Software
Houzz Logo Print
ckamaral

NERVOUS TO PUT IN DARK WOOD FLOORS

14 years ago
We are in the process of remodeling our home and I really want to put in really dark wood floors (an espresso color that is almost black). I love the look of it, but am nervous. I have three young kids and a dog. I currently have light wood floors, and of course, can see all of the dark dirt (and dog hair) that is tracked inside. I have heard that with dark wood floors, you can see all of the light dust and footprints. Does anyone have any thoughts or ideas?

Comments (45)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Dark wood floors are beautiful and very popular at the moment, but they will indeed magnify all of the dog hair, dust bunnies and dirt tracked in much more than lighter floors (as tipi notes, medium-light tones probably hide things best). So as long as you make the decision with your eyes open to the extra cleaning involved, that's fine. Personally, I have enough cleaning to do as it is and don't need any extra, so dark wood floors would not be my choice.
  • 14 years ago
    I was in the same situation this time last year. My daughter-in-law said "don't do it, you will regret it". She knows how I can not stand the dust on my furniture, fingerprints on glass, etc. We are empty nesters and have a dog. I ended up going with traditional colored hardwood floors. So glad I did!!!! I still see the blond dog hair and dust. I can only imagine what it would have been like with the dark espresso floors I so wanted. I would have been going crazy trying to keep them clean.
    Good luck!

    PS Another thing to consider....Is there a LOT of natural light in your home? Are you walls going to be lighter color? Otherwise, it I think your home would look to dark.
  • 14 years ago
    I have walnut floors...they are on the darker side but not expresso colored. They show everything (dust, water spots, etc) when the light hits them. I'd say your choice may depend on the level of natural light in your house.
  • 14 years ago
    Good point by 14thstreet. I have medium/ light oak floors and sweep about every other day. They look great. . . . except when the sun streams through the west facing windows in the late afternoon. I can see all sorts of dust flecks, bunnies, crumb bumbs and paw prints. I'd hate to see what they would like stained a walnut or espresso.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    A few months before my marriage we went ahead with a home renovation , which was massive in scale Hundred thousand plus , we went for carrara on the floors and dark wallnut wooden floor in A master bedroom and both are giving us sleepless nights ;-) , go for a medium stain or floor colour, otherwise you will be a Maid of the Floor !
    (Spending quality time which you would give to your family rather than have a Backache , clean up all the time) But even if you go ahead with dark floors buy a I robot its a great device for automatic pre programmed cleaning of your home .
  • 14 years ago
    Great idea on the iRobot!!!!! Thank you all for your good advice........ :)
  • 14 years ago
    It is that Western exposure that's the killer. I have beautiful floors (hickory) until the Fall, when the sun is lower, and the light streams into the first floor windows. I just don't ask anyone to visit between 3 and 5 P M.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I agree with not going as dark as expresso color.

    Walnut Floors · More Info
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    If considering dark floors or even cherry floors remember sun light will darken them further. I also would consider an oil finish as it shows less dirt because of its lower gloss and it is mush easier to buff out claw marks from fast turning pets. Polly finishes also age and whiten with solar exposure. Remember the clear skylights that fog up after a few years.
  • 14 years ago
    We have dark Walnut almost black, we have a dog and 2 daughters. Its really hard to live with dirty, dusty floors, it drives me crazy. If you have the funds I would check into running the new porcelain tiles that look like wood, they are so close to wood its unbelievable. They don't scratch, they mop great and are not slippery. You can get them in different sizes.
    If you want wood, maybe go buy a box of dark flooring, put it at the sink for a week and see what it looks like.

    good luck, I know the dark looks so great but you can't be screaming at your kids all day to watch out for the foor. We go through lots of sharpie markers to cober up the scratches.

    Also when you put the felt floor protectors on your furniture make sure you get the ones that hammer into the legs of your furniture that way they don't fall off like the other ones.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    pre drill for the nail type protector to avoid splinting legs. I'd take exception with politician not being slippery. I left the spell correctors changed word for Porcelain even though it doesn't have much credibility.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Very good advise on not going with the espresso tones when little people and dogs are involved. You will see all the light dust and hairs. Hardwood floors are wonderful, the less shiny finish, the easier they are to keep clean. Tung oil is a fabulous finish, if you are not wanting a shiny finish. The tung oil absorbs into the wood, rather than forming a hard finish on top of the wood. When your floor scratches it doesn't scratch with white lines. The white lines is the surface finish scratching. When tung oiled floors scratch the wood actually scratches, not leaving the white scratch lines. These types of scratches then add character to your flooring but can tend to be a bit more rustic. They are beautiful though! They are easy to maintain. Damp cloth/mop is best. You do not want to use too much water due to streaking as they dry. Cherry flooring is timeless and durable and as someone mentioned above, will darken with time. In about 6 months, your floors should be to their darkest tone. They will not get to the espresso tones, but will be beautiful. Walnut is also a beautiful finish tone.
    Hope this helps!
    Cheers!
    m.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Think I'm in the minority on this one. Here goes, my house sounds similar to yours, three kids, one dog, lots of people in and out every day. My floors are coffee bean brown or almost black. I love them. My feeling is the floors are going to get dirty no matter what color they are. Cleaning the floor with kids and dogs is just part of the program. Not sure why masking the dirt with medium colored floors is appealing, the dirt, dust and dog hair are all still there, even if less noticeable. I suggest good weather stripping on all exterior doors to help with dust and a good quality dust buster for all the rest. I also use almost black floors on many projects and so far, my clients love them and I have not heard any complaints.
    Charmean Neithart Interiors, LLC. · More Info

    Charmean Neithart Interiors, LLC. · More Info

    angeles
    Charmean Neithart Interiors, LLC. · More Info

    Hope that helps. Charmean Neithart
  • 14 years ago
    Charmean, you have designed three beautiful rooms. That bench in picture #1, what style is that? Is it Empire, Neo-classical?
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Hi judyg. Thank you so much for your compliment. This piece is by Baker and here is the official description on their website, "This is a Directoire style stool with painted, leafed wood feet, and lionheaded arms, a form that melds well in a Charleston drawing room with Empire and classical pieces." Hope that answers your question. Best, Charmean
  • 14 years ago
    Thanks. It is such a striking piece. That entire space is over the top wonderful!
  • 13 years ago
    I love the dark hardwood. We are looking at building next year and dark was what I intend to put in. I agree that all floors are going to show dirt, dust, and hair, no matter what. I am more interested in the type of hardwood that people have in their home and how it holds up to scratches, bumps and stains. I really like the look of strained bamboo. Our trim will be white. Any ideas?
  • 13 years ago
    I have walnut stained hardwood plus 4 dogs, 3 children and two adults. I love the colour except when the sun starts to set as I have a west facing house. Like judlanna20, nobody gets invites between 4-5pm.
  • 13 years ago
    I think going with dark wood/espresso black would look beautiful. but then again i personally loveeee dark hardwood floors and hope to install them for my own home.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Dark is so very pretty.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    The dirt/dust/prints/etc. will certainly increase with a dark floor. One of two ways around this. 1) Work with a medium stain with the same tones in it. You would be amazed at how much darker a floor looks once it is in place. 2) Work with a low-gloss finish. It turns out that the high-gloss on anything will show off far more dirt/tracks than anything else.

    Or three - cork. A medium/dark cork floor can give the appearance of hardwood without dust bunnies! Have a look.
  • 12 years ago
    Charmean, who was the manufacturer of the dark wood. Was it unfinished, engineered, or prefinished solid hardwood? Need to replace our floor and looove the dark floors,
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    The floors in the picture were installed unfinished and stained on site. The color is custom, but best described as a dark coffee bean or almost black. Hope that helps. Charmean Neithart
  • 12 years ago
    I had the very dark wood floors. It was the big look in 2000. I think they look dated now. And I have heard all the horror stories on very dark wood. I would never put them in again. But, live and learn. If you have them get out a swiffer, you will need it.
  • 12 years ago
    My brother in law has oak with a medium stain, three dogs and a very active mud tromping boy and it looks great. Of course any floor will show dirt but a very dark floor is unforgiving and every spec will show.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks Charmean!
  • 12 years ago
    In a floor store looking at woods and narrowed down to a few- none black. A customer walked in to talk to owner who professionally cleans floors and then showed me what he installed 5 years ago: black distressed floors! He said with 3 kids and 2 dogs it was the best decision. Yes he has to vacuum, but looks new and shows no scratches etc. Loves them!
  • 11 years ago

    We just put in Jacobean, dark 5 1/8 inch wide bamboo in our laundry / breakfast / kitchen / family room and small hall downstairs. Our tenants had destroyed our house in the 2.5 years we were in Colorado, so that was the flooring of our choice instead of redoing the tile and carpet in those rooms. It's GORGEOUS when it's clean, but yes, you have to get the dust and dirt off daily. I would not do it any other way. Our kids are now 9 and have 2 cats and a small dog and only the dog goes outside to do his business.

    This picture was taken after the new floors went in, some painting still needed to be done.


  • 11 years ago

    Very nice floor, wish I could have done that with our new house but the threat of termites out weighed my love of this wood.


  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, dark shows the dirt, scratches and imperfections more, but it is so beautiful and generally worth it. Often my customer choose to go just 1 shade lighter for the look, but a bit more practicality. So rather than do ebony, they will choose jacobean or 50/50 blend jacobean/ebony (i.e. espresso), or dark walnut.

    Another key aspect (regardless of color) is sheen. Satin finishes are more stylish and more practical as they show dirt, foot prints and scratches less. You can learn more about it in this blog post. What sheen is most popular for hardwood floors?

  • PRO
    11 years ago
    This thread was great. We are currently replacing out espresso hardwood floors with a medium gloss finish. We had some water damage from our dishwasher.
    I've had the espresso hardwood floors for 8 years. Two dogs, a cat and two kids. It's endured a lot. It actually wore quite well. However I'm replacing with something a touch lighter and with a less glossy finish. Maintaining my floors is so hard. 5 minutes after washing them it just takes one persons foot prints to make me want to start over again. They show everything!!!
    It's the foot prints that drive me crazy though.
    I'm drawn to the new gray toned hardwoods but worry that they will look dated in a few years.
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ooohhh.... Where do I start.... I read some of these older post almost two years ago because I, too, wanted the dark floors. I read all the cons and hubby and I decided, we still want them!!!! We ended up installing super-dark hand-scraped bamboo flooring. My thoughts as the floor was going in? "Wow! This house looks straight out of a magazine!!!" and "Oh my gosh. What have I done?"

    We have (at this point) a 6yr old, a 4yr old and a dog. Everything shows. And I mean EVERYTHING!!! Impossible to keep clean even right after I've cleaned them!!! Many times you can see the line where the mop switched directions. Dust specks as soon as I turn my back.... The floors are an obsessive thought all day long. Way too much energy spent cleaning them and having anxiety over them.

    That being said, they look stunning and dare I say, refreshingly unique. People that visit for the first time usually gasp upon entering and comment on how gorgeous our floors are. I usually end up smiling and saying a graceful "thank you" as my eyes dart over to the corner where I've spotted... Yup.... Dust flecks and dog hair.


    P.S. The reason I'm back on this thread? I was googling "how to keep dark floors clean"!!! Trying to see if there was anything clever out there!

  • 11 years ago
    Tonifawcett
    I found your post extremely helpful. We relate to you very much. We are in the process of remodeling and are considering dark hardwood or bamboo flooring. I would love to know - if you had to do it all over again, would you still do the dark floors?
    Thank you!
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    atkhorshad I do not think so! :-))) We replaced carpet in our bedrooms on coffee beans color flooring...now we are doing flooring in family room...I do not want tile floor there...I think we can not go with different color... and I think we stuck with dark color !

  • 11 years ago

    Atkhorshad, what a tough question!!! Honestly, it depends WHEN you're asking! After I just tried to sweep and mop-- I'd yell, "NO!!!!! Never again!!!". But... They look so beautiful and unique that well.... It's kinda like wearing a pair of shoes you know look fantastic-admired by all around you-tons of compliments... Meanwhile, you're wincing at the blister pain. And yes, some of us are messed up enough to wear the shoes again! So yes, gorgeous floors, huge pain. And yes. We still have plans to add more of the floor as we change things...


    I was of no help to you. ; )

  • 11 years ago
    Thank you, celerygirl!!!
    And tonifawcett. You are too funny, and I love how you describe things. You're more help than you know.
  • 11 years ago
    I would avoid shiny dark wood. I have a satin or mat finish. Mine is Hand scraped, Golden teak acacia. It's dark like walnut. I love it. Easy to clean and the rustic appearance hides wear and tear. Keep a stain pen handy...scratches add to the character of the floor.
  • 9 years ago
    tonifawcett, what are you cleaning your floors with? I had beautiful espresso floors for 5 years. I used all kinds of floor cleaners and all they did was leave marks and steaks on my beautiful floor. I also did some intensive research and found that the best thing to use is diluted vinegar. About a gallon water to 1 cup white vinegar. It worked like a charm. Cheap and no chemicals to worry about.
  • 9 years ago

    Big sigh! when I read about everyone's high anxiety over floors! They are floors, made to be walked on and they get dirty and dusty. I suppose I'm very far removed from feeling anxiety over cleaning my floors and keeping them showroom shiny all the time. I clean them, mop up any spills, and go on about my life. If dog hair and dust accumulate during the week or so I don't vacuum, then I lower the lights and get intimate with the people in the house.

  • 8 years ago

    Don't do it!!!! especially if you have pets. I chose my dark bamboo floor because it was on sale, and I thought it would be pretty. It's kinda pretty, but... The dark color makes my small home look even smaller. Plus, I see every hair and speck of dust and I just can't seem to get it all cleaned up. It's absolutely maddening, especially with four dogs tracking inside and leaving dirty paw prints right at the entryway! Just say NO. I spent $$ only to hate my new floor, and regret not choosing a medium tone.

  • 8 years ago

    And it's strand bamboo so I probably can't even refinish it. Ugh. If my boyfriend and his dad hadn't installed it, I'd definitely remove it or put other flooring over it. To do so would be quite rude to them. But I just HATE how dirty the floor looks, even right after cleaning it!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    You do have a choice in that it is possible to float a new floor on top of the existing floor without taking it up. If that is an option then have it sanded and if you don't like the results you can cover it with a new layer and just change out the shoe and cut the door casing to slip it under.

  • 8 years ago

    to the person that was scared, you should be. dark hardwoods are seductive. just purchased a home with stunning dark hardwood floors. they look terrible if I dont clean them every other day. beautiful and hideous all at once. just realize that to keep the look, it will take almost daily work

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Three years ago I had extremely dark espresso chestnut floors installed throughout my entire home except where there was already tile. They are beautiful and I do love them. They do show all smudges, dust, pet hair (I have a dog and a cat) & a myriad of other oddities that land on the floor over time & it did take a bit of self-analysis to accept that floors are floors and they are meant to be walked on and that all floors, regardless of their color, accumulate the same dust & dirt as mine. I've finally come to terms with my dark floors. I run the vacuum over them then use my Bissell Spinwave to clean & buff them. They are absolutely gorgeous for about 5 or 6 hours until the dust starts to settle and they get walked on here and there. It is progressive and gets worse with time. I smile now and let them get nice and nasty till I get the urge to clean them again. Using the Bissell Spinwave is actually quite relaxing. I also have a robot, but of course it does not remove the smudges.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting