Software
Houzz Logo Print
bearstate

A lesson learned from Cactus Seed (Pic)

19 years ago

The first time I tried to grow Puya Alpestris and Puya Berteroniana from seed, I met with total and complete failure. I planted the seed in egg cartons since they were tiny and I figured the egg cartons would do best.

However I quickly learned that direct sunlight kills seedlings and with Puya, a single raindrop can uproot them and wash them away.

I did an experiment with Cactus Seed, quite by accident really. The instructions said specifically, to plant the cactus indoors until sprouted. Ok, so I did. They sprouted and I moved some of them outdoors and in just 4 hours, the ones I put outdoors were bleached white. They died.

So I analyzed and agonized. It seems that Cactus seed sprout in clouded over Winter and put on their first growth in shady conditions until when Summer finally rolls round, they have toughened up and are tolerant of the Sun. I soon recognized that this goes for many types of seeds, but in different ways. For example, it can be rationalized that many tropicals seed and sprout under the shade and protection of forest canopy, destined in many cases to die for lack of sun after maturing, but alternatively, if blessed by a tree-fall, given the opportunity to thrive in the sun that reaches down through the slash created in the forest canopy. Eventually, they may grow up and fill the slash.

I begin therefore, to understand why the forest service had problems raising baby conifers unless they were raised within a stand or existing growth. The SUN kills the seedlings if not grown in the protection of a stand or existing growth and then too ... wind may blow a lone tree down.

So, being a new gardener, one learns a few things and finds that Puya and Aloe as seen in the photo below, are best started indoors and harbored in safe confines from sunlight and other travails.

{{gwi:489448}}

The photo shows one Aloe Kedogensis and two Puya, one Berteroniana and one Sp. ( Emerald Puya ). They have been carefully sewn in peat pellets and watered with a spray bottle to avoid having them washed away. Even in a peat pellet, a single good sized drop can uproot a puya seedling and traumatize it - to death.

This time, my seeds won't be wasted! I have tripped over my own two big feet and learned.

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    Almost all small seed have to be protected from down pouring waterings, direct sun, and wind

  • 19 years ago

    You'll have to forgive my naivete' as I have only sewn my first seeds back in October of 2006. I'm still on the learning curve as likely are many members to GardenWeb.

    Gett'n old and can't fly airplanes anymore because my eye sight is failing. So gardening is a new and interesting hobby for me and I'm go'n all out to create a jungle in my life.

    The smallest seeds I've worked with are Rhododendron, Senecio, Puya and some of those Cactus. The rock bottom smallest are the spores for Dickonsonia Antarctica, the Tasmanian Tree Fern. Most other seeds have been at at least as big as a chili pepper seed. So yep, I was taken agast at first how easy a single drop of water could vanish my seed investments. And what's worse about Puya is that the seedling seems to cling to life as a tiny little leaflet with barely any root at all for some time, makeing it easy to be washed away, even after germination. And I thought that birds were my worst concern.

    The largest seeds I've worked with so far are Cycas Revoluta, the King Sago. The jury is still out on the germination of ten of these guys and I'm waiting for them to come up.

    Hopefully other naive beginners lurking here will read of my botched experiences and save themselves the time and trouble.

    The amusing thing is that some of my neighbors have become aware of my gardening attempts and we seem to be starting a small club. Don't be surprised if they start turning up here posting their adventures too.

    Thanks for your insights.

    Air Bear aka BearState aka Bear

    ;)

  • 19 years ago

    Your cycad seeds can take up to a year to sprout. Kepp them evenly moist and in deep shade until you see fronds emerge...I have been raising cycads 20 years...When I take pups from the parent plants..I have seen them in shock for 18 months and poof .. out pops three fronds
    You will be good at gardening ..you have patience to raise from seed :)

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the tip.

    Why deep shade? Won't partial shade as provided by a shade cloth do?

  • 19 years ago

    I put them on the ground with 90% shade cloth. They seem to like the temp ..shade cloth is 10-11 ft above the seeds

  • 19 years ago

    Hi BearState, so do I, I found growing brom from seed is challenging,
    but once you knew the trick, it will be a piece of cake (^_Here is my method of raising xeric broms - mostly Dyckia, Hechtia - from seed.

    I use transparent plastic food box as sowing container,
    holed for drainage at the bottom.

    {{gwi:489449}}

    {{gwi:489450}}

    {{gwi:489451}}

    {{gwi:489452}}

  • 19 years ago

    Stephania, are you planning to give Nong Nooch TBG competition? You must have a HUGE place to grow all those plants! That is a lot of beautiful, healthy seedlings!! Japie

  • 19 years ago

    Stephania, I am wondering the same thing as Japie......Happy growing.DO remember me if you have extras...:-))

  • 19 years ago

    Stephania, what is the red plant at the top right of your last pic?

  • 19 years ago

    LOL... I know that must be a lot of works and times, but I have to because
    I don't know how look of new hybrid from those tiny green seedlings will turn up.

    If you mean those beside Aechmea 'Bert' on the same bench of seed boxes,
    they are young plants from pup of Orthophytum 'Starlights'

  • 19 years ago

    Stephania,

    Thanks for the photos! They are very definitely encouraging and the food container idea is somewhat stunning to contemplate as it is so hot here that if I were to put broms outside in that way, they'd boil inside one of those. But indoors, that should work fine. Looks like keeping them moist and dew dropped is a good idea.

  • 19 years ago

    Well, I'm still nowhere near to doing Broms like Stephania does, but I thought I'd like to post an update to show off my success at getting a few more Puyas going by growing them indoors in seeled containers like Stephania's plastic food containers.

    Here ya go ...

    {{gwi:489453}}

    The Puya sp. "Neon Green" seems to produce much hardier and more robust seedlings than the wispy Puya berteroniana which is on the right side of this photo.

  • 19 years ago

    I should probably let Stephania answer this, but I am certain that those seedling containers of his are also being grown under protection of shade clothe overhead, and are not actually getting direct sun. If you think the sun can bake things in Bakersfield, it is even more intense in the tropic latitudes of Bangkok, and they also have a fairly long dry season.

  • 19 years ago

    The topic of this thread "A Lesson Learned from Cactus Seed" alludes to the fact that direct Sunlight is harmful to new seedlings, particularly the succulants and bromeliads. The lids on Stephania's food containers obviously cut back on the sunlight, but I think there is also a reliance on shade there. The pictures of Stephania's nursery above suggest a kind of shady alcove, but some direct sunlight is evident.

    My success with Puya Seedlings seems to have increased due to three factors, (1) indoor temperature control, (2) reduced sunlight due to the indoor environment and (3) increased humidity due to a sealed container.

    Now that I've had a bit of success with a few seeds under these controlled conditions, I feel more confident to plant the remainder of the seeds I have been holding in reserve and perhaps to try some other broms besides Puyas.

    :)

Sponsored
Landscape Management Group
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars33 Reviews
High Quality Landscaping Services in Columbus