Software
Houzz Logo Print
onewebfoot

Tomato Nutrient Compatibility (with other veggies)

21 years ago

Greetings. This is my first post in this forum (I'm somewhat active in the Citrus group, which is also a high quality forum). I've been reading much here for at least 6 months, and appreciate and admire this group's accommodating, helpful, open-minded, innovative and expert atmosphere.

I'm still a hydroponic newbie, but have grown two crops of outdoor hydroponic tomatoes in a GH waterfarm drip ring system (5 square bucket modules, plus controller). I set it all in full sun on the back patio and shade the reservoir, controller and buckets with painter's drop cloths.

This year, I will probably grow tomatoes and compatible veggies in a yet-to-be-built, larger ebb and flow system (using the GH waterfarm system for ornamentals instead). Solution in the E&F system will not be shared with the waterfarm system. I also own Resh's "Hydroponic Tomatoes" book but have yet to read most of it. I do like the customized drip system that he illustrates on pages 36-37, but he doesn't discuss much about drip ring systems in Chapter 1 (which I've read).

Anyway, would anyone know about either of these two topics below? My humble thanks in advance for any comments.

-- Which other garden vegetables would be most compatible with nutients mixed for tomatoes?

-- Does anyone know the specific brand of water level controller that is used in a system like either of the two below? Otherwise, I might get just the multiflow controller then find a water drum from a survival supply store, and whatever free nesting buckets I can get my hands on. I'm planning to set up about 8 grow "buckets" rather than the retail set of 12 for vegetables, and tomatoes would share solution with whatever other plants I grow in this specific system. Thanks again for any pointers or links that you might have. I hope to post some pics of young plants by March to reciprocate, if possible.

Greentrees Multiflow System

Ebb & Gro System

Comments (13)

  • 21 years ago

    Hello again. To answer my first question above (kind of), I found a couple of lists for companion vegetables, and thought I would pass them along, but these analyses are for soil. I don't know how well these would apply to any hydroponic environment, but these will probably influence my thinking unless someone here has better advice:

    -- Companion Vegetable Gardening
    -- Vegetable Companion Chart
    -- Companion Planting (herb and spice emphasis)

    Based on piecemeal comments from other threads and web pages, it appears that I could grow a variety of vegetables with tomatoes in the same hydroponic system. I also gather that tomatoes don't really like to be grown with cabbage, broccoli, or cauliflower. It also appears that onions offend several other veggy types, though tomatoes and onions seem to get along fine. I'm still working out the E&F system design details. After another day of thought, the existing waterfarm system will probably hold herbs and/or onions (not ornamentals), and the larger home-built ebb and flo system (fill-and-drain) would hold tomatoes and documentably compatible veggies. Thanks for further comments if anyone has any.

  • 21 years ago

    Some of the companion guides are meant for problems related to growing in soil rather than hydro. Some companion plants are suggested to help avoid certain pests, & others to improve taste (i.e., borage & tomatoes).

    I do not know what you are considering growing. There are different pH & ppm ranges for different plants, but it may not be a problem if the ranges are not too different. The size of your plants may also affect your selection.

    Here is a related thread:

    http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/hydro/msg1122321328773.html

  • 21 years ago

    Thank you for the response and link. I guess I only had two questions rather than two dozen (grins). I had nagging doubts in my mind about soil-based compatibility charts (companion crop charts) also. So after 2-3 more hours of looking around, I found a bit more information. I hope these links are helpful to someone.

    -- Hydroponics Online (dot com), Lesson 6-5.
    Here is a sample of their info (in simplified format). This is just what they recommend (not necessarily what I would suggest):

    Veggie.....Like needs with.....Rec. System.....Rec. Media
    ------------------------------------------------------
    Basil......Lettuce/Spinach.....Not listed......Not listed
    Cucumber...Tomato/Pepper.......Drip System.....Perlite/Rockwool
    Lettuce....Basil, Leaf crops...NFT,E&F,Drip....Not listed
    Tomato.....Cucumbers/Peppers...Drip or any.....Not listed

    For EC and PH information, I found two additional sources specifically for hydroponics:

    -- Bluelabs Nominal EC Values for Hydroponics
    -- Vegetable pH/PPM/cF chart for Hydroponic Gardeners

    I'm still working out one system design and companion plant choices for both systems.
    -- System #1 (Waterfarm drip ring) will probably hold lettuce, radishes, and one cucumber plant.
    -- System #2 (a custom multiflow system 95% designed in my mind) will probably hold tomatoes, peppers, and two ebb and flow trays of herbs and onions (trays to be set in conjunction with multiflow controller and other bucket-style pots)

    I can report that cucumbers (which I have grown once) liked a waterfarm drip system just fine with hydroton media, and that my tomato plants liked the same system but grew invasive roots in it. I'm not even sure a 2-gallon multiflow style pot would hold a tomato plant without having to trim the roots occasionally. Thanks again for your comments and link.

  • 21 years ago

    I have grown lettuce, basil, lovage, mint & Rosemary in the same system, & all did OK except the lovage. Lovage can get big, so space is a consideration. I have also tried to grow radishes in the same system, but they seem to prefer a more acidic pH. I have also started growing marjoram this year, & it seems to like an alkaline pH. I am still experimenting, however.

    One of the above links suggests Ruda as a companion plant, but I would not put it in the same system because of its smell. Borage may affect the flavor of your other plants  it is supposed to give tomatoes a cucumber taste. If you are planting it with tomatoes, you might want to experiment with a single pot. Borage does not like transplanting, so I would not move it around too much. Gopher purge, mentioned in the above sites does quite well in hydro - I accidentally planted one once. ItÂs planted in the soil, of course, but hydro is a good method of propagation. An herb not mentioned is Vietnamese Coriander (Polygonum odoratum Lour.). It also does very well in hydro & is easy to grow. Chervil seems to be very slow growing in soil  I do not know how well it would do in hydro.

    There seems to be discrepancy between the sites in terms of EC & ppm values for different crops on the above sites & they do not cite their source. They are a guide, however. There is a thread that relates pepper ppm below:

    http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/hydro/msg052315176563.html

    The University of Arizona recommends a pH of 5.5-6.0 for tomatoes.

    http://ag.arizona.edu/hydroponictomatoes/nutritio.htm

    Southern CA has its own unique climate considerations which can affect outdoor hydro growing. You can probably get 3 growing seasons out of your plants. My soil based tomatoes started fruiting in January. Although determinate tomatoes are not supposed to last, mine fruited twice last year. I could have over wintered them had I not cut them down. I found the tree tomatoes did not do well during the hot periods of summer  I have had to move them to the shade. The Santa Ana winds can also quickly dry out & destroy seedlings. I am experimenting with gravel as a media this year simply because of the wind storms.

    There a couple of books you can probably find in your library you might find useful.
    Suzanne AshworthÂs book on seed saving provides information on pollination. The "Carrots Love Tomatoes" book provides some useful companion planting tips.

  • 21 years ago

    Baci, thank you for another very informative and thoughtful reaction to my ramblings. :-) Your responses have and will definitely influence me for the better. I saved this thread on my system for frequent future reference. I'm trying to populate a spreadsheet of information for veggies and herbs (pH, cF, EC, PPM, etc.) because no single source has ever had all the info I wanted. :-) But I wouldn't be aspiring to more hydro if I didn't enjoy reading. :-)

    As you know, we're wrapping up yet another Santa Ana wind condition now in SoCal. I'm thinking about anti-dust tactics for these two outdoor systems (both are still under construction or design). But your comments about SoCal tomatoes (in hot summer) leads me to modify a pending framework over which I can drape window screen for some minor sun and temperature reduction on the hottest days. I might need this feature for both systems, but that's another decision to make in coming days. Thanks again - very much. -Vince

  • 21 years ago

    Good luck; I have learned from your posts also. Increasing the root oxygen may also help with the tree tomatoes. If you come up with any dust tips please share them. Besides the dust, the ash storms from wildfires are another factor. Last year when there were ash storms, I shut down my hydro, & just kept the plants wet. I cleaned the pumps afterwards & fortunately they are still running.

  • 21 years ago

    What do you think of growing tomatoes, sweet peppers and basil in the same system ?
    Rgds, Chefmichel

  • 21 years ago

    Chefmichel, based merely on a relative newbie's (my) research, i would be optimistic about that specific combination. But please note the reasons for my optimism, in case it is misplaced. The profile for tomatoes (accounting for pH, eC, etc. etc.) seems very compatible with Basil. Though I haven't nailed down the profile for sweet peppers, peppers are known to be compatible with onions, and onions have a very similar profile to tomatoes. Therefore, peppers might have a profile similar to tomatoes and basil also, making all three compatible in the same system (in theory).

    Given that no single source comes close to the kind of charts I wanted, I researched the charts linked below from 4 sources. I post this non-copyrighted information boldly because (1) i cite the sources at the top, and (2) none of these sources comes remotely close to my approach or my completion level, and no single source can claim to have provided the bulk of this information.

    Please note that SEVERAL comments in these charts were added from Baci's comments (in this and other threads). I hope this is helpful. This took several hours to develop.

    Hydroponic Plant Profiles Consolidated by onewebfoot for non-proprietary use

  • 21 years ago

    First-time-poster, Long-time-reader

    >There seems to be discrepancy between the sites in terms of
    >EC & ppm values for different crops on the above sites &
    >they do not cite their source. They are a guide, however.
    >There is a thread that relates pepper ppm below"

    Baci - Aren't PPM & TDS converted from an eC reading? Different meters can give different readings on the same solution as a result of the algorithm chosen by the manufacturer.

  • 21 years ago

    You are correct, kpkratz - different manufacturers may use different conversion factors, which can result in different readings. To avoid this, a standard conversion factor of 0.64 is recommended.

  • 20 years ago

    If you were to grow tomatoes and basil in the same system, wouldn't both plants start to flower when the nutrient solution was changed from Grow to Bloom? I would assume that any leaf herb grown should be grown with Grow nutrient solution to decrease flowering, never Bloom (unless the herb is grown for its flowers, such as chamomile).

  • 20 years ago

    fraxer - thanks for pointing this out (and "bumping" an 11-month dormant thread). :-) i worked this both ways last summer - kept plants in shared system for vegging (and moving out basil for flowering of tomatoes), or flowered basil with the tomatoes. got and dried lots of basil leaves both ways, and then I moved on to other veggies and various combos. no disasters thus far, but fruiting veggies best without sametime foliage herbs. opint observed and taken.

    I have some strawberry plants right now (alone), with nice berries, but I have to modify entire patio system against rats (or whatever is taking my berries). about done. regards.

Sponsored