Software
Houzz Logo Print
paul_in_mn

Frost Damage A Week Later

16 years ago

It's been over a week since we had frost or near frost temps - and some of the damage was slow to appear - noticed these leaves yesterday. Morning dew really highlighted the damage. Frances Williams usually good for me was also affected. I have Yellow Waxbells in two locations - one hit hard and the other untouched. I'm sure I have more that will show soon. Didn't cover - impossible task. How did you fare?

{{gwi:986138}}

{{gwi:986139}}

{{gwi:986140}}

Paul

Comments (14)

  • 16 years ago

    So frost damage can look like HVX? I was wondering about that. Someone recently posted a picture of a Sum and Substance and I thought it was more frost damage maybe.

  • 16 years ago

    Will someone who knows more than us please weigh in on this? It does look a lot like what I thought HVX looked like. What DOES frost damage look like, if this isn't it?

  • 16 years ago

    Pics above I noted that dew helped highlight the damage. Here's another set of pictures - dry. HVX in plants I've seen tends to still be green and growing - although slower or collapsed or distorted. Pretty clear in below pics that tissue is dead lost all green. Included AHS HVX link below.
    {{gwi:986141}}

    {{gwi:986142}}

    {{gwi:986143}}

    {{gwi:986144}}

    Paul

    Here is a link that might be useful: AHS Hosta Virus X Photos

  • 16 years ago

    So frost damage can look like HVX? I was wondering about that.

    =============>>>> i have been saying that for years ... but all you peeps want to do.. is dig them up and throw them away ... perhaps a reason to buy more ...

    i just dont understand.. how when they arent even fully leafed out.. and not even properly colored up ... here in the great white north ... you can diagnose HVX while RULING OUT FROST OR FREEZE ...

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    I can tell a difference between frost damage and HVX.
    Frost damage, over time... weeks... turns the tissue translucent. HVX is more like ink bleed.

    I DID cover nearly everything and even the some of the covered ones got frost burnt. Parhelion took on some damage in a pretty big way.

  • 16 years ago

    Oh, Paul, that's so sad.

    Monday morning, I was shocked to see what looked like HVX on Brother Stefan. (Shocked because it came from a venerated local nursery, where I know they are extraordinarily careful of their stock.) I got the shovel, bleach bucket, newspaper and a container for disposal. When I took a close look in the afternoon light I realized it was frost damaged, not virused. It was covered for the late frost. It's just a baby, and the damage could have happened on any of a number of cold nights, since they emerged so early. Frances Williams, though covered, also has some light frost damage, I think.

  • 16 years ago

    I no longer worry about HVX, damage due to excessive heat, slugs and nematodes. My focus now is damage due to 3 frost nights in 4 days 10 days ago to the early plants. Luckily only perhaps 10% of my hostas show damage. Mostly hostas in the open got affected. The most startling are my 10 or so Blue Cadet which have the upper leaves turned white. All of my 4 or so Francis Williams show the effect of too much sun, but this time some margins were zinged by frost. One yellow/ chartreuse one has dark green veins now. An American Halo got all leaves mushed or wilting, but has fresh new growth coming up. Some white ones got changed : Ivory Coast and Sea Thunder have distorted leaves, Dancing in the rain and Eskimo Pie have stalled growing (but have roots). One Great Expectations has distorted leaves, the other is beautiful.

    Interestingly the basic green and yellow old-varieties were not affected by the frost, but were leaved out. Some of my dwarf conifers (picea, taxus) got fresh growth browned by the frost.

    The other apparent problem I have here in my garden is voles / mice. Several hostas seemed to not grow well, seem to have fairy ring, but when dug up have no roots. I provided pellets into any mouse hole I could see, but there were no holes in the vicinity of these plants.

    Have a good one!
    Bernd

  • 16 years ago

    The front side of my frozen leaves look like this, but the underside of the leaves were all dark, like a frozen lettuce leaf. The frozen leaves on my plants are droopy, I don't think those with HVX droop.
    Pam

  • 16 years ago

    Well in my defense the first pics do seem to look like typical HVX(to my very UN-trained eye)the angle and lighting of the camera doesn't help.

    I thought in the spring you didn't really think about HVX, just blamed most things on slugs and frost damage until the new Leaves came out later in the spring when there was no threat of frost damage. But with some posts popping up about it and the fact that I still don't know nearly enough, I was starting to doubt my judgment.

    I am easily rattled about things I don't know. Say anything about animals and I am pretty sure of most of my abilities, but gardening is still fairly new territory for me. I am very unsure about things. I also don't have any Hosta resources except for one about 500 miles away. There for even the smallest question is most likely going to be asked here. My mom has a black thumb and hates Hostas and she is the only person I know of that is willing to listen to my incessant babbling. So this is pretty much it for my learning.

  • 16 years ago

    I have one that looks like the pictures, but it does every year. I may throw it this year...UGLY. It is not HVX. I keep hoping it will grow out of its sensitivity, but I am giving up. Interesting enough my mother in laws patch five hours south of me got more damage. My tree cover saved the day!

  • 16 years ago

    I just commented on my thread "Snow!!!!!!" that I too am noticing damage over a week after the frost. But my damaged leaves turned white and limp. They don't look anything likes yours Paul.

  • 16 years ago

    Teresa, I think your temps may have been colder than Paul's.
    Last year, we froze harder and mine turned white and then to mush. This year, not as cold and they looked like Paul's.
    Now, they are turning kind of a gray color and limp.
    The buds on the iris froze and the new growth on the rose of
    sharon froze too.
    Pam

  • 16 years ago

    Paul, Thanks for this post. I live north of you in WBL and noticed after the frost that only my Endless Summer Hydrangeas had some brown leaves on them. Today I noticed that my Gold Edger border nearby had a lot of white leaves on them. I didn't read this post until dark but am anxious to get out tomorrow and take a more careful look at the rest of the yard. Does one pull off those white leaves or just let them sit and see how they look later? I have never seen this happen before in the 20 years I've had Hosta. Next time frost is forecast, I will be more alert to the damage that can happen and what areas of my yard are vulnerable. Mary

  • 16 years ago

    I dipped below 20 degrees about 10 days ago. Leaves were nearly fully out. Lots of very sad leaves this year. This year was the worst.

    It happens here most years. I should invest in some floating row covers.