Software
Houzz Logo Print
thisismelissa

How to bare root?

17 years ago

I know, dumb question...

But, I've tried bare-rooting a hosta before, and stopped short of getting all the potting medium off.

I was spraying with a hose-end sprayer... set on various settings (shower, center, jet) and it seems as if it takes a WHOLE LOT of water.

Am I doing something wrong?

Comments (14)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I won't ask the question WHY the bare root -probably because you want to ship a division I suspect. And yes, it can indeed take a whole lot of water to do that. When I un-potted my Hyacinthina sport clump in June, I wanted to be able to see EXACTLY where to make the cuts and be able to tease as much of the roots apart as possible so that each division would end up with a decent amount of root. This was a 2 gallon pot, pretty full with around 15-16 shoots, and the plant was put into it in 2007. There was a large root system and I bet it took me 10-12 minutes, perhaps even more, of spraying with the jet setting of my spray nozzle to get to a point I was happy with it. The clump was too large to make an attempt at cleaning the potting mix out of the root system by fairly vigorous agitation in a large vessel with water, there would have been too much damage to the leaves by the time it was done. Spraying with a nozzle really was my only option.

    When I find myself where I have to use a spray nozzle for cleaning a root ball I try to find an area that can benefit from some extra watering, making sure the spray doesn't stray straight into the garden, at least the water won't go to waste that way.

    Pieter

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Am I doing something wrong?

    ==========
    yeah .. worrying about it ... throw it on the driveway and run it over a few times.. the soil will fall off ...

    surely some aggressive water work isnt going to do all that much harm.. short of using a power washer ...

    but per the last post... why are you concerned about it ...

    i do recommend removing as much POTTING media when planting... but this is NOT operating room clean ... 90% is good enough..

    just plant the darn thing .... i appreciate the quest for knowledge .... but dont worry about it all ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you have a lot of clay, or the soil is sticking because the roots are thick (a good thing), you can pop it into a bucket of water for a while before spraying the dirt off. This will take off a LOT of the excess dirt and make the spraying technique better.

    Believe it or not, (Ken, I think you'll appreciate this technique) I used to take the dirt off of my Undulata Albomarginata (which I had hundreds of as a result of separating one plant over & over when I was a kid) by holding the leaves in one hand and smacking the root-ball on the ground or against the tree! But then I felt bad for the tree & maybe got a bit more refined. But I never killed a single hosta with that technique. I think a couple of them had to go through therapy, though!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    HILARIOUS ...

    the tree method ... been there.. done that ...

    banyai told me to do it.. that by threatening its life you trigger release of growth hormones ... and the things actually become more aggressive ....

    if you ever have one that's struggling.. dig it up.. and either.. scrape the roots on the sidewalk/driveway ... or beat it on a tree ..

    replant.. try to drown it.. etc

    ken

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hostas are MY BABIES !!! LOL And yes I have done all of the above to get dirt off the roots. It all depends on whether you paid big bucks for it or you are just dividing an old faithful.

    Connie

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    holy cow, and Ken thought the hostas were getting stressed IN the mail! Run over them in the drive way, beat them against a tree, turn the fire hose on them! Ok, who has actually waterboarded them?
    Pam

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    CAREFULL!!!

    This thread has now come to the attention of the National Security Agency (NSA) due to the reference to waterboarding.

    The NSA has never waterboarded hostas, Cheney did not approve it, and they won't do it again...

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    and yes, I frequently use the "beat the root ball on the ground" technique. I want to leave as much soil at the spot in the garden where I'm removing the plant...

    But I don't think Melissa's question is out of line. I do try to clean my plants pretty well before I mail them, both to save weight in shipping and to make the recipient feel more secure that I'm not sending them soil that might have fungi, nematodes, and other bad stuff... and I too have been struck by how long I can stand over the root ball with a hose.

    I think the suggestion about putting them in a bucket of water is the answer. The soaking before spraying does, indeed, save a bunch of water.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Then again, if there's hosta cooties in the dirt, it's also probably gonna be IN the hosta that's being received, so what is the problem with receiving a hosta with some dirt on it. On the other hand, maybe getting rid of slugs would be good, especially for a recipient like me, who has little to no problems with the little buggers... especially this summer, with the autumn-like temperatures!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay, what is wrong with you people? Beating a hosta against a tree? That's the most outrageous thing I've heard in ages! What EXACTLY do you think the handle of your shovel or garden fork is for??? Why bother to walk all the way to the nearest tree? Just whack the root clump against the shovel handle until the majority of the dirt drops off and then move on.

    Seriously, though, I have, over the course of about 30 years of digging and dividing hostas, come up with a method that works well for me. First, I don't use a shovel to dig hostas. On really large varieties, I will use a shovel to cut the roots out at about the perimeter of the leaves, working my way around the hosta and simply driving the shovel 8 or 10 inches into the dirt. You will hear little snick snick noises as the roots are cut. Don't worry about this--unless you were planning to dig a new hole at least 4 feet in diameter to replant the huge hosta, you won't have room for those extra roots anyway on a large plant. Most large hostas have the majority of their roots growing within the area covered by the leaves. The exception is very upright hostas, and with those you can start out a little further than the area the leaves cover.

    Once the roots are cut, I switch to a heavy duty garden fork and start about 10 to 12 inches out from the base of the hosta, further if I'm digging out a real giant. I stick the fork in the ground and pry gently, working my way around the plant. Once the soil is loosened, I start to work in towards the plant. This method allows almost all of the roots to work their way loose from the soil without damage. Once everything is loose, I put the fork at an angle under the crown and gradually pry the hosta out, switching sides as needed.

    With medium hostas, I usually skip the shovel altogether, because the root system is smaller, the individual roots are much thinner, and the root pruning isn't necessary. Start with the fork about 10 inches from the crown of a medium hosta, and gently pry all the way around the plant to loosen the roots. Then put the fork right next to the base of the plant and pry it out. If it doesn't come out easily, work around the plant and loosen the roots a bit more. Most mediums will pop out very easily. Small hostas are really easy--I loosen the soil on one or two sides, depending on the width of the clump, then pop the plant out by putting the garden fork under the crown and lifting. Minis I dig with a trowel, sticking the trowel at a slight angle into the dirt about 3 inches from the base of the plant, then prying carefully. If the hosta doesn't pop right out, try the same thing from another side of the plant.

    With this method many hostas will come out of the ground with very little dirt still attached. Medium and small varieties will often pop right out with the dirt almost completely gone and the roots completely intact. If there is still some dirt attached, I will gently (repeat, gently) tap the plant on the ground a couple of times, lifting it by the root ball, or gently swing the root mass into the handle of my garden fork. Then I turn the plant upside down and gently shake it from side to side. The reason for turning the plant so the leaves are pointing down is that otherwise this shaking can break petioles. Once inverted, the leaves aren't nearly as prone to breakage. This not only gets rid of any excess dirt on the roots, it also gets rid of all the loose stuff that may have been collecting at ground level--leaves, twigs, mulch, and other detritus. And if you are really lucky, most of the spiders and other wildlife will exit, too.

    On dry days this gets all the dirt out of the root mass, and the hosta is then quite easy to divide. On days when the soil is wet, there will be some dirt, or more accurately mud, left on the roots. In this case, I drop the whole plant into a tub of water and gently bounce it up and down and swish it back and forth through the water to wash off the soil. If there is a large amount of dirt, I leave the plant in the water for 10 or 20 minutes (or sometimes a day or two if I get distracted) to let the soil loosen, then bounce it and swish it gently to wash the soil off. On really large hostas you may have to tease the larger roots loose from the center, then dunk the plant again.

    I realize that this may sound like a lot of work, but it's really doesn't take any more time than any other method, and it's much easier on the plants. Most hostas will respond to this method by eliminating the "sleep" year so often seen after a plant is divided and transplanted, which for me makes it well worth any extra effort.

    I know it is considered standard practice, but I really hate getting hostas in the mail that have nice, clean white roots. This usually means that some well intentioned person has fire hosed the roots to get all the dirt off. These are the hostas that do the sleep/creep/leap routine in the garden. Why? Because along with the dirt, all the tiny, hairlike fine roots have been washed right off the larger roots, and often the surface of the surviving roots will be damaged as well. The hosta will regrow these roots, but frankly I'd prefer to have my new hostas spend their energy developing into a mature plant rather than replacing lost roots.

    When I ship hostas, I never rinse the roots unless I'm digging in wet soil and it's absolutely necessary. I dig the plant carefully, shake off any excess dirt, divide as necessary, then wrap the roots in dampened newspaper and surround the root mass with a plastic bag. I'm sure some people are dismayed to receive a hosta with dirty roots, but they are delighted when they see how well the plant does in the garden.

    Another advantage to this method is that it makes dividing most hostas extremely easy--with the root system loosened and dirt free, you can see exactly where the natural divisions are and separate accordingly. Some varieties will literally fall into single divisions, some will have to have a bit of crown cut to separate the divisions, then the roots can be gently coaxed apart. Some will require more major cutting of the crown if the variety is one that grows a thick, compact crown, but in all cases the roots themselves can be gently teased apart after the crown is cut.

    Hostas will, as has been pointed out, take a lot of abuse and still survive. But with a bit of extra care in the handling of the plants, they will do more than just survive, they will thrive. It has been my experience that I enjoy my plants more when they are thriving.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    dhaven, thank you for the details on lifting with a garden fork! My only problem now is that every fork I buy breaks within a week or two. I need to research some nicer garden shovels and forks.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The ideal shovel for working with hostas is called a "posthole shovel." The blade is long and narrow... lets you get way down and under the root ball. It also allows for "shovel division" of crowns with a lot more precision.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have found the posthole shovel type the best for dividing hosta. Mine is actually called a transplant shovel. It's also great for digging any rocks out of the shovel. I also bungee cord my very large hostas before digging them out. Same concept as Ken and his tape.
    Jen

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have used several types of transplant shovels, posthole shovels, trenching shovels, and even one called a perennial spade, an English variety made specifically for transplanting perennials. I still prefer the garden fork. I used to have one with a very long, padded handle, which gave great leverage and was easy on the hands. It finally bit the dust after many years of service. I could have replaced the broken handle, but the tines were bent as well--I dig a lot of large hostas that have cedar, pine, or maple roots growing through the crowns. I looked for another long handled fork, but they are no longer readily available. I tried a couple of standard shorter forks and didn't care for them, with, as Mary4b says, breakage being a major problem. Turns out I'm tough on tools, according to my local hardware store!

    Last year I came across a medium length fork produced by Fiskar, which has a mid-length shaft, about 6 to 8 inches taller than a short fork, and a hideous large orange plastic handle with good ergonomics. It is quite heavy, with much thicker tines than the ordinary fork, and the tines are triangular in shape rather than flat. It has a nice wide step platform, with heavy texturing to ensure that your foot doesn't slip. It has a heavy duty steel shaft, and it's a bit of a pain to haul around the garden because of the extra weight, but it's the best garden fork I've ever used. And best of all, I bought it at the local Menards on sale for less than $20. I liked it so well I gave one to a hosta maniac friend, and it's the only tool she uses now. She has a major hosta collection, and holds huge sales every year, so she does a lot of digging, and she too says it the best garden tool she's ever used.

    Check your local Menards if you have one, although at the store here they were sold out almost immediately and have not been restocked. A word of warning about the Fiskar tools, though--since I liked the fork so well, I bought the short shovel as well when my old one snapped, and it's not nearly as sturdy as the fork. It works well enough for cutting small roots, but you wouldn't want to do much digging with it, and it won't cut through even smallish tree roots.

    It's amazing how much difference having a really good tool can make in the garden. I simply can't dig out hostas with a shovel anymore due to some physical limitations, and the shorter forks also weren't working for me, but this new fork has given me back the ability to really work my plants without having to spend a couple of weeks flat on my back afterwards. The weight is somewhat inconvenient for carrying, but it drags perfectly well, and the extra weight actually makes it easier to use--it slides into the ground with very little effort. The wide foot rest spreads out the strain, making it much easier on the feet, ankles and knee joints. And the large, triangular tines, combined with the longer shaft, make prying a hosta out practically effort free, given the combination of weight and leverage. The orange handle is truly hideous, but it also makes it impossible to lose the thing in the garden--it definitely passes the 20 foot rule.

    There are still some very nice long handled garden forks out there, with almost all of the outstanding ones being from England. They work quite well, last practically forever, and are extremely expensive. I seriously considered spending the money to get one before I found my ugly orange fork, but no longer feel the need to do so.