Software
Houzz Logo Print
caterwallin

Some flowers a disappointment

19 years ago

Last year I had Joe Pyeweed blooming this year for the first time and I didn't even see one butterfly on it; the same thing is happening this year. I've read on here that it's such a great nectar plant, but so far it's been a flop here. I planted tithonia this year for the first time and I've seen only a couple on it in the past several weeks that it's been blooming. I can almost always count on going outside and seeing no butterflies on it. Another one that I was really looking forward to seeing butterflies on it is the Anise hyssop. That's a bomb here too except for the Cabbage Whites, but it's not like I'm trying to attract them...I already had plenty of those. The bumble bees love it though. I thought that it kept me busy enough picking all of the Japanese beetles off of my zinnias, but I find just as many if not more hanging on the A. hyssop. I have to be careful picking them off of those because there are always bumblee bees buzzing around them.

I deadhead most of my flowers to encourage more bloom, but I don't think I'm looking forward to doing that to the hyssop. Does anyone here have that plant and how do you deadhead the flowers? There are so many on the plant that I can picture myself taking a few hours just to deadhead mine. It's easy to deadhead something like zinnias, but when you have a lot of blooms on one plant like the hyssop, it's going to be hard to deadhead them all separately. Do you just down all of the foliage too, i.e. using a big shears to chop off, say, a foot of the plant to include all or at least most of the spent blooms?

Side note: As of August 14, I've successfully released 25 male Monarchs and 15 females. My count should double or triple by the end of the week with all of the ones that I have in the butterfly cage.

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    Oh am I with you there! I bought a couple of things this year that I read were big butterfly nectar plants and nada-nothing!
    Let's see it was Sneezeweed, beautiful flower but not one butterfly. The other was blanketflower, nothing.

    In fact the only plant that I have that gets any butterfly action is the butterfly bush. I even have Pentas and I have not seen one butterfly on them.

    I'm going over lists and lists of PA flowers that attract butterflies for next year because this year I planted alot of wrong things or it's like the other person said, there is a lack of butterflies here this year.

    I was watching the Hyssop and that is all I saw on it was bees so I didn't get it. I got the Joe Pye Weed and carried a butterfly around with me while I carried it, it was a Painted Lady.
    I've been making a list like I said for next year. I want to get Spicebush and Willow, I'm just not sure what type of Willow yet for host plants. Also I printed out a paper from Penn State about butterflies in PA-they suggest alot of different plants, I'll included the link for you so you can print it out. It's really interesting and it's for our state.
    Hopefully we'll have better luck next year, you live and you learn is what I always say.

    Aggie

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gardening for Butterflies

  • 19 years ago

    SO true!

    I have mentioned this as well. For example, I have NEVER had a butterfly ever land on Lantana. Nope. Never. They just don't care for it. So, I dug up the several I had and took them to school and planted them there. The bees seem to like it (as do the cut- and armyworms). Interestingly enough, I didn't have any takers on the Brazilian verbena and I know others swear by the stuff, so out that went.

    We have loads and loads of Hibiscus in our yard. Everything states that Hairstreaks use this as a host. This year I haven't seen any around although in years past, I have. I have never seen any actually using it as a host plant, though. The only one who really LOVES to eat the plant is my dog Chelsea. ;P She likes the flowers. The Monarchs and Hummingbirds love the blossoms, too.

    Are you ready for a weird one (or two)? Gardenias and Plumeria! Monarchs love Gardenias (at least in my garden). This year, the Gulf Frits are trying to nectar on the Plumeria (the smaller blossoms), which I've found most interesting. The Monarchs have always liked the Plumies.

    Go figure...

  • 19 years ago

    I haven't noticed any butterflies on my Joe Pye Weed either. I found my first plant locally last month; I had such high hopes. And it's surrounded by coneflowers, which get lots of activity (duh; obviously!). I also purchased a chocolate one, but it's not doing much (not blooming). But I love my hyssop, regardless of little butterfly activity. It's always swarming with bumblebees & carpenter bees, as well as other bees & wasps. The goldfinches go crazy for it too. I don't deadhead them at all, just because of the goldfinches.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm quite new to this forum, so I'm no where close to an expert. However, it seems to me that I've heard that butterflies' tastes vary from year to year and from location to location for reasons that are not clear. It may be that you just have other stuff in your garden that they are in the mood for. Or maybe someone elses garden has the stuff they want right now. Or maybe there are predators around that the butterflies are avoiding or they're being eaten. I think the best thing to do is to provide the greatest variety we can, avoid chemicals, and let the butterflies do what comes naturally.

    Martha

  • 19 years ago

    I think you're right, Martha!
    Welcome to this forum!!
    MissSherry

  • 19 years ago

    Another thought on the JPW and Hyssop: I don't usually see the big activity on either of these plants until in the fall. When the Monarchs start their southern migration, my JPW will be covered. I may not even see a BF on it until then. Ditto for the Tithonia.

    The hyssop is visited by the Tigers in my yard in the fall. And of course, the little Goldfinches love the seeds.

    So don't give up just yet, wait a little while longer, and you may see activity before the year is over.

    OKSandy

  • 19 years ago

    Year to year favorites never seem to remain the same in my garden, that's for sure. The lantana always attracts a ton of skippers; the zinnias always attract the swallowtails and Monarchs. The Lavendar never fails to attract butterflies every year, as well as the Monarda. And, the tropical milkweed has proven successful for the 2 years in a row that I've planted it. Those are staples for me.

    Others that seem to be "off and on" are pentas (this year the PVS love them), Cleome, Joe Pye Weed, Cosmos, Veronica, and Salvias.

    The fall bloomers like asters and coniclinum (Gregg's mistflower), always attract lots of butterflies.

    Some butterflies are attracted to colors, too. The Monarchs seem to favor pink and red. The swallowtails love both as well. The Sulphurs love red. The Orange Sulphurs love the pink & white salvia.

    If I had to note two most popular I'd say the Lavendar and the Tropical Milkweed based on the past 2-4 years. The good thing about Lavendar is that it blooms from spring to frost, with no break in blooms.

    I am anxious to see how the Solidago and the Verbesina encelioides do this year, too.

    So far, I haven't noticed a lot of activity on the Mexican Flame Vine.

    Susan

  • 19 years ago

    The swallowtails & monarchs can't get enough of my white buddleia and the "Pink Delight". I haven't seen so much activity in years, at least at the same time. Over the weekend, there were 3 yellow swallowtails, 1 black, & 3 monarchs duking it out for nectaring rights. I'm seriously considering removing one of my low activity buddleias and replacing it with another "Pink Delight" Throw in some Verbena bonariensis and they're in heaven ;)

  • 19 years ago

    V. bonariensis is a highly sought-after nectar plant, isn't it, Tracy? Even the hummers vie for nectaring rights on it. They and the GFs and PVS's fight all day long for a place on a Verbena Ice Cream Stick! LOL!

    I'm going to have to check into the Red Porterweed. Is it easily grown from seed, or best to purchase a plant?

    Susan

  • 19 years ago

    Here in cen. Tx, I would have to say that my duds for attracting butterflies are verbena, a dark purple red color, I'm not sure of the variety, and pentas. I've never seen any BF on either. The top three attractors in my garden is lantana, buddleia black knight, and butterfly weed, curassavica, and tuberosa. I'm sure that may change as fall comes on.

  • 19 years ago

    hello
    my verbena gets a lot of attention, but one thing I was told butterflys loved was coriopsis, to my experience only the bees like it.
    my honeyvine seems to be a universal attracter, I have seen tigers, monarchs(host and nector),buckeyes, frits, and well almost everyone nectering from it. it is not a flashy plant with unimpressive clusters of tiny white flowers, but they all find.

    I have also had good luck with lantana, and my cosmos and zinnias are always popular.

    michelle

  • 19 years ago

    You guys won't believe this but the butterflies in my garden are liking the Impatiens...Yes I said imapatiens. But not all colors...only the raspberry purple ones. Yesterday I saw a yellow tiger swallowtail nectaring on them. She only went to that particular color, skipping over the pinks, reds, and whites.

    The buddleias are my top draw right now. But my anise hyssop is atracting the CWs and many monarchs.

    Maryann in CT


  • 19 years ago

    Buddleia, buddleia, buddleia! It seems like everyone loves the Buddleia. I have a number of different ones...

  • 19 years ago

    For me the duds are pentas and lantana. The favs are Tithonia (BFs and bees love this), passion flower vines, fennel, dill, parsley and my dwarf poinciana tree. I'm planting more Tithonia because the neon orange color just pops in the yard, easy to grow and it seems that all BFs like it.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert