Software
Houzz Logo Print
taylorm_gw

Clematis roots thru the pot

21 years ago

I have a Proteus Clematis that was purchased last year. It was only a few inches when I bought it. It was in a very small pot last year. It was in a bit of a larger pot over the winter. This year it was planted in a larger container...at least 5 gallons. I put the pot behind lattice under a porch and let the vines climb through. I havent been around much this year to take care of it. I just went out to take a good look at it and its roots are attaching it to the ground. Yikes! I didn't realize the root system would grow that much in one Massachusetts Summer.

I don't think I have another pot that much larger than 5 gallons. Will I kill it if I leave it in that pot.

Hmm...now that I think about it...how was I going to take it into the garage for the winter if the vines are on the porch! What was I thinking! Can I cut the vines during the winter and bring it into my cold garage where I wintered it last year?

Thanks.

Taylor

Comments (14)

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Can you plant it in the ground now in a permanent place ? I think it wants more root space ! Once the roots reach the size yours have it's best to plant them, unless you want to move up to a 15 gallon pot and winter it in your garage !
    If you leave the pot outside over a 'Massachusetts winter' it may die. Putting the plant into the ground in a permanent spot will insure you against losing it and it will be much healthier in the long run. Clematis can have enormous root systems.
    Suzy

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you.

    Is it okay to cut off all the vines now before it goes dormant?

    Its definately not long and stringy. It has alot of vines coming from the base. Although, it did not flower...but I believe its an early bloomer.

    Taylor.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It sounds as if you have a group 2 type there. These DO NOT get pruned because they bloom from OLD WOOD. If you prune that wood off, chances are you will have no flowers next year.
    Maybe this is the reason yours did not bloom this year. Did you prune it back last year ?
    Suzy

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Actually Proteus blooms on both old and new wood. On old wood, it will bloom double and on new wood it will bloom with single blooms. Mine was pruned back last fall due to dieback on the plant, but I must have left at least some old wood since I got a few double blooms early in the season (late April-early May) and single blooms in about June.

    Early blooms lower on the plant from the old wood

    {{gwi:622388}}

    Single blooms in later spring/early summer (Piilu also present in the picture on the left)

    {{gwi:622389}}

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Clematis roots through the pot can be a problem. I have a Ernest Markham in a 16 inch pot that has been able to plug the drainage hole with its roots. It is on a deck so cannot root into soil but plugging the drainage hole causes the pot to fill with water. Al

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Miguel, (knickvilledude), we don't have the luxury of treating our group 2 clematis as group 3's up here in Massachusetts. We get little to no bloom from these when they are hard pruned because of our short growing season.
    Suzy

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Suzy, I am not talking about type IIs that bloom in a given year, and then cutting them back after the first bloom flush and getting them to rebloom within the same year. I pruned the Proteus late in the summer/early fall of 2004 and it put out the new foliage and single blooms the following year and bloomed by June of 2005 (the same year). The double blooms were very early in the spring of 2005 on old wood. I find it hard to believe that your growing season is so short that if pruned late in one season that clematis won't have time to develop enough new wood to bloom by the end of the next years growing season. I could see this if you were much further north, say maybe zone 5 or even zone 4, but surely zone 6 is not so far north that your growing season isn't long enough for this to happen. If that is the case, how do your type IIIs ever have time to bloom since they are always cut close to the ground in late winter/early spring? I know that just recently Jackie in Ohio zone 5 is having rebloom on her Crystal Fountain and on Belle of Woking. These are new blooms on new wood that has developed in zone 5 over the course of this growing season. How do you explain this?

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Trust me Miguel, I have tried and tried and my group 2's simply won't produce a nice flush if treated as group 3's.
    You just have to live here to understand, I guess, lol. Believe me, I would love to be able to have late blooming group 2's !
    My group 3's are much more vigorous growers and have no trouble blooming, since they bloom on new wood. They start blooming around mid-July.
    One thing I have noticed about zones and that is that there all kinds of differences in the same zone. For instance, my zone 6 is not the same as zone 6 in New Jersey. We are much colder here at times and have much wilder fluxuations. As an example, last year we had bitter cold one day with 4 feet of snow, and the next day it was 55 degrees and melting ! These fluxuations get averaged, thus the average may be the same as in New Jersey where the temperatures are a bit warmer, but MUCH STEADIER. I don't like the zonal maps one bit, because for some of us they're very misleading, especially for those of us who live along the coast who endure the wild nor'easter storms of winter. If you asked a weatherman where he would most like to work they usually say, "Boston" because of it's wild and unpredictable weather. The old saying here is, 'wait a few minutes and the weather will surely change', lol. Do you remember the movie, "The Perfect Storm" ? That winter storm took place here. We lost 1/2 of our town along the coast and these cold nor'easter storms are quite common here in winter, although this storm was worse than some. Anyway, I hope I have given you some comparisons so that you can see that zones are not always a good indication of 'same weather' conditions. It's these late winter fluxuations that are the problem for my group 2's. Some years, I lose the old wood entirely which means no flowers or very few, because the new vines won't have time to harden off to produce buds.
    BTW, here, the leaves are just beginning to show hints of turning color and the nights are cool in the 45-50's on average. The leaves in New Jersey are far from turning color, yet we are in the same zone ! It doesn't make sense to me, since our growing season is over and theirs has a way to go yet.
    Another example: We have a saying here for growing corn. The saying goes, it should be 'knee high by the 4th of July'. In Jersey they're eating corn on the 4th of July!
    Zones are obviously not an indicator of growing and harvesting times, nor can zones be an indication of growing season for clematis drawn as they are at present. It's frustrating for me to explain, because I don't believe these zones to be accurate at all.
    Suzy

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Suzy, I can very well understand that all zone 6s are not the same and that really all zone maps give you is an estimation of the temperature minimums in a given area. The maps not only don't take into account microclimates within a zone so that someone listed as being in a zone 6 could actually be in a zone 4 or a zone 7, but also don't take in humidity, temperature vacillations over summer or winter, etc..

    All that taken into consideration, I was responding to your statement that people in Massachusetts can't treat their type IIs as type IIIs. I understand that in your experience with the type IIs you have attempted to treat as type IIIs, they did not do well, but that might not be the same experience someone else living in zone 6 Massachusetts may have. Add to that the fact that not all type IIs are cut of the same cloth. Some are more vigorous growers than others. Some are hybrids of more sturdy and rambunctious growers than others. Additionally, how old the plants are when they are either pruned back or nipped back to the ground by an extremely cold winter will also affect how robustly they grow next year.

    In my experiences in zone 7a, the type IIs that have responded most positively to either my cutting them back (intentionally or otherwise) or their getting cut back due to dieback and then responding by blooming in short order are Sunset, Proteus, and Blue Light. These can be cut back and be in rebloom within a month to a month and one half at the max. Sunset was originally purchased and supposed to be Margot Koster, a type III, so she was cut back in winter as is customary with type IIIs and came back like gangbusters in the early spring as though she hadn't been cut back at all. On the other hand, my HF Young and another unknown type II were cut back within the same time frame as the Blue Light and although they have responded by putting out a lot of foliage, HF Young has only put out two blooms so far and the other, none at all. Blue Light responded quite dramatically with 15 or so blooms.

    Here's what I don't quite understand about the type IIs and their growth patterns in your experience. Let's say you have Blue Light and it gets frozen back to the ground over the course of the winter (something that has probably happened to quite a few type II clematis in your zone and lower). My Blue Light survives as it typically does unscathed, blooms with double blooms in the midspring and over the course of the summer browns out. I cut it back in late July to within 6 to 8 inches of the ground and one and a half months later it is putting on its second flush of single blooms on new wood. How can your plant, which was frozen back to the ground over the winter, have all spring and summer to bloom and still not generate enough new wood to bloom? It just doesn't make sense that it would be an issue of growing season length since the plant would have from when it emerged in spring until the fall to generate new wood on which it could bloom before it would be bitten back by frost. Can you see why I am having problems comprehending why the type IIs don't respond to either intentionally being cut back in the fall or even early spring for that matter and their inability to bloom that same year--even if it is at the end of the growing season? Which type IIs have you tried this with and how old were the plants when you tried this? Have you tried this with established plants of Blue Light, Sunset, or Proteus?

    Thanks for your time in answering these questions, although for Taylor who originated this thread, the answer is probably mute. It sounds as if his potted clematis is in a pot under the porch and the vines have intertwined themselves in the lattice. The only way he can plant it or move it into a protected area is going to be to trim it back. Trying to remove mature vines that are intertwined in lattice will be difficult if not impossible.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Miguel, Do you remember the experiment I did this summer for your benefit as well as a few others in warmer zones who were convinced that we ALL should hard prune our group 2's? Well, to prove my point that it never works here, I followed through with the results of my experiment of hard pruning several lovely plants, hoping that you and Gardengal would see them. The link is below. I feel a bit like a broken record on this subject, but for me it is a fact. If you lived here it wouldn't seem so hard to comprehend. Seeing is believing and living here has taught me well through the years. Believe me, I know clematis and have tried 'hard pruning' several plants on many different occasions. The results were always terrible. By the way, the plants used in the experiment were both mature and beautiful plants. It is possible that in other parts of Massachusetts a hard prune may produce flowers, but I highly doubt that there are many cases of a full flush. Our spring usually doesn't begin until May 15-June 1st which is likely to be the reason why my group 2,hard pruned plants are unable to flower. By the end of September it begins to get quite chilly and the plants are 'long done'.
    Roses also have a difficult time here and I cannot grow ANY Hybrid Teas at all, which I grew plenty of in my zone 6 - in New Jersey many years ago. New Jersey's growing season is MUCH longer than mine. It's a different climate here entirely. So, you can see why zones are a bit of a joke to me. I just laugh and wonder what idiot drew the lines !
    Suzy

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pruning group 2's as group 3's

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Suzymac:

    I'd be curious about sunlight hours causing not enough growth. Have you ever tracked that where you live? Also forget the average temps.....how do night-time temps change? I've noticed with growing roses and clematis that subtle changes in night temps and sunlight hours seem to signal the plants to do things (ex. put on a growth spurt, bloom more and slow down growth). Another factor could be rainfall......how does the pattern change during the year?

    I'll be doing more intense info gathering next year and it'd would be great if a group of us could compare notes next winter (2006). Interested? How about you, nckvilledudes?

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Suzy, I have no doubt that your experiences are true and valid for you. The important thing is what didn't work for you might work for people in similar zones. Also, you report results on two examples of type II clematis that you performed one experiment on. Do you think that proves beyond a doubt that all type IIs will respond accordingly?
    Do you not think that some type IIs are hardier/more vigorous than others and might respond differently? Do you not think that people in your zone and other should push the limits and see what might work for them in their zones?

    I can remember Ton and Roger Van Loon from GBs telling me not to plant Clematis florida 'Sieboldii' or Princess Dianna in the fall because when they had done so, they lost plants. I tried to explain to them that conditions in their zones were vastly different than those in my zone and I did end up planting both of them one fall, one of them on Halloween, Oct. 31st, and they survived the winter with no problems. If you had listened to conventional wisdom, you wouldn't have attempted growing Clematis florida 'Sieboldii' because it is listed as only being hardy to zone 7 and we all know now that is not the case.

    My point here is not to be argumentative but to point out that different people in the same area can have different experiences growing clematis. You haven't been successful in getting type IIs to rebloom in your area if they are trimmed in late winter. That is all good and well, but that shouldn't discourage others to try and see what works in their area. I think it discourages people when they see someone say "we don't have the luxury of treating our group 2 clematis as group 3's up here in Massachusetts." That is your experience and you can live by it but it comes across as being something that is set in stone for all type IIs and for all people in Massachusetts growing clematis. Do you see how that might prejudice someone against experimenting with their clematis in your area? I guess I take Edith Malek's attitude in her book "Simply Clematis" who says:

    "I believe you should never lose sleep over cutting back your clematis. Don't be afraid to prune! Even if you cut away too much, your clematis will recover to bloom another day."

    As a gardener, I think I look to the future to see what all I can learn and discover in my garden. Gardening shouldn't be all about rigid rules that prevent or discourage one from experimenting in the garden. Your experience are valid for you and you alone until someone else tries it and sees that something either works or doesn't work for them.

    Shebear, interesting concept of recording data. What specifically do you suggest and how to go about doing it? Last year when this whole issue came up, I asked that people give me examples of type II clematis that they had cut back and had to rebloom in their zones. I got responses from a few people as to the specific clematis, what zone they were in, when they cut them back, etc. and compiled it into a spreadsheet. If you or anyone else would like to add to it or even see it, email me directly and I will be more than happy to send it to you since I don't have a good way of posting it here. Cheers!

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ahhh Miguel, somehow we missed eachother's points. Oh well, let's end this.
    Suzy

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Agreed Suzy. Let's just say we agree to disagree! LOL

Sponsored