Software
Houzz Logo Print
pondluvr

Puckering in Hosta

16 years ago

Okay, I'm sure I'm just paranoid about HVX because most of my hosta came from my dear, 93-year-old grandpa (and my love for hosta too).

Long story short, I have moved all of my hosta to containers as of least year. They overwintered fine (I was holding my breath). Out of 24, I only lost 3 to some sort of rot. They are all doing great in the pots. However, quite a few of them have puckering on the leaves. They are all different, and I'm pretty sure not all of the ones that have puckering are "supposed" to, as in that is not a trait common to that variety. They are all very close together, and the leaves do touch. I have not been cutting, bruising, or any other invasive thing to them. But the puckers concern me. They do not have the color problems associated with HVX, nor do they have any tissue damage or breakdown. Just puckers on many of them which I doubt should really be there.

Any of you experts want to chime in? What causes puckering on varieties which normally should not have any? I am no expert, but I am always reading to try and learn more. I could not find much info about puckers, except for that everybody wants hosta varieties that are "puckery". :o)

Thanks for any info, and if you can put my mind to ease, that would be great. I could take photos if necessary, but honestly, the puckering is the only symptom.

Sandy

Comments (21)

  • 16 years ago

    You need to post a pic.

  • 16 years ago

    Sandy, I'm no expert, but I had a Patriot that I had gotten from my sister five years ago. This year, all the leaves unfurled very puckered. I know this is not a Patriot trait, so I looked very closely at the leaves. Sure enough, several of them (but not all) exhibited some tissue breakdown. There was no sign of inkbleed. I checked for HVX with my Agdia test strips and sure enough, it tested positive for HVX. With a heavy heart, I dug it up and tossed it. Sorry, Sis.

    Leaf detail showing puckering. Tissue breakdown doesn't show on this leaf. I couldn't capture the breakdown well.

    It was a lovely plant.

  • 16 years ago

    i answered in your other post.. link below ...

    patriot is one of the most puckered hosta in my mind.. refer to the hosta library ...

    i see no ink bleed in the pix above [noted what you said].. i see cleandon streaking.. or a 3rd color where the two color layers overlap creating a grey ....

    i am sorry .. but paranoia reigns.. and i am sure chris will differ.. but if you are going to throw away every maturing hosta that shows puckering.. you may as well cut down the trees and go back to daylily ...

    i would pay postage .. for a patriot like that ... let me know next time.. before you chuck one ...

    time to get a camera and post some pix ...

    good luck

    ken

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 16 years ago

    Ken... not to question your authority...not saying the puckering is HVX... but her test strips showed positive for HVX... are test strips sometimes wrong?

  • 16 years ago

    ABSOLUTELY ... and not 100% correct either ...

    and i claim no EXPERTISE in HVX ... just opinion .... the expert is chris ... and if i am wrong.. he will correct me ... but probably not change my mind.. lol ...

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Just to clarify. I am not suggesting that all puckering in hosta is a symptom of HVX. And I am not paranoid. I have tested five hosta in three years, and I have over two hundred. When I see a hosta that looks unusual, I look it over carefully. Two years ago, my Summer Music displayed distorted, puckered leaves and the classic inkbleed symptoms. I did not automatically throw it out; I tested, and the results were positive. Then I tossed it out.

    The excessive puckering was what caused to me to look closely at Patriot and to then find the tissue breakdown. Unfortunately, I was not able to get a good photo of the tissue breakdown, but there are websites that do show many hosta with this symptom.

    I am using this as a learning experience. I try to be a good steward of my hosta garden and being aware of diseases is part of it. I don't run about testing every hosta, but when a plant displays unusual characteristics, I investigate. Ignoring a problem does not make it go away. Being paranoid is not a solution; being watchful can be helpful.

    Sandy, I'd just be watchful. Educate yourself on HVX, but don't be afraid. When I last bought the Agdia strips, you could buy five for $25. Now I notice that the minimum order is about $75 if I remember correctly. Maybe several people can go together to purchase them. That's what I hope to do. Good luck.

  • 16 years ago

    Wow it sure does seem strange that the particular hosta tested positive for HVX. Makes me wonder if any of us stands any chance of avoiding it...

    also makes me wonder if the test strips are worth using lest they cause general unrest - testing positive if a plant isn't, and testing negative when a plant is. sheesh.

    i probably wouldn't have tested that plant because, like ken says, it just looks so darn gorgeous.

  • 16 years ago

    Candice, I am sure that 100% accuracy cannot be guaranteed by using the test strips. The person conducting the test can make mistakes even if the test itself is infallible, which of course it isn't. I can't remember now the degree of accuracy attributed to the Agdia strips, but as I recall it was quite high.

    I wasn't depending only on the strips. You will recall I said that I detected symptoms that have been shown to indicate HVX. The test only validated my observations.


  • 16 years ago

    I'm sorry,but I see no HVX in that Patriot,despite the puckering,which is a very desirable trait in hostas. I think you threw away a perfectly good hosta! Just MHO,and I'm sticking with it. Many of you here on the forum know that I have several HVX-infected plants. I still have them,and they are not infecting other plants. Maybe the rest of you want to panic when you see a strange leaf on a hosta,and that's your prerogative. The only HVX I ever encountered in 7 years of growing hosta came from bagged hosta,which I don't buy anymore. Phil

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for your comments, Ken and Phil, however I do not agree with you. We all do what we believe to be in our best interests. Vive la difference!

  • 16 years ago

    I also have the HVX paranoia and wonder about anything that puckers! Some of my hosta are over 20 years old and a larger planting that's been in place for years and years is showing no puckering, but the inkbleed symptoms started last year and are now in about a third of the patch! I can't imagine how it could have infected that particulat group as I've had them at least 15 years and transplanted them 9 years ago when we re-landscaped. Do I dig up all of them? Their roots have to be touching because they are close together and I'm fearful that everything will be infected. I think chipmunks have a burrow under them and are spreading it. Any suggestions? I haven't actually tested with the stips but I'm pretty sure it's HVX.

  • 16 years ago

    Phil, what do you mean "bagged hosta?" I don' think I've heard that term.

    Indyrose

  • 16 years ago

    I'm fairly new to this HVX thing, and I am also fairly new to these forums. It seems I unintentionally opened a can of worms here somehow. I want to apologize, and I did not mean to cause a bunch of strife among you all. My hosta are mostly from my grandfather, who is 93. The thought of him not being around much longer and maybe losing all my hosta to HVX is what makes me sad. If they were from Home Depot or even boughten elsewhere, it would not be such a big deal to me. So yes, I am paranoid. I will admit it. Still, I am sorry for bringing it up because it seems like this thread is causing problems.

    I took photos today after it quit raining, but the sun was so bright I think the photos will not do justice to the puckering. I will post them tomorrow, but again, sorry for causing the stir here. I'm not sure what I triggered, but this might not be the place for somebody like me who is DEFINITELY paranoid and not afraid to admit it.

    :o)

    Sandy

  • 16 years ago

    Indyrose,bagged hostas are those bare-root hostas that Lowes,and Wal-Mart sell every year. They come in little green bags,with some peat moss inside. There is a picture on the bag,supposedly showing what the hosta inside will grow into. Sometimes the roots and crown are not even the same as the hosta they are supposed to be. You're much better off to buy hosta in person,in pots,so you can see what you are getting. Just my opinion. Phil

  • 16 years ago

    Hey, don't be hard on yourself, Sandy. It seems many threads about HVX seem to turn this way, everybody has an opinion. It can be a touchy subject. Just read, and learn. *Gives hugs!*

    Karen

  • 16 years ago

    Sandy-

    We love worms here, so opening a can of them gets our juices flowing. No need to apologize. This is a topic that needs to be discussed, as it is a very serious problem. Most puckering (sometimes called "bumples") is very desireable. ;-) Isn't it really called rugrose? It is that ink bleed that mottles a hosta, and the other bumpy deformities that ruin it that are the problem.

    Thank you for your post and especially for the photos, which look just fine to me. You may want to post to the Hallson's HVX forum. Chris is in charge there and he really does know his stuff, and has been watching this epidemic unfold over the last few years.

    -Babka

    Here is a link that might be useful: Hallson's HVX Forum

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks, guys, for the kind words. I never mean to get anybody upset.

    About the pictures though....they are not mine. That was somebody else's response to my original post. I still need to upload my photos for you all to look at.

    Thanks again. I am learning a lot here.

    Sandy

  • 16 years ago

    Sandy-

    Sorry I thought those pics were yours...chemo brain excuses all the dumb things I do...

    Please post some pics so we all can see what the heck you are talking about. We really do need photos to render our most august opinions. And, haha, after all they really are all just opinions. In the end you may do whatever you'd like to do and you can still come back here and post away. ;-)

    -Babka

  • 16 years ago

    That discarded Patriot was a beautiful plant, all evenly puckered. Perhaps you had early frosts? I have two Dancing in the Rain hostas which should not have puckered, but did on some leaves due to being hit last month 3 times in 4 days with frost just below 32 F. I also have 2 plants which show ink bleed on most leaves, but they also were out early and got hit by those frosts. Some hostas had mushy leaves. Other early hostas do not show any effect of those frosts, probably because being hardier cultivars, the local climate was not as cold, etc.

    Therefore, I decided that these cases in my yard are not HVX, give all damaged plants another chance, let them develop healthy leaves in the next months, compare them next year again, be slow on the trigger.
    Good luck!
    Bernd

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for your comments, Ken and Phil, however I do not agree with you. We all do what we believe to be in our best interests. Vive la difference!

    +++>>> absolutely lois.. i dont come here out of a need to argue... i hate such... why i was never any good as an atty ... if you read passion into a reply... its passion for the hosta.. not some attack.. trust me on that ... OK????

    ===>>>

    the original posters first comment was about paranoia .... and i think there is a certain paranoia with some of the newbies here ...

    ==>>> and pondy .. be proud that you posted a post that stimulates discussion ... there is nothing to regret in that situation ....

    the biggest problem in the typed word... and the reading of said typed word.. is interpretation ... lois and i could have the same conversation with an adult beverage next to the fire pit ... and NEVER misunderstand intent ...

    its when we type/read that problems sometimes happen ...

    regardless.. absolutely nothing for you to be concerned about ....

    have fun peeps.. peace out ....

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    I feel the same way as Ken. Just don't panic every time you see a leaf on a hosta that looks different. If I did that,I wouldn't have any hostas left! Stuff happens,debris falls from overhead tree branches,frost damage when leaves are unfurling,slugs,voles,leaf-cutting bees, rabbits,tree sap,I could go on,and on...! I don't like to argue with everyone here on the forum,but we are all entitled to our opinion. If I offended anyone here on the forum,I apologize. Now,lets get back to talking about our favorite plant! Phil