Software
Houzz Logo Print
brandys_garden

My hostas

13 years ago

I had never had a green thumb but a couple of summers ago, I bought my first hosta (a albomarginata) and it did very well so I bought some more last year (a fire and ice, a fire island, a pineapple upside down cake, and a blue mouse ears) and my neighbors gave me their mama mia before moving. It came to me very sick but I nursed it back to health. I was so happy and rewarded to see it come back this year! I am hoping it blooms and all 4 "babies" came back as well... Pretty soon, I will need to divide my albomarginata. I am a hosta lover!!

Comments (25)

  • 13 years ago

    They are easy to fall in love with :)

  • 13 years ago

    And you don't NEED to divide them. Just keep putting them into larger pots (or into the ground). Don't use saucers. Put a couple sticks under each pot to allow the wood/cement underneath to dry out between waterings or when it rains. You have begun a journey that will thrill you every Spring for many years.

    -Babka

  • 13 years ago

    Yea, I am hoping the pot I got it in now will do for the duration of the albomarginata's life... It's the largest they carry. I can't put them in the ground. It is gravel and rock here. :( But soon the babies will need to be moved into bigger pots. They should be OK this year. The Wheee will be OK for a year or 2 and the dwarf Mama Mia is good, too, for quite awhile. All the info online said I shouldn't have to divide the albomarginata but it is quite big and the hosta expert guy I know said that it may need to be next year. Hoping not, though. Anyway, heres the picture of my albomarginata today. It is going to be HUGE this year!

  • 13 years ago

    if you want a bigger pot.. find a nursery that sells trees.. and ask if they have a recycle pile ...

    and albomarginata is one of the bulletproof ones.. i would free it to mother earth.. and find something more stunning ... to keep close to you in your pots ...

    ken

  • 13 years ago

    Brandy,

    Nice Hostas. What is the one with the label in the first picture? Are those Oak trees that I see near the walk way? You seem to have your Hostas corralled on your porch, is that their wintering over spot or do you keep them there all summer too? That ground by the Oak Tree (if that's what it is) looks very inviting to me. BTW, your Fire Island is looking a very bright yellow. Welcome to the forum.

    Steve

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks, as explained, the earth is very hard and gravely over by me what you see is not grass, it's moss. And the oak tree was probably nature's doing? I can't put them in the ground, I tried once for two days and I couldn't get past the rock by the oak tree. They are fine and thrive very well in the pots plus I can better contol slugs from getting to them in the pots! ;) Which hosta are you referring to Steve? There are 5 in the first picture. The Wheee is the newest and largest right now. But the one beside it in the brown pot is a blue mouse ears and the others in the green pot is a fire island; white pot is a fire and ice; and in the rust pot is a pineapple upside down cake.

  • 13 years ago

    HI Brandy,

    Welcome to the forum. I also grow hosta in pots for the two reasons, one is the heavy soil and the other is cold time.

    You'll find that hosta are often mislabeled. I'm whining about that in another thread right now. We joke about it regularly in threads talking about Lowe's.

    So what's the one in the blue pot?

    bk

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks BK but the Wheee is the only hosta I've ever gotten from Lowe's and I know it's labeled correctly. One of the growers were there. As for the other 4 "babies" I didn't buy them from a store. I bought them as seedlings last year from a private grower/expert. I question the fire island one (what you call a blue pot that is actually dark green) as it looks like a couple of varieties and not quite as shaped on the leaves as pictures of other fire islands I have seen but I still think it is beautiful. As for the others, I have no doubt. They look like the other pictures I have seen. Although, the mama mia one I got from my neighbors, I don't know? It could be mislabled, too? I don't know where they got it. All I know for sure is that it is a dwarf variety. Anyway, a better picture of the fire island.

  • 13 years ago

    HI Brandy,

    I suggest you look up Whee! and Fire Island in the Hosta Library.

    I have gotten mislabeled plants from dedicated hosta growers (people who make a living at hosta growing). Fully 60% (maybe higher) of my plants from Lowe's have been mislabeled. It's just a fact of hosta life.

    Here's a link to several photos of whee! http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/hosta/msg050922056130.html?16

    bk

    Here is a link that might be useful: Hosta Library

    This post was edited by bkay2000 on Tue, Apr 16, 13 at 14:44

  • 13 years ago

    I appreciate it BK and I have looked up the wheee not on this site, but others and mine looks just like many of the photos, not all but not all hostas look the same. I am not saying it's not possible it was mislabeled but I don't know why you are so bent on this? It looks like a Wheee to me. The picture displayed is from the internet and looks like many of the other pictures I found. I am sorry you have had bad experiences. But even if it's not a wheee by your standards, I love it and I find it very unique and beautiful. As for the fire island, I have suspected from day 1 it was mislabeled but again it doesn't matter to me one bit. I don't know what it is for sure but I find it unique and beautiful- to my area. I appereciate your concern but I know some areas also have different names for the same hostas. Like pineapple upside down cake is called curly fries to some. It's basically the same thing. It is not a big concern to me. A rose by any other name would smell just as sweet and that is how I feel about my hostas. :)

  • 13 years ago

    Hi Brandy! Welcome to the forum, and to your new found interest in growing hostas! There are tons of people who grow lots of hostas, and can tell which plant is a hosta and which is not (petunia, tulip, geranium!!!) However once a gardener really falls in love with hostas their names become important, and the unknown varieties (NOIDs - no ID) become a real source of anguish. We puzzle over their true ID, share pictures and opinions, discuss the options. Perhaps we're a bit crazy. But a lot of the folks here are REALLY KNOWLEDGEABLE, and when one of them suggests one of my hostas might be mislabelled, I take them pretty seriously!!! Lots of the folks here have hundreds of varieties and the know their stuff.

    There do seem to be some discrepencies with names, as when two growers introduce the same plant with two different names. Won't say it can't happen. But if some call 'Pineapple Upsidedown Cake' 'Curly Fries" instead, I have some money that says they are just plain WRONG!
    For what it's worth.....
    Jan

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you Jan and I do understand and appereciate everyone's point of view and thoughts on it... But I did not ask if anyone thought this was so and so. I don't care about names. I care more about looks and what strikes me as different and unique. I have done my research on all my hostas and I am fairly certain that all of them, with the exception of 1 maybe 2 (the so called Fire Island and the Mama Mia) are what I paid for. The Wheee is in question and I didn't even question it. I looked at many, many different sites and the majority of the pictures I found looked just like mine. If it's not, I don't really care. Like the Patriot and the Liberty, they pretty much look the same to me and very much like my Fire and Ice. So names and labels are not important to me. I care more about appearances than labels. I am like this with my clothes and shoes, too. ;) So again, I appereciate everyone's interests in what I really have, in their opinions, but I love them regardless and it is just not important to me. The picture is of my baby fire and ice last year in August.

  • 13 years ago

    I'm sorry I offended. I certainly didn't mean to.

    bk

  • 13 years ago

    Welcome to the forum. They are pretty and healthy looking. Some of us fancy ourselves "collectors" so we want to name them all. Your Whee looks like Whee to me too. The others look too small for me to take a guess and why should I?

    I plant in containers and the ground. For similar reasons - where I can't dig - I use containers. I have Maples with thick webs of roots which limit where I can plant things so I put down a couple of bricks and put a pot under my Maple tree last year.

    Works great.

    Beverly

  • 13 years ago

    Oh BK no you didn't offend me in any way! No one did! I was just wondering why you seemed so upset that a couple may be mislabeled? It doesn't bother me any. The way I look at it, yea some may make mistakes because some do look so similar. And also there are the factors that you may take "parents" of a certain species and combine them but the "offspring" looks nothing like the "parents". I know this happens. I will never "show" or enter contest but it doesn't mean I don't love them any more than anyone else. Labels just aren't that important to me. Here's my mama mia, what is labeled as my mama mia taken last year while it was still recuperating, maybe you can see why I don't think this is correct? This year, the edges look more of a light green than a cream color.

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you Beverly! As long as they are healthy, unique and thriving, this is what I care about. The small ones, which I call the babies are still seedlings. This is their 2nd season and they are already twice as big (the leaves I mean) than their first season!! So it is hard to judge them just yet, I think. Sometimes the Fire Island, what is labeled as one, I can see how it got that but other times I am at a loss for how he could have sold it as such? I don't know? I care more that it is healthy and beautiful, though, than I do a label. Thank you for understanding and the complements!

  • 13 years ago

    Of course you can love them w/o the proper names attached. I have a few of those too. But you really shouldn't refer to them with their registered name when there are clearly not said hosta. They don't come true from seeds. You cannot grow seed from a hybrid plant and get the same plant. "Pineapple Upside Cake" is a medium sized hosta with leaves and form that are very different from a small narrow leafed "Curly Fries". The names are not interchangeable. One is a seedling of the other, but there is different parentage. So, for example, you can happily name one "Seedling of PUD" but it will never be PUD.

    I've grown Fire and Ice for years, and it never has green centers in the new growth. You may have something very special there, but it isn't Fire and Ice. Here is mine still unfurling today.

    -Babka

    {{gwi:974316}}

  • 13 years ago

    Well, you have some pretty hosta, Brandy, and knowing what you like is making it easy to choose your plants. Just watch out for the day you start wanting a hosta because of it's NAME.

    Yeah, I must admit that in the beginning I bought a lot because I liked the names. Such as Jaws, Scallion Pancakes, Sharp-Dressed Man, Beet Salad, Purple Lady Fingers, The Razor's Edge, Stained Glass, Brother Stefan, Eskimo Pie, and on and on, until I found myself with about (I think I forgot to count some) 325 separate named hosta. :)

    Watch out, the hosta mania can sneak up on you!
    With that caution, welcome to the forum!

  • 13 years ago

    Blue mouse ears today

    This post was edited by Brandys_garden on Wed, Apr 17, 13 at 0:48

  • 13 years ago

    Moccasinlanding, thank you, I appereciate it. I doubt names and labels will be important to me. I had a chance to get a Liberty and a Patrieot, I can't remember the other one but it had a cool name, too.... But when I saw them, I was disappointed. Cool name, not very unique hosta imo. So I didn't even look at the Wheee's name or the pineapple upside down cakes. I just thought they were cool looking. As with what I was told was a fire island. I got it because of the yellow leaves and red stems and it was different from my others. It is important to remember that my seedlings are still considered seedlings. So they are not fully grown or at full glory so it it hard to critique them just yet.

    Another thing I've noticed is that with my albo, it seems to look a little different every year so far. Just like with the seedlings (granted they aren't full grown yet and neither is my albo I guess) but they look different every season. Has anyone else noticed this, too? Or is it just me?

  • 13 years ago

    Slow down there Brandysgarden! You are obviously a new hosta gardener. We are trying to help you learn about them. Won't you please let us help you? I don't understand your objections. This is a public forum and you posted a photo and we all get to comment. After all, that is why you posted your photo. If comments you don't agree with cause you grief, don't post. Opinions are not harrassment, and you don't get to pick who responds to your posts.

    Almosthoooked ( who has never been rude a post that I can recall) clearly said that her Fire and Ice looked like the photo I posted. Then she talked about her Patriot and THAT was the lovely photo she posted.

    Heed your own words... PAY ATTENTION. Sleep on it and see how you feel in the morning. ;-)

    -Babka

  • 13 years ago

    BK I do understand your point of view. I was not angry with you. I posted so people so people could see and appereciate my hostas. I think they are beautiful and all different and cool. I did not ask to be questioned on labels. And I'm hit with "well that's not a PUD or a Fire Island or a Wheee. You can't call them by false names!" To me, I'm like "what the heck?" What does it matter is my question? And I did my research. I am very happy with my hostas. I will call them with what I believe them to be. As for the Fire Island, I just call it that because I don't have another name for it and it helps me explain it to people. If you don't like it, this is your issue, not mine. I understand how public forums work, believe me. There are always certain people that believe they are right and have to prove it all costs and then blame others when they don't agree with their point of view. As for Almosthooked, they know why I was offended. It was not because of the picture. They deleted it before you could see, I'm sure. It doesn't matter. It's my hosta garden. I think it's beautiful and I did not ask to be questioned on labels. If you wish to do so, speculate yourself privately. I will listen and would love to learn more but you are missing my point entirely. I don't care about labels. I care more about keeping my hostas thriving and beautiful. If I have questions, I will ask and would love input but labels and things I do not ask about.... Well, I don't see the point in going round and round about it. It isn't important to me. It's important to you, I get that. And I appereciate it. But I don't need it shoved on me over and over. What difference does it make really if I misname my fire island or mama mia or whatever? It's not yours, it's mine. My mama mia or whatever today.... See GREEN edges, not cream or white. Still pretty, though! And it does say it's a hybrid on the label. Does that make a difference you said before?

  • 13 years ago

    I've not considered it from this point of view before, but now I realize that the name of a hosta is the common denominator for every bit of advice that is offered on this forum. If someone needs help with a specific hosta, one which they are having a problem locating in their garden, it is not performing as expected, whatever the issue, the first bit of information required to have a discussion is.......which hosta are you talking about.

    So it is fine to like your hosta in the garden because they look pretty, satisfy your need to grow things, and call each one Tom, Dick, or Harry. But if you begin to wonder why your Elegans, for instance, is not looking magnificent as Ludisia's Elegans, then you may begin to realize that yours might be another hosta. It isn't important at all, until you begin to ask questions, at which time, identity is required.

    One of the recurring themes on our forum involves knowing the name, and going forward from there. The knowledge of specific hosta behavior is a great storehouse made available to everyone who comes and asks for help, for information, or just to share what they've learned over the years. I'd sure be nowhere at all if I did not have this forum to ask when I get confused.

    My very first mail order for hosta were all healthy plants, but three of them were apparently not what I'd bought. I kept trying to make them fit what I expected them to do, and it did not work. It was confusing to me. I have a couple now which may be different than the name tag, turning into a miniature instead of a medium, or totally green when I expected it to have a gold middle. Let's just say that as I've gained experience, I can appreciate knowing one plant from another.

  • 13 years ago

    Brandy, welcome!
    The very easiest way in finding out size, leaves, flowers, light requirements, etc. of a certain named hosta should look like is to go to the Hostalibrary.org and review it there. 4 years ago I looked through the whole Hosta Library to find out what I actually got after 20 years of growing 35 different hostas. Now I have 200 different ones and know their data.
    There is another world of hosta growing, called Hybridizing, and for the people of the Hosta Seed Growers Forum, correct names and data of hosta is very important.
    Good luck!
    Bernd

  • 13 years ago

    So I called the guy I got the hostas from and I asked him if he has anything neat to show me, he said he'd send pics. I'll add maybe one more this year. I told him you guys question his Fire Island and Fire and Ice especially. He told me he's not surprised. He claims about 75% of hostas are misnamed and most aren't even misnamed they just come out not looking at all like the parent plant. It's a wierd phenomenon! Like I know with biology you can predict what flowers will look like based on the parent plants... I guess it's not like this with hostas? Anyway, all the seedlings look completely different from last year but they are still growing. I just didn't expect that much of a change in all! And the hybrid (it says so on the label) Mama Mia is completely light green edged. No white or cream edges this year. That's strange to me, too. I thought perhaps it was 2 hostas put together? Maybe so? And it was given to me in poor condition and it took a lot of care to get it back to reasonable health, so maybe only one of the plants made it? I don't know? It doesn't matter to me. I just enjoy caring for them and I love that everyone loves my garden the best and comes by to admire it.

    I realize it's very important to name and label to some but to me it is not. I am not going to show them or whatever. They are just for my personal enjoyment. I hope others can enjoy them, too. But if you feel the need to label and critique them, I only ask that you be respectful and realize it is not important to me.

    As for the light requirements... The big oak tree provides plenty of shade all day long. They only get morning sun and only up until about noon, even during the summer. It is so shady that even grass doesn't grow on that side (though this is partly due to the rocks and gravel, too.) I water them during the summer 2-3 times a week.

    They are well cared for, I assure you!