Software
Houzz Logo Print
soitgoes_gw

Butterfly larvae or pest?

19 years ago

Hi, I'm a newbie, and I'm wondering if there is a general guideline to distinguish a nice larvae from a pest?

I'll confess butterflies are not my special passion, but I am planting mostly native shrubs and trees and perennials on our new construction lot to make my yard critter-friendly.

I was checking up on my two brand-new serviceberries and noticed someone has been eating the leaves. I found a small (half-inch, maybe) caterpillar-looking thing that had folded a leaf around itself. It seemed to hold the leaf closed in a sticky secretion. Without thinking first, I am embarrassed to say I plucked him off. I am not sure if it was this little guy or the tent caterpillars (or more likely both) chewing on my serviceberry. My fear was that a young plant, just stressed from transplanting, could not handle too much leaf damage.

So is there some basic guideline to follow to tell good guy from nuisance? Or will I need to spend hours looking at images of creepy-crawlies whenever I find someone living in my bushes?

Thanks!

Comments (2)

  • 19 years ago

    There are several good books you could get to help you ID the caterpillars you find. One is Caterpillars in the Field and Garden which is a field guide to the butterfly caterpillars of North America by Allen, Brock and Glassberg. Once you learn what your local butterfly caterpillars look like, then at least you'll know not to squish them. If you're in the east, another good book is Caterpillars of Eastern North America by David Wagner - this is mostly moth caterpillars. I'm sure you'd want to save any big silk moth and most sphinx moth cats. Then everything that's left is probably a pest, especially if it's tent caterpillars. I'm glad that yellow-billed cuckoos show up here every year just when the outbreak of tent cats is beginning! Another helpful book is Garden Insects of North America by Cranshaw - this book IDs a lot of butterfly and moth caterpillars, plue other larvae like sawflies that eat leaves.
    Another way is to take a picture of the offending leaf eater and post it on this forum - we may (or may not) know what it is.
    I don't blame you for wanting to protect your serviceberry. I've got a young amelanchier arborea that I just love - so far, no cats have found it. I figure the only ones I'd be likely to find on it would be either red-spotted purple cats or tiger swallotail cats, and I wouldn't mind having them - these two butterflies lay their eggs far apart, so no plant gets really ravaged by either of them.
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you. I will have to check out those books. I'm in PA, by the way.

    There were two types of holes in the leaves: bigger ones that looked like tent caterpillar damage (and I did pull one tent cat off my other serviceberry. I didn't have the heart to kill it, but I did put it over near the bird feeder. BTW, the tents are pretty bad around here this year). Then there was a smaller set of holes that was probably from this little guy. No leaves were eaten enough to actually kill them, but it's early yet. Luckily the little trees/shrubs are broad for their height and have a fair amount of foliage, so hopefully they'll be ok.

    Since we're planting a fair number of natives, I'll definitely have to study up on cats. I don't want to kill the good ones. And I'll have the digital camera on stand-by, just in case. :-)

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting