Software
Houzz Logo Print
butterflymomok

Editorial comment

18 years ago

I'd like to address the idea that raising cats in a paper bag is cruel. This summer I have raised and released 79 Monarch BFs to date. I currently have over 100 chrysalides awaiting eclosure. I have raised Monarchs for 25 years.

When my BF friend first approached me with the idea of raising caterpillars in paper bags, I was very skeptical. I decided to do an experiment (as documented on this forum) to check out the process. The idea came from a book and my friend copied the article for me as he knew I raised and released large quantities of BFs (276 so far this summer). I found it to be a very effective way to raise healthy butterflies which has always been my goal.

Some people would consider raising any type of caterpillar in a container as cruel as it is against nature and confines the larvae. As we all know on the BF forum, leaving caterpillars out to fend for themselves results in very few making it to maturity. Some might argue that we are affecting the food chain by removing these caterpillars and thus depriving birds, frogs, and other insects from their meals.

The benefits of raising cats in bags are:

A dry environment. Moisture does not build up in the paper bags.

Easy to clean. Frass can be removed easily either through cutting off the corner of the bottom of the bag, or shaking it out the top.

A good place for a chrysalid. The surface of the bag provides an excellent surface for the chrysalid to adhere to. I have not had the problem of chrysalides falling off.

Easy to move to an eclosing container. The bags can be cut apart and the chrysalides on the paper taped into a mesh eclosing cage.

Eclosing is facilitated. The paper bags provide a good surface for the eclosing BFs and they can easily move to the mesh surface of the hamper.

Cleaning containers is not necessary. Paper bags are disposable so there is no contamination of a new brood of cats. And lunch sized paper bags are relatively cheap.

I do, however, start my cats in containers until they are eating well and can go through the leaves I provide them in several hours. This assures that the food stays fresh in the bags.

One observation that I have made is that my chrysalides that come from my PB raised cats are on the whole, larger than my container raised cats.

Light penetrates the PBs when the bags are set on a window sill. I can actually see the outline of the cats and tell where they are in the bags.

I was the biggest skeptic of all when I did the experiment. However, I have seen the results and I can't dispute that this is a good method. I don't feel like everyone in the world needs to do it this way. But, as a person that raises quite a few caterpillars, I will resort to this method. It allows me to limit the number of cats in each bag. It simplifies cleaning. And it produces healthy livestock.

Sandy

Comments (2)

  • 18 years ago

    Questions and a comment:

    (Q1) So the process is, hatch in a container; transfer to paper bag at suitable maturity (2nd or 3rd instar?); cut out paper with chrysalis and tape to cage?

    (Q2) Are the paper bags *in* the cage?

    (Q3) How much maintenance is required per cat -- are you changing out leaves every other day or so?

    (Q4) You clearly have been optimizing for high volume (1000 or so butterflies this season, IIRC). How much space do your paper bags take up?

    (C) This would make an excellent FAQ article.

    Jeff

  • 18 years ago

    Jeff,

    Here are answers to your questions:

    Q1 yes.

    Q2 paper bags sit in my window sills, actually in my breakfast room and living room. They are only there for several days--about 4-5 at the most. These windows are on the east side of my house.

    Q3 I keep leaves that I have collected in my fridge. I replenish leaves as needed which could be up to 4-5 times daily right before pupation. The only waste is frass, which is very dry and easy to remove from bags, either from the top, or a small hole cut in one of the corners of the bag.

    Q4 As I put 6 cats of all the same size and instar in each bag, I had 10 lunch bags on my window sill in my LR for 60 cats. I very carefully matched the cats by size so that pupation in each bag would occur at approximately the same time. I began by putting less in each bag, but found that 6 cats can do well in one lunch bag. These were kept closed by folding once over in one direction and then in the opposite direction and secured with a clothes pin.

    My season total will probably be around 500 BFs released, including other species entirely container raised. Using PBs for Monarchs allows me to use the containers for the Pipevines(92), Variegated Frits(37), Black Swallowtails(42), Cloudless Sulfurs(13), and 6 other species that I also raised/or am currently raising . Numbers in parentheses are the numbers of each species I have released so far this season. The person who shared this with me also raises Pipevines and BSTs in PBs by putting food in pics or water dishes with lids. He uses large grocery sacks, but I don't have a supplier for these.

    As a control group, I concurrently raised 40 caterpillars in 3 large plastic storage containers with sheer fabric covering. I used water bowls and wet foam in saucers to keep the food fresh. My size comparisions were made with this group.

    Sandy