Software
Houzz Logo Print
rjj1_gw

First Attempt at Butterfly ID

19 years ago

Would this be a female Variegated Fritillary? Clickable thumb

{{gwi:455903}}

randy

Comments (18)

  • 19 years ago

    It's not a VF, but definitely one of the crescents, undoubtedly a pearl crescent.
    Beautiful!
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks MissSherry

    Thanks for the id. I would like to learn a little from this post. What are the things that stick out to you that make this id easy?

    Is there a website with photos of live butterflies I can go to for id? Looking at the faded carcasses on the Dallas society page doesn't help me much.

    Should I be counting spots, shape of spots, location of spots, Or just beat my head against the wall and hope a name rolls out:-)?

    After you gave me the name, I googled it for images. To my uneducated eye the antenna was the first thing that stuck out.

    randy

  • 19 years ago

    Randy that's a very beautiful pearl crescent! They are one of the most common butterflies here in CT. Aren't we lucky?

    Late last summer I was surprised to spot several Variegated Fritillaries here too. I think they are occasional late season strays.They were quite a bit larger than the pearl crescents.

    Here's a friendly pair. I found them in early sept and I regret not keeping the female and trying to coax here to lay eggs so I could raise the cats. Since then I've read that it can be done.

    {{gwi:455905}}

  • 19 years ago

    Maryann

    There were probably 20 or more in the yard when I took this photo. Mainly flying around in pairs, one waiting a few inches away on a blade of grass while the other worked the dandelion blooms.

    I see a lot of the Gulf Fritillaries here during the summer. They are much bigger than the Pearl Crescent.

    I just read my last sentence on my second post, "antenna was the first thing that stuck out." I guess they do, don't they? An unintended pun of course:-).

    randy

  • 19 years ago

    Hehehe!!
    The first thing that stuck out to me was the blue coloring on the head of your PC - I've never seen that before and thought it might be another type of crescent.
    The most helpful thing for beginners is a good field guide - my favorite is the one by Brock&Kaufman. Whenever you see a butterfly, take its picture and then either post it on this forum or flip through your field guide until you find it. After a while, you'll notice that there are certain butterflies that you see in your area and others that you don't. Pearl crescents are by far the most common of the crescents in the east and central part of the country - once I see that familiar crescent pattern, I just look in my field guide to be sure it's not one of the other ones, and if it isn't, then it's a PC.
    I ordered and planted some aster carolinianas, a climbing aster, next to my new picket fence, in hopes of getting some PC cats this year. I see the adults frequently, but I've never raised any.
    Here are some clickable thumbnails of some I've photographed -


    {{gwi:455906}}


    {{gwi:446353}}
    I think the top, darker one is a male and the bottom, paler one is a female.
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks MissSherry.

    The sun was hitting him at a great angle in that photo. I saw the color flash much like the throat of the Ruby Throated Hummingbird when he turns and the sun hits it just right. I took 3 or 4 other photos at slightly different angles that don't show that blue or the red/orange below it on the body.

    randy

  • 19 years ago

    Randy, I have trouble too with some, so don't feel bad, you're not the only one.

    Cathy

  • 19 years ago

    Great pic of a Pearl crescent, Randy.

    It's a lil early for the Variegated frits. Wait until you start to get Silvery and Gorgone checkerspots. It still gets kinda confusing for me.

    Try this link for Id:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Randy Anderson's website

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the link Linda. I didn't save that site when you posted it before, but did it this time.

    Just got back from Sectionals, Amber's gymnastic meet that qualifies her for the state meet in 4 weeks. She qualified:-).
    {{gwi:455908}}
    randy

  • 19 years ago

    Woo! Hoo! Randy, that is Awesome!!! I'm sure that she is one happy girl. And you are an extremely proud Dad. Congratulations!

    Pearl Crescents are quite variable. If you can still find the book, "Butterflies of Oklahoma, Kansas, and North Texas" by John M. Dole, Walter Gerard, and John M. Nelson, it is an excellent book of the main butterflies of Okla. It also gives you comparisons between similar species.

    Another excellent book is "Butterflies of North America" by Jim P. Brock and Kenn Kaufman. It gives alot of visual comparisons of similar species, but you have to watch the maps, as they may not be common here in Okla.

    The upperside shows orange and black lines, circles, and crescents. The underside forewing is orange and black, while the hindwing is intricately marked with brown and vaires from light orange (summer) to whitish and brown (spring). The hindwing underside has a white crescent partially or completely surrounded by brown.

    This common to abunadant species overlaps the ranges of all other crescents and checkerspots and must be well studied to separate it from others. Pearl Crescent lacks the pale bands of Phaon and Painted crescents, the heavily marked forewing underside of the Vesta crescent, and the intricate zigzags of the hindwing underside of Gorgone checkerspots, and the white-centered hindwing spots of the Silvery checkerspot.

    Seen April thru November. Host plant: asters.

    Hope that helps.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Butterflies and Moths site

  • 19 years ago

    Congratulations to Amber!
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    Randy,
    Congratulations on your daughter's gymnastic accomplishments! Btw, I also have a daughter Amber but she's 21. I wish your Amber the best of luck in the state meet!
    Cathy

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Ladies.

    I've looked at a few photos of Pearl Crescents. It seems patterns stay consistent, but exact markings on each specimen varies slightly.

    randy

  • 19 years ago

    Wow - pretty Pearl Crescent, Randy. Another good butterfly book is Butterflies through Binoculars (Eastern). I got a used book (still in excellent condition) from Abe Books, for $11.00. Good price. You can probably find the book Linda mentioned at Borders or one of the big bookstores in Norman. Look in the "local interest" section.

    Congratulations to Amber! She's very talented. Is she at Bart and Nadia's gymnastic club?

    Susan

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Susan

    Yes, she goes to BCGA (Bart Conner Gymnastics Academy).

    Bart handed out the medals to the girls. He brought Dillon, their one year old son with him. Dillon had a shirt on a few days ago that said "My Mom's a Perfect 10!"

    randy

  • 19 years ago

    I always thought they were the sweetest couple, and I still fondly recall when Nadia one all of those 10s at the Olympics when she was so young! To me, it's amazing that they came together and now call Norman home. Hope to see Amber on the OU gymnastics team in the future! Is that where she wants to go to school (or has she even thought about it?). I know at one time that OU has a very good gymnastics team, but don't know what their status is now.

    I get very confused on ID'ing the crescents and checkerspots. The Bordered Patch is one that is easily ID'd, but some look so similar that you have to have pictures of them to study before reaching a conclusion.

    Susan

  • 19 years ago

    You mean Nadia Comaneche ?sp. has found a home in Norman? How wonderful! She was such a little doll, swinging around on those bars! Your daughter couldn't have a better teacher, Randy!
    I don't follow gymnastics except to watch it during the Olympics - is Bart Connor a former gymnast?
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    Susan

    Getting a scholarship to college his her second goal. Becoming an elite American gymnast and competing internationally is first. Most elite gymnasts compete internationally and then attend college for a degree to support themselves after their competitive career is over. By college age they are a bit over the hill age wise for international competition. It's rough on an older body. Too many years of long hours of pounding that your body has to endure.

    Amber probably practices and spends more time in the gym each week right now than the NCAA allows their students.

    OU has consistently been a top 10 to 15 team the past few years. Amber talks about attending a PAC 10 school though. We'll see. I personally would like to see her locally, but wouldn't mind if she was good enough to go to Utah. They've won more national championships than anyone over the past 20 years, I think 10.

    Hi MissSherry

    Yes, that Nadia.

    We don't see Nadia much. She's more of an inspiration and visible example for the girls to what hard work can accomplish if you live your dream. She travels quite a bit doing a lot of work with kids and raising money for them internationally. Amber's coaches are younger people with some recent Olympic or collegiate experience.

    Bart is the only male gymnast in American history to win gold at every level of gymnastic competition.
    I think 1984 was the year he helped USA team win gold and he won individual gold on parallel bars.

    randy