figure).

    Kublakan -- I got the test panel from J&P last year. There was no lavender rose. The test panel roses, we think, are the new introductions called Chardonnay, Crescendo and Shazzam and a darker reddish pink hybrid tea that hasn't been officially released yet, but which throws enormous blooms but not often.

    Kathy

  • 15 years ago

    Kathy,

    I stand corrected. I was thinking of the test panel from two or three years ago. That rose ended up coming out as Sweetness.

    So we return to the same question: what is it?

  • 15 years ago

    I wonder if J&P read this thread?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rare Roses Blog

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks Kathy! I feel reassured and my panic is quelled. We got a discount code that helped off-set the shipping. I didn't know you could pre-order at Armstrong, I'll tell DH.

  • 15 years ago

    I would have to bet that someone from J&P is lurking both here and on the similar thread on Ros arian's Cor ner.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for mentioning Ro sarians Corner...never heard of it before...sounds like my kind of place.

  • 15 years ago

    Yah -- it'a fun group over there, but GardenWeb considers them competition, so you have to split up the name like that, or they bounce the post. But if you google it, you'll get there.

  • 15 years ago

    Here's something rather odd. In the past, I've received all of my J&P orders right away. In fact, in some years it was too early because they used to let you schedule delivery dates. (Twice I got plants delivered while I was on vacation because they came the last week of December.)

    I emailed J&P and my order from 12/30 isn't supposed to ship until 2/1 which is really strange. I usually do all of my pruning on New Year's Day but put it off this year to coincide with the delivery of the new ones. Not a big problem here because with all of the rain in SoCal in the last several weeks my gardens are still too wet. However, I'm thinking about canceling the order and just calling Walter Anderson's or Armstrong. Don't think I want to wait until mid-February to prune.

  • 15 years ago

    I got mislabled roses last time I ordered and so am afraid to try again. Does anyone else sell Heaven On Earth or should I try Armstrongs? The plant I got that was supposed to be HOE was a murky orangey-brown rose. Somebody at my yard sale liked it and took it home. I stopped buying bagged roses because I didn't like surprises.

  • 15 years ago

    S&W has Heaven On Earth listed as sold out. Roses Inc of Tulsa has it listed on it's web site but without a price so it may or maynot be available. I'd call them before ordering...If you are close to a local source such as Armstrong I'd try them first...Maryl

    Here is a link that might be useful: Roses Inc of Tulsa

  • 15 years ago

    Their customer service is horrible this year, too :( They were supposed to replace a rose I bought last spring, and I tried bugging them about it since last May, but their final verdict is a $10 credit. Great.

    What are the credit card policies on this sort of thing? If they send dogs, can I just have my cc company cancel the charges, you think? Surely bum product + bankruptcy would work to not have to accept another store credit if it's done quickly enough?

    ***Does anyone have any experience at all with Heavenly Dawn? That's who I'm considering using my credit on if I decide to actually use it.***

    I was going to buy Heaven on Earth there now, too, but any J&P rose available elsewhere at all should be bought elsewhere, imho. (Unless your cc company is usually very great about bum companies, I suppose ;) Mine usually is.)

    Heavenly Dawn isn't some known rose, is it?