Software
Houzz Logo Print
calm1_gw

Sawdust beans

12 years ago

Hello everyone,
Question is most folks on the mulch forum are against using sawdust-wood shavings because it depletes nitrogen from the soil. I'm thinking that because beans "absorb" nitrogen & affix it to the roots, perfect spot to use up a bunch of shavings & sawdust as a mulch. Make any sense?
Thanks
Ed

Comments (6)

  • 12 years ago

    Ed don't do it. My friend used horse manure with wood shavings mixed with the manure. His garden vegetables were a pale yellow even after adding Ammonium Nitrate. It took several years to get his soil back to normal.

    If it works don't fix it.

    Luther

  • 12 years ago

    Ditto. I wouldn't use sawdust unless it had been composted.

  • 12 years ago

    Ok not to sideline this thread...but I am curious, as the leaves fell over the winter. I raked and piled them on my garden over the winter to enrich the soil for future springtime. After all heck it's free right.?? I have a ton of oak, and poplar leaves piled up at least a foot deep in some spots.

    Anyhow with a break in the weather earlier last month, I roto-tilled most of them in. I plan on doing that again as soon as the soil is once again workable.
    Anyhow my question is should I add ammonium sulfate to the area to counter act any nitrogen depletion that may occur?? If so I am curious as too how much? My gardening area will be approximately 16'x50'

    My main crop for the area will be bush beans, squash, pole beans and a few tomato's of course. I just wanted to chime in and say I have been reading all of the posts here for quite sometime now and have thoroughly enjoyed them!

    As you might be able to tell I have been thoroughly bitten by the bean affliction that is running around on this forum !! Great forum here ... Thanks for any words of wisdom and advice as well.

  • 12 years ago

    Ok not to sideline this thread...but I am curious, as the leaves fell over the winter. I raked and piled them on my garden over the winter to enrich the soil for future springtime. After all heck it's free right.?? I have a ton of oak, and poplar leaves piled up at least a foot deep in some spots.

    Anyhow with a break in the weather earlier last month, I roto-tilled most of them in. I plan on doing that again as soon as the soil is once again workable.
    Anyhow my question is should I add ammonium sulfate to the area to counter act any nitrogen depletion that may occur?? If so I am curious as too how much? My gardening area will be approximately 16'x50'

    My main crop for the area will be bush beans, squash, pole beans and a few tomato's of course. I just wanted to chime in and say I have been reading all of the posts here for quite sometime now and have thoroughly enjoyed them!

    As you might be able to tell I have been thoroughly bitten by the bean affliction that is running around on this forum !! Great forum here ... Thanks for any words of wisdom and advice as well.

  • 12 years ago

    I use composted wood chips including bark and it works great.

  • 12 years ago

    When You till the leaves in over the winter months they get composted. Google how to compost, then you will understand how to decompose carbon material.

    Luther