Software
Houzz Logo Print
necro1234

Sphagnum alternatives?

21 years ago

Hi everyone

Ive been looking around for any Sphagnum alternatives.

So far I've only seen a few articles about this, of these Ive come across 2 products:

Cocopeat: this is a peat mix made from coconut husks

Moorland Gold: water filtering through large peat bogs carries peat particles downstream where it gathers in a dam and is collected.

Im curious if anyone has tried any such alternative or knows of any other good ones?

Thanx

Sheldon

Comments (21)

  • 21 years ago

    I've also wondered if you could use peat moss?

  • 21 years ago

    in select places in britain they use eco-harvesting of live sphag, which is to slice strips off, in a large line, leaving behind somewhat of a sewer-grate design. then they move on, leaving the previous seasons' sphag to heal back, and eventually 5 years later when they return to the first bog, its entirely healed. they've been doing this in parts of england for centuries now, since they've discovered, well, it makes a wonderful fire. of course, maybe if someone explained to them they wouldn't have needed to burn sphagnum if they hadn't cut down all their trees, we wouldn't be having to go to such extremes in the first place. not to say i wouldn't conserve this precious resource anyhow.

    it'l only be once the last tree on earth is struck down, and all the lakes are dry, humans will discover they can't eat money.

  • 21 years ago

    Hi xpochian
    Ye I read about this been done in Britian and some places in Europe, unfortunetly the main moans of nature conservation seems to have its eyes on certain companies within the USA.
    Sphagnum is awesome stuff, just wondering what else could be used.

    Ye I completly agree with you, all of these massive comapies act asif they have the right to do as they choose, oil compaies are a prime evil.
    If humanity really wanted to be eco friendly and without loosing what it has, we very well could.
    Hydrogen engines would pretty much release oxygen, no harmful byproducts and would out preforum petrolium as well.
    Hell a 500Hp motor running on hydrogen would be insane, the tech is out there, but large corporations would literally kill to keep their product selling.
    The middle east thrives on oil, imagine if it was no longer needed?
    Then again its a worry since the Bush family are oil barrons as is.

    Well it has to change some time, just depends on when the change happens if there is anything left to save I suppose.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    agreed. i don't know if you're still there or not, but if you could get around to reading my 'seed emergency' post, i'd be highly greatful.

  • 21 years ago

    I had read and heard that New Zealand is the only country harvesting it's sphag. in a sustainable way for the gardening industry, so I only buy NZ sphag. It's quite high quality moss, too. Coir can be good, but it breaks down a lot faster than sphag. I know that Canadian peat is supposed to be the best, but I have no idea how it's being harvested. I suspect they are draining natural bogs.

  • 21 years ago

    What the fella above me said is what you want to look for. Look for new zealand moss, also called Golden Sphagnum moss, or Angel Moss. IMO I think it is nicer to have, it looks better than normal sphagnum and doesn't have that decaying stench.

  • 21 years ago

    Nice

    Funnily enough the large bag of Sphagnum peat I got from the Wasache Shadows nursery here was marked as "New Zealand Sphagnum Peat Moss" so guess it was a lucky find.

    Thanx for the heads up.
    Ive read a few things online which say that Canada infact is mining their sphagnum in a way that will not damage the spag fields, but cannot be sure if this is true ofcause.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    hi!
    and where can i buy this NZ moss???

  • 21 years ago

    Just as an aside... because it pops up a lot.... the main way that hydrogen is produced is by using fossil fuels. So as far as output and per input... gasoline is still the way to go.... though hybrids have helped reclaim some of the excess energy. The end. Back to spagnum. :)

  • 21 years ago

    I find NZ sphag. at my local garden centres. Not places like HD, but actual garden centres that don't sell anything except for plants and items related to their care. It always says specifically on the package, which is a square bale wrapped in plastic: New Zealand Sphagnum Moss. It might also have the words 'long-fibred' in there. If you live in a small town and can't find a local store, you can order it online through most orchid vendors.

  • 21 years ago

    A little education is a dangerous thing, Necro.......

    How do you live,... if you practice what you preach?

  • 21 years ago

    Lance how so?
    I said Im looking for alternatives to sphagnum, how does that stop me from living?
    I said that companies are pretty much not interested in conserving anything other than their cash flow.
    I said that humanity as a whole is greedy and destructive, so what must I practise?

    Cheers

    Sheldon

    PS I dont think anyone needs much education to know humanity is the most destructive thing in the cosmos.

  • 21 years ago

    Well Necro, I see you trashing Humanity....Businesses...Oil companies......Sphagnum harvesters....etc.

    If you are so opposed to those 'terrible' things, I would certainly expect that you would honor your beliefs by not supporting them. That's why I asked if you practice what you preach.

    You seem to have some intelligence, and you seem passionate about your beliefs. You're just ignorant as hell and I would encourage you to get educated about the things you trash.

    Stop drinking the Kool-aid and use your own brain. Instead of repeating what others tell you to think and to say, gain your own knowledge. You'll be a better person.

    Incidentally, there is no substitute for the good things that mosses can do...not even coconut fibers. Canadian moss harvesters are VERY 'Earth-friendly'.

    And by the way, even YOU could go out and purchase one of those oil leases, or sphagnum moss leases, and then go about running your own business the way you wanted it to be. (Don't complain about not having the money...what do other companies do?)

    One other thing...the greatest mass extinction on earth occured eons ago. It wasn't done by humans....it was when oxygen producing microbes 'poisoned' the atmosphere and killed all living things, (other than themselves).

    If you intend to reply to this, please do us a favor and check your spelling and use proper punctuation.....(it gives others a good impression of you).

  • 21 years ago

    simmer simmer

  • 21 years ago

    Oh dear

    Well look who has a degree in hostility from Harvard itself now.
    Firstly when did I say that Canadian sphagnum is not harvested in a manner, which does not destroy it?
    If you bothered to read my post, it says that I have read many articles that say Canada in fact does harvest it correctly so that the fields are not destroyed, I also stated that of cause I cannot be sure of this either now didnÂt I?
    Next, did I say that coconut fiber could be better than sphagnum?, no I did not.
    I ASKED, what alternatives there are, because I was curious if there are any out there that I in fact donÂt know about and that people have used.
    Next up, as far as crude oil is concerned of cause it is a large pollutant, I think thatÂs kind of obvious, and of cause with the technology progressing as it is, there are now ways to still have the same luxuries, just running cleaner sources such as hydrogen.
    Next I donÂt repeat what others tell me to think, if I did why on earth was I the one that went off about this nonsense of high humidity and CP's?
    Huh, the large majority of people here and on other forums believed this story, now a large amount of them risked what I said and are growing their plants out of the enclosure.
    Next up, my major moans as you could see if you would bother reading the post is that many large companies are more than happy to cause damage for cash, lets be realistic about that one now.

    I still donÂt see what things I am preaching that I need to live by?

    Oh and by the way Lance, since you are so high up on the evolution process, why donÂt you rather try to answer questions here and assist instead of trying to make yourself superior.
    Oh and when you do try and be all superior here, maybe you should try reading the posts so that you can actually respond to things people have said.

    Lastly to wrap this up, I do not need spelling or an ego to give people a "good impression" of me, it kinda looks like the person that gets bad impressions would be you, now does'nt it?

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Hi all

    I'm still trying to figure out who or what I've so badly insulted here, so let me state in clear words what my post was.
    I meantion no names of people nor companies, I asked what alternatives there are.
    I stated that I SEE humanity as being a destructive force, face it, we are.
    I said that I believe canada mines their sphagnum in a good manner but cannot be sure of this.
    I said that I have READ reports that there are moans about CERTAIN companys with in the USA that have abused the sphagnum fields.
    My talking on Hydrogen power was based on fairly old tech which takes water which is 2 hydrogen and 1 oxygen atom, removes the hydrogen from the water leaving oxygen behind and then of course uses this collected hydrogen to burn in the combustion chamber as per a normal motor.
    I never preached that people should not drive cars nor that people should not use sphagnum or anything else.
    I never said ONE THING against companys that harvest sphagnum, I said that SOME do abuse it, this of course is fact.
    Yes I make spelling and grammar mistakes, we all do, I type quickly and normally do so in the early hours of the morning when I am tired.
    My reason for being on the forum was to ask questions, gain knowledge and then to give back any knowledge that I gain, not to try and belittle or flame anyone.
    I dont feel that gets us anywhere.
    I have not insulted any company, any person or any technology.
    I stated my opinion on things and asked questions to things I was not sure of.
    I have no need to insult humanity, history states all the good and all the bad we have done and are capable of.

    Hopefully this explains my posts more clearly.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

    PS: I would ask that if Lance has the intelligence that Im lacking, then he could rather inform me, and the rest of us to the answers or corrections to our "misinformation" as opposed to simply saying that a person does not know what s/he is talking about without even correcting them.
    If a person is lacking knowledge or is mistaken, why sit back calling them an idiot rather than giving them the chance to learn the correct answer that you supposidly have?
    Next if grammer was such a critical thing here, Im sure it would be changed from the "CARNIVOROUS PLANT" forums to the "GRAMMAR" forums.

    Thank you for reading

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Hello Necro,

    As I stated, I thought you were intelligent. I did not say you were stupid or an idiot, I said you were ignorant as hell....which you are. ('Ignorant' means, "lacking information".) If you were to become more informed, I am certain that your views of the world would change in a dramatic way....which was my whole point in my response to you.

    What you refer to as my "intelligence" is my knowledge about things. I'm an old fart who's been around a lot longer than you. I use my intelligence to learn things for myself and I do not pay any attention to people with political agendas, such as the major news media. I search for my own answers to things in which I'm interested but it often times takes some work. You seem rather energetic, so that's what I suggest that you do....learn your own truths and don't get it from a bunch of Kool-aid drinkers.

    I did not see your posts refering to your ideas about humidity, but from what you say, this is exactly what I am talking about that you should do to learn your own truths.

    Grammar is important, Necro, it gives you credibility. We all make mistakes and it takes work to get it right. (I can tell you, there's nothing worse than seeing something you've written and published that is a mistake!)

    By the way, businesses are run by honest people who have risked their life's savings and those of friend's to take a chance at that 'dream of success'. Corporations are the same, only bigger. But there are crooks and dishonest people in all walks of life, so don't besmirch everyone else just because of a few rotten apples in the barrel.

    If you don't like oil companies, well....the rest of the world depends upon oil, just like you do. They have paid for the right to develop their product, just like logging and mining companies. Someone has to provide these materials, our modern life depends on them. I agree that some things can be improved upon, but I suggest that you be constructive about your criticism rather than so destructive.

    My criticisms of you are meant to be positive, and they could be if you viewed them as such. I don't have the time to educate you about all the things I've criticised you about....I'm a busy person and you need to do these things for yourself in order for them to be meaningful to you. Don't be angry or insulted by my comments, learn from them. I hope you will.

    Lance

  • 21 years ago

    Lance thanx for the post

    I have no issue with comments against me where I am wrong.
    I always make a point to research something that interests me as much as I can.
    My point is not against large corporations, or oil companys themselves.
    What I see as an issue (mabey) of powerful people/familys such as the Bush family is that if a technology is there that can replace oil, this leaves it in a bit of a catch 22 situation.
    It would of course be in the interests of everyone to have such technology but it would hit these people/familys/corporations hard. (Imagine all those saltons out there in the middle east with their cash flow cut to shreds)
    The need for oil would drop dramatically if in 10 to 20 years there is no longer any petrolium burning motors.
    My points of view are just that, I am not tring to dictate that anyone live by any standards or not.
    I have read up a fair amount from various sources and various points of view about Sphagnum, how it is mined and what the effects are, both from individulals and from nature conservation.
    I do add the text "but I cannot be sure of this" when I have no real proof of a situation to try and cover my question/statement.
    I just still see the greed humanity has, thats not meant to be a bash against them, mearly my observasion.
    Hey, money is a great thing, and just like everything else, you can over indulge in it.
    Power gets to ones head, no matter how hard you fight it, and I think its all to true that no matter how hard you worked, the morals you had when you started are sometimes difficult to maintain in order to keep and increase both your power an cash flow in the company.

    Anyhow, Im not here to flame or have warfare with anyone, I mearly like to help those with problems conserning their plants and in turn get plenty of help from them, while meeting some wonderful people.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Necro,

    Contact me : lance@lancebirk.com

  • 21 years ago

    Oh you guys didn't take this argument private soon enough. I thought flaming sessions like this only happened on that other carnivorous plant chat line.
    I am getting more educated every day
    Thanx for listening and keep 'em plants growin'
    Lois

Sponsored