Software
Houzz Logo Print
wolfen_gw

Confused ,,,rooted cutting,,, or not ???

18 years ago

I bid on, and won, 3 rooted cuttings, from a seller- ljenkins022, of frosty pink.. What I recieved today was 3 fresh cuttings, wrapped in dry paper towel,( it may have been wet ) surrounded by wadded up plastic bags.

I e-mailed her, and asked why they were no roots, and this was her reply: "Do you see the small white bumps on stem? That would be the roots, if you leave the brugs in water to long they will rot. Once the little bumps appear on stem, they can be planted in a good quality potting mix. It only takes about three days in water for the root nodes to appear. If you have any other question feel free to ask."

Well, I'm not taking this any farther with her, not even leaving feedback untill I get over feeling "taken", if I do get over it... GGRRRRR.... But I don't want anyone else to be disapointed buying from her,, She has an auction for the same going on now, same advertisement for ROOTED CUTTINGS on her auction page!!

Will anyone/someone tell me if just "nubbies" are considered as a rooted cutting ?? If there are nubbies on these cuttings, they must have disappeared during shipment....

I have only succeded in only a very few rooted cuttings, and I kept them in water untill roots appeared, and then planted them in soil. Any suggestions / opinions ??

Sandra

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    NO!!! I would not consider that a rooted cutting!

    Can you post the link to the auction...I'd like to see it..
    Kylie

  • 18 years ago

    Sandra, I think I just found the auction you bid on. $3.99 + $6 shipping is that right? No, rooted cuttings would actually have roots! But, have you e-mailed her back to tell her that's not acceptable? I think sometimes it's best to try and work problems out with sellers before posting their ID's here... Of course I understand your frustration and I know nothing about this person and am not defending her, but she may have screwed up her listing in the beginning and not realized it and might very well make things right if you contact her back.

  • 18 years ago

    No, rooted cuttings have ROOTS. Plain cuttings have no roots. Those little nubbies (lenticels) are pre-roots but they're still not roots. & 3 days huh? I have had some sit in water for weeks & even more than a month before they root & some that stay in water all winter because I don't have anywhere to put them. Your item was not as described.

    Linda

  • 18 years ago

    Wildflower, yes, that was the auction. Please believe me that I am not trying to cause a riff. And I didn't realize that posting her identity would not be right when I was posting here. I do not want to cause her any trouble. I will write her back, and suggest that she may not want to advertise rooted cuttings, but maybe that the cutings are begining to have the "nubbies..Only suggest. Not insist. If I was interested in just cuttings, I may have bought them. But , I realy expected to get cuttings with roots.
    I consider myself rightfully chastised for revealing someones identity like that. I do beg everyones forgiveness, There will not be a next time..
    Sandra

  • 18 years ago

    That's definitely NOT a rooted cutting. Yes they will probably do just fine once planted but that doesn't excuse her misrepresentation of the auction. It's BS that the cutting will rot in water once the nubbies show. The nubbies aren't even always the area where the roots emerge from. I think it might have been Barry that pointed that out some time ago. I don't see a problem with revealing the auction. It's not like it's a gray area. It's not rooted, period!
    Karyn

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, Karyn is right. There is no "gray area" in that listing. Why don't we start a list now of every seller that's ever screwed up? Who cares about communicating with them to see if they'll make things right. They screwed up so we should nail all of them.

    I think I'll take a break from these forums for a while until I get my BP meds re-filled.

  • 18 years ago

    If its any consolation Frosty pink has been one of the easiest to root for me and I think every cutting lived. Good luck with your plants. I agree to contact the seller and let her know that you don't agree with her about the nubbies being roots and work it out between yourselves. Hopefully she will replace them if they fail to root. She may have honestly been under the impression that the nubbies were roots if she didn't know any better.

  • 18 years ago

    Those don't sound rooted to me but I agree it is an easy one to root. Just put them in a few inches of water and change it daily. Holler if you need some help.

  • 18 years ago

    I am not intending to keep this thread going, just want to say that I did e-mail the seller and said I was not happy with what I recieved, and said it may be to her benefit that on any other auctions, that she not advertise rooted cuttings, which is misleading, unless there are true visible roots. I didn't ask for a refund, or replacement as maybe she really thinks the nubbies are roots. I did leave positive feedback, saying "nice cuttings".
    I do want to apologize again for starting any hard feelings, it was not intended that way, but after re reading my previous post, I see that I really sounded nasty. Thanks for all your advice,
    Sandra

  • 18 years ago

    I kind of don't think you should've let her get away with it. somewhere down the line she's going to take advantage of some newbie who will believe her slimy claims of "LOL THOSE R ROOTZ" and won't know any better. you know what to do to make them thrive, but that poor newbie won't.

    I personally would have caused at least a modest stir. maybe I'm just an unforgiving, bad person, though.

    Ria

  • 18 years ago

    I would be really ticked, Def not "rooted"!
    And I don't think there is anything wrong with letting us know who it was, so we don't get rooked too! Thank you for letting us know!
    Glad to hear you left her feedback saying they were cuttings, but I think it should have been a nuetral fdbk, if she didn't know the dif..
    I'd be ticked. I AM ticked! She's not an honest seller IMO. Even if she didn't know the dif between nubbies and roots..she should have found out before stating that they were indeed rooted. If she's not sure, and claiming they are rooted, then she IS lying. She could have very easily said that they were cuttings with nubbies.
    Really though, come on..if she doesn't know what she is talking about, she shouldn't be selling them.
    Sandra, again thank you for letting us know..and I am sorry you got ripped off. Doesn't matter how easy FP roots, they could just as easily NOT root for you.
    OK I'm shutting up now..I just hate dishonest sellers.