Software
Houzz Logo Print
chrissy_ns

Eureka Daylily Guide

17 years ago

Hi

I would like to hear opinions on the latest guide so I can decide if I should buy it. Colors accurate?

Christine

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    I know little about it. I too would be interesting in hearing what it's all about. I really thought it was just a black and white listing of varieties and prices from the daylily nurseries. I can google that myself. But if it has lots of good pictures that's a whole other ball game. What price are they asking?

  • 17 years ago

    Here is a link to info about ordering the Eureka Daylily Guide.
    It does have a lot of pictures.

    http://www.gardeneureka.com/

  • 17 years ago

    Over the years the Eureka has slowly gotten better. The pictures are as good as ever but if you are buying it primarily for the pictures then don't. The selection of pictures is determined by what Ken Gregory happens to take and what contributors happen to submit. It is an eclectic collection at best with the quality of pictures ranging from excellent to poor.

    Each year it contains a little more information, the prices reflected in Eureka in general are higher than those on the lily auction. That is to be expected because the prices in Eureka are solely the average price of those who advertise in Eureka.

    The pictures in Eureka are also available on CD for $20 but this year the Eureka logo is plastered on each and every picture which diminishes the value of the pictures for anyone who might want to reuse them.

  • 17 years ago

    Actually, I don't think Ken has used any of his pictures in Eureka for the past couple of years as he has missed the last two National conventions. My take on the color in this issue is that most of the pictures were darkened in the printing process. Some of the pictures had issues with color or lighting before they were printed, hence,some show up better than others. Regrettably, when photographers submit pictures to any publication, they have no control over the printing process and may not even recognize their original pictures when they see them in print! I say this because my pictures have appeared in Eureka for the past nine years, and this year's pictures are quite a bit darker than the originals sent in. Some years the color is more accurate than others.
    There are more pictures used than in the past, however,which people like, but there are fewer advertisers. A lot of people now rely solely on website and Journal advertising and have quit advertising in Eureka. As a result, there are fewer listings for some cultivars, which really doesn't give a totally accurate picture of "average" prices for cultivars! ( IMHO of course.)

  • 17 years ago

    I've been disappointed with the Eureka guide for the past two years. I have guides for the last eight years, and always found it a helpful source for finding some older daylilies and just for admiring the photography.

    This year's guide has noticeably fewer vendors, therefore many fewer cultivars listed. However, the quality of the photographs is better than my copy from last year.

  • 17 years ago

    I ordered it for the 1st time this year and at around $40 including shipping I was expecting something fantastic. I have to say I was disappointed....none of the vendors I normally buy from were listed and the photography was not as great as anticipated. Will I plan on buying it again? Probably not. But if you think you must have it, take advantage of their prior year publications that are greately discounted at around $13 each as opposed to the $35+/-.

    Just my opinion, not meaning to be critical of the guide itself or the amount of time it must take to be put together...I consider that an exceptional effort!

  • 17 years ago

    Didn't buy it last year; didn't order it for this year; haven't given it a second thought.

    I've said it before, here as well as elsewhere -- my main issue with it as a "guide" to prices is that the math can be suspect in so many cases. Either too few sellers of a cultivar to make the "average" price meaningful or a relatively small number of sellers with prices all over the place (and, of course, if there are not many sellers, even relatively small price differences affect the utility of the average) or one or two sellers with outlier prices (way too high or way too low), thus again affecting the average.

    I guess the other major issue for me is that I rarely actually referred to it. I'd bring it to gardens but not want to bother carting it around. At home, I have a fast enough internet connection so that I don't need the guide to check prices.

    Also, I generally use the lily auction as my guide to the most current prices.

    Also again, I have favorite sellers, both hybridizers and resellers, and I generally give them my business. Some of them may sell at above-guide prices, but I am far more interested in the quality of plants than in squeezing a few dollars out of a transaction.

    But having said all of that, if your club offers it at a good price, it might be worth having.