Software
Houzz Logo Print
belindach

Taste Test

19 years ago

I know many of you have grown countless peas and beans over the years. I'd appreciate your input. What varieties do you grow in the black eyed pea family which taste different from one another, same for shellies, limas and green beans?

Comments (2)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well I love all the black eyes and pink eyes etc but they all do taste very similar. I have started growing cream peas because they do have a different and wonderful taste. I have Dixie Butter pea maturing as we speak and am anxious to see how it tastes.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wow... that's a tall order (and it doesn't even include soybeans).

    Others could probably comment better than I on Southern peas & limas. My favorite limas so far are "King of the Garden" and "Hopi Pole" (both pole) and "Fordhook 242" (bush).

    For snaps, there are already several excellent threads on this forum. My favorites would be "Fortex", "Garafal Oro", and "Kentucky Wonder" (all pole).

    As for shell beans... they are my longest-running garden project, and I trial several new ones each year. In this country, only a few companies list varieties for that use, and then only a handful. Most of the varieties that I have found are heirlooms, some of which were intended for other purposes (usually snaps) but also make good shellies.

    - "Bird Egg #3" is a show-stopper for size (at over 1" long) but has a fairly course texture, and potato-like flavor. "Canon City" & "Portugal" are similar in both appearance and flavor, but smaller (smaller is relative - they are still large).
    - "Jembo Polish" has seed nearly as large as "Bird Egg #3" in shell stage, but a finer texture, richer flavor, and more tender skin. Fewer per pod, though, and harder to shell.
    - "Ma Williams" (a.k.a. "Goose" or "Pumpkin Bean", which are similar) has large seeds with a thin skin, fine texture, and rich flavor... one of my favorites. Earlier than most pole shellies, and very high yielding. The ripe pods (which I have photo'd on other threads) are a beautiful rose-pink, and very easy to shell.
    - "King Horticultural" has medium sized, nearly spherical shellies that cook down to white, and have good flavor.
    - "True Red Cranberry" has smaller, nearly spherical seeds, of deep red.
    - "Brita's Foot Long" (white) and "Soissons Vert" (green flageolet) are both roughly the size of "Great Northern", and have the richest flavor & tenderest skin of any beans that I have tested.
    - An unknown Serbian pole wax bean (I hope to eventually obtain the name from the GW source when they next return there) had surprisingly large & tasty shellies, the only wax bean I have found so far that is good for that purpose. The large, fat seed appears to be a bigger version of "Calypso" at first glance, half black,half white.

    Even "Garafal Oro", which I grow as a fine-flavored snap, produces a large crop of sweet shellies if allowed to seed.

    All of those above are pole varieties, but I have found a few good bush or half-runner types as well:

    - One of the biggest surprises this year was a bush variety known only by its USDA number, "PI 507984". It has markings similar to "Jacob's Cattle", but is much larger. The shellies were very good quality; and the plants were vigorous, did not lodge, and bore heavily & early. It shows enormous potential for more widespread cultivation.
    - "Bumblebee" also has very large seed in the shell stage, but I found the skin a little too tough for my liking.
    - "Coco Rubico" is a bush "horticultural" variety, with medium-sized, very fat seeds of good flavor.
    - Two half-runners have proven to be good shellies. "Bert Goodwin" has deep red beans about the size of "Red Kidney", but with speckles. "Brockton Horticultural" is similar to "Canon City", but slightly smaller. Given optimal conditions, either of these can climb & are best given support; but the majority of the crop is borne close to the ground. They might make good cornfield beans... an experiment worth trying.

    There are photos of some of these & more descriptions on the Shell Bean thread.