Software
Houzz Logo Print
caterwallin

Your observations?

19 years ago

I was just wondering if anyone here has ever witnessed a wasp, fly or anything else getting after a Monarch (or any other) cat? I know that they do, but I didn't know what the chances are of a person actually seeing it happen. I hadn't seen any wasps or flies at the cats when I was outside gathering up the cats to bring inside last summer, but I was too late to save one Monarch cat. There was a Monarch cat (I should say half of one) :( on the underside of a leaf on one of my Swamp Milkweed plants and something on top of it. I got a good look at the culprit and found out later that it was a robber fly. I've seen them around before but never knew what they were until that day when I looked it up. It must have seen me and flew off with its food. I was too late to save that cat, but I like to think of all that ones that lived to be butterflies though because I brought them inside and got them before anything go to them.

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    Cathy, I remember when I worked in the nursery, one fall day, I fertilized the fall cabbaage seedlings with fish emulsion. This was not the norm, but I thought I'd try it rather than the normal miracle grow. It attracted many yellow jackets, probably attracted to the protein in the emulsion. I watched the yellow jackets and actually saw a few on ocassion kill the cabbage worms and fly off with them.

    This delighted me since I was always trying to get rid of those darned things without resorting to pesticides.

    Now, 5 years later, I realize that those "darned" things are butterfly larva!

    And I wonder how many other butterfly cat species the yellow jackets take?

    I suppose that without the predators, we'd be overrun with caterpillars of all types. But I wish they'd leave my BST and Monarchs alone.

  • 19 years ago

    Maryann, Yeah, I can see why you would want the yellow jackets to get the cabbage worms when you weren't even into butterflies at that time. I bet lots of people who garden kill worms not even realizing that they would soon be butterflies. I wish I hadn't killed caterpillars before I got into butterflies, but I know that I did. I remember killing tomato hornworms, and I suppose that I killed some others over the years just not knowing what I know now. I feel bad about it, but I'm trying to make up for it now by helping them out if I can.

    That would be interesting to know how many other butterfly species the yellow jackets take. I've wondered things like that already, how many different types are taken by which wasp and which by yellow jackets and which by robber flies. I wonder if each of those are selective about which types they eat or if they would eat any of them.

    I agree with you, that we would probably be overrun with all types of caterpillars if there wouldn't be certain insects around to keep them in check, but then when I read about the populations of the Monarchs and others being so much less than they used to be, then I wish that their predators would spare them, but I know they have to eat too. It's just that I see far more yellow jackets, wasps, and flies than I do butterflies, so it's just seems unbalanced from my point of view. Maybe since I'm on the side of the butterflies, I don't see things in the proper perspective? I just wish that there were more butterflies around. I know I saw more as a child.

  • 19 years ago

    Uh oh...I am staying out of this one! tee-hee-hee! (Larry Gene, I don't want to be in THAT statistic again!)

  • 19 years ago

    A few years ago I was protecting some monarch cats on milkweed by sleeving the branches - this a. currasavica had grown big! I was changing the sleeves to another spot, like you do after they've eaten most all the leaves within their sleeve, and just as I opened the sleeve to snap off the last leaf with the cat on it, a wasp flew into the sleeve and attacked and killed the poor cat! And right there within about a 1/4" of my hand! I've also witnessed wasps eating sulphur cats on my cassia bicapsularis - I got a picture of one rolling up the body of either a sleepy orange or a cloudless sulphur cat before it carried it away.
    Sherry

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:453244}}

  • 19 years ago

    I've been witness to a wide variety of 'checks and balances' in the garden. I find it fascinating and remarkable. The very best thing we can do, as individuals, to prevent the decline of insects (of all kinds) is to encourage your communities to stop widespread (and nearly useless) mosquito abatement programs and to replant or protect native green areas that have been removed. Educate your neighbors and friends about non-chemical means of gardening and lawn care, and the importance of providing a varied landscape that will invite all kinds of insects.

    Believe me, predator and parasitic wasp populations have been hard hit in the past many years, mostly due to the addiction to chemical pesticides. This has resulted in increased deforestation, agricultural crop attack, etc. Thus.....MORE chemical use. It's not only the butterflies and moths that have been affected.

    My yard is a safe haven for all of the critters. Well, I draw a line in the dirt with some of them, lol. We enjoy a steady population of moths and butterflies much of the year visiting the flowers, but I don't provide a large number of host plants. It only takes one YJ nest or just a few wasps to clear out a large population of caterpillars. I'd rather they stayed busy after the tent caterpillars in the trees! Now, THAT'S a satifying sight to behold! (Yellow jackets after tent caterpillars.)

  • 19 years ago

    But, tent caterpillars are such pretty little moths, Rhizo! LOL!

    I'm with Tdog - not going there with Larry_Gene! However, Maryann qualified her statement by saying that was "before she knew what they were"! Hee Hee.

    Susan

  • 19 years ago

    MissSherry, That must have been one sneaky yellow jacket. Man, would I have been ticked off at that little devil. It sure seems like he was an opportunist for sure, almost like he was sitting there watching for the perfect opportunity.

    rhizo, I sure do agree with you about those points you brought up. I've been wondering for many years if they should be doing the mosquito programs, but I think the people around here insist on it (not me). I saw put up bat houses and let them eat the mosquitoes (they eat LOTS of them), and that is what I'm going to do this year as soon as I can find the lumber that I need. I don't use any kinds of chemicals in our yard at all, but I bet most people do. Yes, now that would be a nice sight to behold, yellow jackets getting after a bunch of tent caterpillars!

    tdogmom & Susan, I guess there's some private joke going on here and I'm left out, but that's okay if it means you won't get in trouble with Larry. :)

  • 19 years ago

    I recall the nature or nurture or squish'em debate from some months ago, and I'm not sure how I fit into this thread, but the choice between yellow jackets and cabbage worms is a tough one.

    A compromise: Control cabbage worms until July 4th, then control yellow jackets. During the holiday season, control chocolate intake.

  • 19 years ago

    Hehehe...

    I like your style Larry Gene...

    ..to every thing it's season.

  • 19 years ago

    That seems like a pretty good compromise, Larry Gene! :) You didn't mention controlling chocolate intake the rest of the year...I could really go for a Hershey Bar right about now. Hehe.

  • 19 years ago

    Control, control?????????? When I think of control, I think of girdles. Sorry, I'm impossibly uncontrollable!

    But, I have learned to appreciate the cabbage whites, due in part to Larry_Gene, and because they're often the only butterflies in my garden early in the season. LOL!

    Susan

  • 19 years ago

    Okay, okay...let me explain the 'Larry_Gene' connection here for those of you who haven't been with us overlong. :)

    Larry_Gene does these remarkable statistical compilations every now and then. When he does them, they are quite entertaining AND informative (sometimes WAY more informative than some of us would like!!!).

    Each year the topic of Wasps appears and depending upon which way the topic goes, it can or cannot get heated. HEATED?! What? Yes, a topic on Wasps can become heated..."to kill or not to kill" and the thread can become a dissertation in itself. There are so many types of Wasps out there that the debate becomes, well, uhh...Just mentioning an opinion might get that thread going so I have found that abstaining is often best. tee-hee-hee

    So, that's my story and I am sticking to it. :)

  • 19 years ago

    Susan, Haha, that's funny! I'm pretty much uncontrollable too. I gotta admit, I had squooshed a cabbage white or two or more over the years, but I wouldn't now. I'll have to remember to notice what butterfly is the earliest in my garden. I know the tigers are here in early May to mid May for sure because they love our lilac bushes, but I'm not sure if any other kind beats them here or not. I know I didn't a whole lot of action here until a little bit later.

  • 19 years ago

    Sherry, Oooh, now I get it! :-O Hee hee, I can see why nobody wanted to get started on that then! :) Yes, I've been on forums where things get heated sometimes, so I know what you mean. Yes, I agree and best to abstain from mentioning any of that. lol

Sponsored
Innovative & Creative Custom Closet Designer Servicing Franklin County