Software
Houzz Logo Print
donnaz5

Do all Beans hybridize with each other?

13 years ago

I am going to grow some heirlooms this spring, tepary, speckled christmas lima, and a purple yard long...
I would like to save seed from each variety for the next season...

Will they all cross pollinate with each other?
If they will..then how far apart will I need to plant them so this doesn't happen?
I know that I can plant the yard long pole beans way far away because I plan to grow sunflowers and have the beans climb on them...so they are really not so much of a problem...more the other two. My garden is only about 30 feet long...anybody have any ideas on this?

Comments (5)

  • 13 years ago

    Tepary beans, limas, and yard longs are all different species, and will not cross. You can grow them side-by-side & still get pure seed.

    Each could possibly cross with others of the same species, if they were nearby. Teparies are adapted to hot desert climates, and are not commonly grown in the North... so it is unlikely that anyone near you is growing them. Yard longs are are botanically cowpeas, and could possibly cross with yard longs / cowpeas grown by your neighbors... but this too is unlikely.

    Limas are another story. Their blossoms are very attractive to bees, and if one of your neighbors is also growing limas, a cross or two is possible. My rural garden is over 1/4 mile from any other gardens, and I got a lima cross one year.

    One note regarding tepary beans. Some of the varieties in circulation carry bean common mosaic virus (BCMV). Until you know if your stock is infected, I would recommend planting them some distance from your other beans as a safety precaution.

  • 13 years ago

    I grow the white wood aster and the mexican petunia to decoy the bees from the limas,cowpeas and yarlongs
    I never see bees on them while the flowers are blooming
    I only save seeds from those blooming the same time as the asters

  • 13 years ago

    zeedman...thank you for the info...you said you got a cross one year...how did you know that, other than planting the next spring and finding out, is there a different way to know?

  • 13 years ago

    Unfortunately, if a bean cross does occur, it will not be visible in the seed from that year. All of the dry seed - including any crosses - will look like the original seed. Only when the seed is planted, in the F2 generation, will any differences become apparent.

    The lima cross introduced white seed patterns which were not present in the original seed, and were atypical for the variety. The plant with the white seed was also shorter in comparison to others in the row; had I been more observant of this, I would have destroyed the plant before it bloomed. I had considered a cross unlikely, since limas are not that widely grown here... but the traits of the variant suggest a possible cross with "Henderson's", or a similar bush lima.

  • 13 years ago

    I wonder if I got a cross with my BJBBS's ?

    I am trying to keep the seed pure by planting my other Lima beans, speckled butter beans, at least 200' away. I did notice some different colors this year. Some were pure white and some were white with red streaks.

    The only other garden around here is 2/10th's of a mile away.

    I saved only the black seeds for planting this spring.