Software
Houzz Logo Print
garnetmoth

you DO get what you pay for

21 years ago

Ok, so ive been learning with seedlings, and bought some sale trees from Gurneys, $30 including shipping for 3, a Key, a Meyer, and an unknown sweet orange.

theyre crooked, branched, and some of the leaves were cut/mangled. They have been planted for over a week, and 2 are showing growth. One has lost about 2 leaves. I think theyll all make it, but will be little better than scion wood. Which is why I bought them anyways, but ouch. (Im groing FDs from seed too)

I would have preferred single stem, or at least straight plants, but they'll work.

Comments (14)

  • 21 years ago

    Garn, I don't understand..are you satified or not with your new trees? LOL
    Since Gurney's, (Jung's and Henry's) are not nurseries that specialize in citrus, you may not be a happy camper. I know, I recently bought a fig from one of the above nurseries and an not at all happy.
    One thing about Gurney's, their citrus are not grown as a standard, upright tree..These are sold at citrus nurseries. Good luck w/your new trees..Toni

  • 21 years ago

    for $30, Im accepting that I cant gripe. much. :-)

    Since I got them to be scion wood for my FD rootstock seedlings, im not too upset that theyre "bushes". I probably wont keep them around after Ive kept a graft or 2 off of them.

    I did get a Nana Pomegranate from a less-than-known-for-fruit nursery, at an end-of-the-year sale, and shes finally fruiting and looking really good (and was under $10)

  • 21 years ago

    Garn, the Nana's are nice Pome's..I've one on order from Mellingers.com It won't be delivered until spring for some reason..Congrats on your Pom..how tall? Toni

  • 21 years ago

    {{gwi:633320}}

    I got this dwarf cara cara at a whim at HomeDepot
    It is from LaVerne Nursery which does deal in citrus

    I took off a few straggler branches and I think I can get those 2 branches to be close to vertical but they are growing out to the side.

    Does she look like a good tree

    I was looking at other dwarf trees for maybe 5 or $10 more
    and I don't want a bush as most dwarfs are

    It says this one will be about 6 to 8 feet

    The dwark root stock is a bit odd as it look like it has 3 knuckles on the bottom

    close up of trunk
    {{gwi:633321}}

    I can take it back to HD so I guess I'm asking whether it looks like a good healthy tree

    Thanks

    I tried citrus about 2 years ago
    had a few trees in containers and they all got root rot and some brown dyback on stems

    So I am a bit concerned and figured the $20 Dwarf Cara
    would be good to try

  • 21 years ago

    Looks great for a $20 tree! I agree with you about branchy little bushes, I am not averse to something being branched, but I think stubby low plants are a little less desirable looking.

    Have you read what can cause root rot? Keeping the plant too wet (and im guessing its easier to over water in the winter/indoors) Wide/shallow planters are less desireable than thinner/deeper.

    The soil looks a bit thirsty (but make sure its not still wet at the bottom)

    My mystery orange has just had a huge flush of growth. looks like mine will muddle through.

  • 21 years ago

    Thanks

    I guess its better to try with a $20 tree than a $30
    Most dwarfs aren't the best shape
    but I was thinking of maybe seeing if I could find a nicer one
    but heck its cute
    love its toes
    LOLI too like the look at least on a min tree with some stem
    This one has a small stem then 2 v branches
    could be worse I guess
    and it does look healthy

    I used a water meter on this one
    its reading pretty wet under the top
    I just got it Friday and didn't water it
    Not sure of what size to go up to
    probably do a conservative repot
    esp since it is winter

    last time I went from 5 to 15

    The mix is sandy
    sand does stay pretty wet
    and its true mine pretty much always read wet
    guess the root ball didn't get much sun but the tops did
    as the balcony wall shades the bottom at times of the year

    I do love them though and the cara cara is quite tasty
    and has nice dark green leaves

  • 21 years ago

    Dwarf rootstock(flying dragon) dwarfs about 40%. So instead of 30 feet tall, the tree gets 24 feet tall. Citrus dwarfs aren't true dwarfs like dwarf apples.

    Here is a link that might be useful: mrtexas

  • 21 years ago

    Here's a link to an article that says Flying Dragon dwarfs by 75%.

    http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1216/is_6_211/ai_111354238

    Here is a link that might be useful: article from Sunset

  • 21 years ago

    Is there a good book that a vaguely science educated person can understand? I would like to know more about what these trees need and are capable of. Id consider buying a book soonish (I probably wont buy any large trees until we move to a more permanent house and I can have a greenhouse or large coldframe)

    Is there a general chart on how dwarfing certain rootstocks are? How many summer-heat-hours "marginal" citrus like Key lime need?

    Ive searched on a general science journal search, and I usually get genetics or virus research. I dont need that much detail ;-)

  • 21 years ago

    I'm not sure if the rootstock is flying dragon
    How would you ID FD?

    I know Atrmstrong sells ntra dwarfs
    It does say the tree will be a bush 6 to 8 feet

    I prefer the look of a standard
    and been tempted to get one as they say it will be dwarfed if grown in container
    I've heard that is so
    but saw a 6 foot standard in a 3 gal yesterday with fruit
    Very tempting when I look at my little guy
    but mine has healthy green leaves and the one I saw yesterday had yellow leaves and was stressed in the small pot laden with fruit.

    I wonder if a tree like that would be a problem coming back
    Would think it would more likely be nutrient diffiency than overwater considering the small pot.

    What I don't like abut mine is the chopped branch at the graft line which I assume is the original seedling it was grafted too.

    I've seen some really nice seamless grafts
    and to me it just lookes better

  • 21 years ago

    Garn, I've three citrus books purchased at Amazon.com
    'Citrus,' by Lance Walheim.. The second book is 'All About Citrus, and Subtropical Fruits,' by Ortho...the third is 'Sunset Citrus.' by Sunset.

    Each book has about 6 pages regarding growing citrus in containers, but they give backgrounds, growing environments.. They are detailed to replicate citrus natural growing habitats. Great pictures, description and pics of citrus/fruits. Soils, watering, sun, temp, humiidy, etc etc.
    You don't have to be a scientist to understand these books..each are user-friendly reading. Toni

  • 21 years ago

    Garnetmoth - Unfortunately, I don't know of any book like that, and my library of citrus books and research articles rivals anyone that I know of. If there is anything specific that you would like to know (without going through all the Latin stuff, LOL) I'll gladly look it up for you.

  • 21 years ago

    Thanks muchly for all your advice!

    I think Ill try to find those books in the store before buying them Toni, thanks! Ive read most of the fact sheets from Coop Extensions I can find online.

    Im mostly wondering what types of things are too frustrating from seed, I understand Key Lime are a great choice, short juvenility. Mandarin, bad choice. Which of the stranger citrus are nucellar/true? (Im looking for Kaffir fruit this season for another seedling!)

    Also, if Key Lime is marginal in cooler summer locations, will they produce OK in Nashville (90+ most of the summer, but now its pretty cool/dry, indoors)? I understand the concept of chilling hours, but is there an analagous warming hours for picky citrus?

    Take Care, happy citrusing everyone! I took Latin in high school. I think I can still read it, but botanical names are a bit far for me! Especially citrus, but I have printed out a few things about sweet/ trifolate/ fortunella and am wrapping my brain around some distinctions.

  • 21 years ago

    I washed all the pld soil off sandy and it was wet for too long
    Home depot was on the way to root rot

    Hope she likes my mix
    She is a flying fdragon
    least I;'m pretty sure the way that root was contorted and bent kind on cute

    She was very well rooted almost whole 5 gal but was starting to get mushy roots on bottom from being so wet

    I gave her 3 or so inches under her and 3 inches wider
    Think that should be ok
    To tell you the truth I think she looks better already

    {{gwi:633322}}